Skip to content
Specialized Packaging Market Intelligence and Strategic AdvisoryPackaging Intelligence. Clearer Decisions. Stronger Growth.

SPI NewsUnited States · Packaging EPR

CalRecycle has 75 days to rule on CAA's SB 54 plan, and comments close on 13 November

CalRecycle received Circular Action Alliance’s California plan on 13 October 2026 and has 75 days to review it; the SB 54 Advisory Board meets on 6 November and public comments close on 13 November.

By the SPI teamPublished 15 min read

Every remaining step in CalRecycle's review falls within 90 days of the 13 October receipt date Unit: days after 13 Oct 2026
Every remaining step in CalRecycle's review falls within 90 days of the 13 October receipt date5 bars. Largest: 90 days in statute text, 11 Jan 2027, 90.90 days in statute text, 11 Jan 202790 days in statute text, 11 Jan 2027: 90 days after 13 Oct 202690Programme start target, 1 Jan 2027Programme start target, 1 Jan 2027: 80 days after 13 Oct 20268075 days, 27 Dec 202675 days, 27 Dec 2026: 75 days after 13 Oct 202675Public comments close, 13 Nov 2026Public comments close, 13 Nov 2026: 31 days after 13 Oct 202631Advisory Board meeting, 6 Nov 2026Advisory Board meeting, 6 Nov 2026: 24 days after 13 Oct 202624Every remaining step in CalRecycle's review falls within 90 days of the 13 October receipt date5 bars. Largest: 90 days in statute text, 11 Jan 2027, 90.90 days in statute text, 11 Jan 202790 days in statute text, 11 Jan 2027: 90 days after 13 Oct 202690Programme start target, 1 Jan 2027Programme start target, 1 Jan 2027: 80 days after 13 Oct 20268075 days, 27 Dec 202675 days, 27 Dec 2026: 75 days after 13 Oct 202675Public comments close, 13 Nov 2026Public comments close, 13 Nov 2026: 31 days after 13 Oct 202631Advisory Board meeting, 6 Nov 2026Advisory Board meeting, 6 Nov 2026: 24 days after 13 Oct 202624

Source: CalRecycle SB 54 page, consulted 23 Oct 2026; California Public Resources Code section 42051.2; SPI calculation, checked 18 Nov 2026.

Day counts are SPI's calculation from the receipt date CalRecycle gives. CalRecycle cites 75 days under its regulation; the statute text in section 42051.2 gives 90 calendar days. CalRecycle has not published a decision date.

Show the data
Every remaining step in CalRecycle's review falls within 90 days of the 13 October receipt date (days after 13 Oct 2026)
StepDays after receipt (days after 13 Oct 2026)
90 days in statute text, 11 Jan 202790
Programme start target, 1 Jan 202780
75 days, 27 Dec 202675
Public comments close, 13 Nov 202631
Advisory Board meeting, 6 Nov 202624

Key takeaways

  • CalRecycle’s SB 54 page says it received CAA’s producer responsibility plan on 13 October 2026 and has 75 days to review it for compliance under 14 CCR 18980.6.1(b)(2).
  • CalRecycle is taking public comments on the plan until 13 November 2026 at packaging@calrecycle.ca.gov, with the subject line “PRO Plan Comments”.
  • The SB 54 Advisory Board meets on 6 November 2026, 10:00 to 16:00, at CalEPA headquarters in Sacramento and online, CalRecycle’s page says.
  • Public Resources Code section 42063 gives CAA 30 calendar days to resubmit if CalRecycle disapproves, and section 42051.2 gives 12 months to meet conditions after a conditional approval.
  • SPI analysis: a decision on day 75 would land on 27 December 2026, by SPI’s calculation, leaving five days before 1 January 2027 and almost no slack if CalRecycle asks for changes.
CalRecycle has 75 days to review, the start date falls 80 days after receipt, and the mitigation fund draws USD 500 million a year from July 2027

75

Days CalRecycle has to review the plan

under 14 CCR 18980.6.1(b)(2)

CalRecycle SB 54 page

80

Days from receipt to 1 Jan 2027

13 Oct 2026 to 1 Jan 2027, by SPI's calculation

SPI calculation

500

Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund

USD million a year for ten years, from July 2027

CalEPA

Source: CalRecycle SB 54 page, consulted 23 Oct 2026; CalEPA SB 54 Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund page; SPI calculation, checked 18 Nov 2026.

CalRecycle received Circular Action Alliance’s producer responsibility plan on 13 October 2026 and has 75 days to review it, the department’s SB 54 programme page says, with public comments open until 13 November.

For a board or a buyer, the next ten weeks decide whether California’s packaging fees become binding before the 1 January 2027 start date that Circular Action Alliance (CAA) is working towards. CalRecycle gives no decision date. Counted from the 13 October receipt date, the 75 days end on 27 December 2026, by SPI’s calculation, five days before that start.

SPI’s report of 15 October covered what the plan contains, including CAA’s fee ranges and the comparison with Oregon and Colorado. This piece sets out what happens between now and a decision: the meeting, the comment window, the review clock, the possible outcomes and the dates that follow.

How CalRecycle reviews a producer responsibility plan

SB 54, the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act of 2022, tracked as PR-US-004, makes producers of single-use packaging and plastic food service ware fund the system that collects and recycles it. They do so through a producer responsibility organisation (PRO), and CAA is the one approved PRO. CalRecycle’s role is to approve its plan, budget and annual reports, the department’s SB 54 page says.

The plan passes through two reviewers. Section 42051.2 of the Public Resources Code, in the published text, first sends a draft to the Advisory Board, which has 60 calendar days to comment. The PRO then has 120 calendar days to revise and file the plan with CalRecycle. The statute text gives the department 90 calendar days from receipt to respond.

The regulations add a second track. CalRecycle’s Final Statement of Reasons says section 18980.6.1(a) of the regulations keeps the 60, 120 and 90 day sequence, “consistent with the timeline set forth in section 42051.2 of the PRC”. Section 18980.6.1(b) allows an “optional, alternate timeline” for a draft filed by 15 June 2026, subject to conditions in (b)(1) and (b)(2).

CAA’s draft reached the Advisory Board on 15 June 2026, the board’s page says, which places the plan on that alternate track. CalRecycle now cites (b)(2) as the source of its 75 days. SPI has not yet confirmed the wording of 18980.6.1(b)(2) itself, including the exact event from which the 75 days run, in the final regulation text.

Those regulations are recent. The Office of Administrative Law approved the permanent SB 54 regulations on 1 May 2026 and they took effect on filing with the Secretary of State, CalRecycle’s public notice of 12 May 2026 says. The department’s rulemaking page carries the approved text and the Final Statement of Reasons, which together set the procedure CalRecycle is now running for the first time3.

The plan review runs on fixed windows, from 30 days to resubmit after a refusal to 120 days to revise a draft Unit: calendar days
The plan review runs on fixed windows, from 30 days to resubmit after a refusal to 120 days to revise a draft6 bars. Largest: PRO revises after board comments, PRC 42051.2(b)(1), 120.PRO revises after board comments, PRC42051.2(b)(1)PRO revises after board comments, PRC 42051.2(b)(1): 120 calendar days120CalRecycle review, statute text, PRC42051.2(b)(2)CalRecycle review, statute text, PRC 42051.2(b)(2): 90 calendar days90PRO implements after approval, PRC42051.2(c)PRO implements after approval, PRC 42051.2(c): 90 calendar days90CalRecycle review, cited on its SB 54pageCalRecycle review, cited on its SB 54 page: 75 calendar days75Advisory Board comment on draft, PRC42051.2(a)Advisory Board comment on draft, PRC 42051.2(a): 60 calendar days60PRO resubmits after disapproval, PRC42063PRO resubmits after disapproval, PRC 42063: 30 calendar days30The plan review runs on fixed windows, from 30 days to resubmit after a refusal to 120 days to revise a draft6 bars. Largest: PRO revises after board comments, PRC 42051.2(b)(1), 120.PRO revises after board comments, PRC 42051.2(b)(1)PRO revises after board comments, PRC 42051.2(b)(1): 120 calendar days120CalRecycle review, statute text, PRC 42051.2(b)(2)CalRecycle review, statute text, PRC 42051.2(b)(2): 90 calendar days90PRO implements after approval, PRC 42051.2(c)PRO implements after approval, PRC 42051.2(c): 90 calendar days90CalRecycle review, cited on its SB 54 pageCalRecycle review, cited on its SB 54 page: 75 calendar days75Advisory Board comment on draft, PRC 42051.2(a)Advisory Board comment on draft, PRC 42051.2(a): 60 calendar days60PRO resubmits after disapproval, PRC 42063PRO resubmits after disapproval, PRC 42063: 30 calendar days30

Source: California Public Resources Code sections 42051.2 and 42063; CalRecycle SB 54 page, consulted, checked 18 Nov 2026.

Statutory windows from the published code text, plus the 75-day period CalRecycle cites under 14 CCR 18980.6.1(b)(2). The 12-month period to meet conditions after a conditional approval is not shown.

Show the data
The plan review runs on fixed windows, from 30 days to resubmit after a refusal to 120 days to revise a draft (calendar days)
WindowDays (calendar days)
PRO revises after board comments, PRC 42051.2(b)(1)120
CalRecycle review, statute text, PRC 42051.2(b)(2)90
PRO implements after approval, PRC 42051.2(c)90
CalRecycle review, cited on its SB 54 page75
Advisory Board comment on draft, PRC 42051.2(a)60
PRO resubmits after disapproval, PRC 4206330

What has happened since CAA filed the plan

13 October: receipt. CalRecycle records that it received CAA’s plan on 13 October 2026, the date CAA’s release gives for the filing. The release says the plan was revised after more than 2,400 comments, and that the agency may approve, disapprove or conditionally approve it13.

14 October: first coverage of the numbers. Packaging Dive reported on 14 October that the revised plan estimates about $1.11 billion of spending in 2027, and between $7.81 billion and $13.1 billion over five years. SPI has not yet confirmed those figures in the plan document; the earlier report sets out the comparison with the June draft.

16 October: a meeting date that moved. Packaging Dive reported that the Advisory Board would discuss the revised plan at its meeting on Friday 16 October. CalRecycle’s Advisory Board page still listed a 16 October meeting at the Sierra Hearing Room when consulted on 23 October. CalRecycle’s SB 54 page lists 6 November instead, and its events calendar shows neither date. SPI has not yet confirmed whether the 16 October meeting took place or moved to 6 November.

The comment window opens. CalRecycle is now taking public comments on the plan for 31 days from receipt, to 13 November 2026, by SPI’s calculation. Comments go by email to packaging@calrecycle.ca.gov with the subject line “PRO Plan Comments”, its SB 54 page says. That is a second public round: the first, on the June draft, ran from 15 June to 14 August 2026 and went to CAA and the board2.

What the plan changed. CAA’s release lists the areas revised since June: environmental justice, reimbursement, materials strategy, Responsible End Markets, budget development and fee-setting, with the budget and fee chapters expanded. Those are the sections commenters in this second round are most likely to address, and the ones CalRecycle must test for compliance by its 75-day mark13.

6 November: the Advisory Board. CalRecycle’s SB 54 page lists an Advisory Board meeting on 6 November 2026 from 10:00 to 16:00 at CalEPA headquarters, 1001 “I” St., Sacramento, with attendance in person or online by Zoom or webcast. The room is shown as “XXXX Room (2nd floor)”, so the hearing room has not yet been named, and SPI has not yet confirmed whether the plan is on the agenda.

“CalRecycle is accepting public comments on Circular Action Alliance’s producer responsibility plan through November 13, 2026.”

CalRecycle, Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, SB 54 programme page, consulted 23 October 2026

The board’s make-up. The Advisory Board has 13 voting members and three nonvoting members, the nonvoting seats going to a retail association, a grocery association and CAA itself, its page says. Its statutory role on the plan was the 60-day written comment on the June draft2.

What has not happened. As of 23 October, CalRecycle had published no decision, no request for more information and no timeline for a decision, all options under section 42051.2(b)(2). It also gives no date for one. The 75-day mark of 27 December 2026 falls on a Sunday, by SPI’s calculation.

Four dated steps remain between receipt on 13 October and the 1 January 2027 start
  • past
  • event
  • next
Four dated steps remain between receipt on 13 October and the 1 January 2027 start10 dated items from 1 May 2026 to 1 Jan 2028.2026202720282029Today1 May 2026: Permanent SB 54 regulations approved and in effect15 Jun 2026: CAA files draft plan with the Advisory Board14 Aug 2026: Comments on the draft close13 Oct 2026: CalRecycle receives CAA's plan6 Nov 2026: Advisory Board meets in Sacramento and online13 Nov 2026: Public comments on the plan close27 Dec 2026: 75 days from receipt, by SPI's calculation1 Jan 2027: Next Covered Material Categories List due; CAA's start target; 10% source reduction target1 Jul 2027: Mitigation fund payments begin, July 20271 Jan 2028: 30% of single-use plastic recycledFour dated steps remain between receipt on 13 October and the 1 January 2027 start10 dated items from 1 May 2026 to 1 Jan 2028.2026202720282029Today1 May 2026: Permanent SB 54 regulations approved and in effect15 Jun 2026: CAA files draft plan with the Advisory Board14 Aug 2026: Comments on the draft close13 Oct 2026: CalRecycle receives CAA's plan6 Nov 2026: Advisory Board meets in Sacramento and online13 Nov 2026: Public comments on the plan close27 Dec 2026: 75 days from receipt, by SPI's calculation1 Jan 2027: Next Covered Material Categories List due; CAA's start target; 10% source reduction target1 Jul 2027: Mitigation fund payments begin, July 20271 Jan 2028: 30% of single-use plastic recycled
  1. Permanent SB 54 regulations approved and in effectpast
  2. CAA files draft plan with the Advisory Boardpast
  3. Comments on the draft closepast
  4. CalRecycle receives CAA's planevent
  5. Advisory Board meets in Sacramento and onlinenext
  6. Public comments on the plan closenext
  7. 75 days from receipt, by SPI's calculationnext
  8. Next Covered Material Categories List due; CAA's start target; 10% source reduction targetnext
  9. Mitigation fund payments begin, July 2027next
  10. 30% of single-use plastic recyclednext

Source: CalRecycle SB 54 and Advisory Board pages; CAA release, 13 Oct 2026; CalRecycle Producer Guidance; CalEPA; SPI calculation, checked 14 Oct 2026.

Show the data
Four dated steps remain between receipt on 13 October and the 1 January 2027 start
DateLabelCategoryLink
2026-05-01Permanent SB 54 regulations approved and in effectpasthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/
2026-06-15CAA files draft plan with the Advisory Boardpasthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/advisoryboard/
2026-08-14Comments on the draft closepasthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/advisoryboard/
2026-10-13CalRecycle receives CAA's planeventhttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/
2026-11-06Advisory Board meets in Sacramento and onlinenexthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/
2026-11-13Public comments on the plan closenexthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/
2026-12-2775 days from receipt, by SPI's calculationnexthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/
2027-01-01Next Covered Material Categories List due; CAA's start target; 10% source reduction targetnexthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/producerguidance/
2027-07-01Mitigation fund payments begin, July 2027nexthttps://calepa.ca.gov/programs/sb54ppmf/
2028-01-0130% of single-use plastic recyclednexthttps://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/producerguidance/

What CalRecycle can decide, and what follows each outcome

Five possible responses. Section 42051.2(b)(2) says the department “shall review the plan for compliance with this chapter” and respond by approving, disapproving or conditionally approving it, asking for more information, or setting a timeline for its decision9. Only the first three settle the plan; the last two extend the process.

Approval. If CalRecycle approves, section 42051.2(c) gives CAA 90 calendar days to implement the plan and post it on its website. A decision on 27 December 2026 would put that deadline at 27 March 2027, by SPI’s calculation.

Conditional approval. The department must say in writing which parts do not comply. CAA must meet the conditions and resubmit a revised plan within 12 months, section 42051.2(b)(3) says, and the 90-day implementation duty in (c) applies to a conditional approval too.

Disapproval. CalRecycle must explain in writing why the plan falls short, and if a resubmitted plan still falls short, “the PRO shall not be deemed in compliance with this chapter” until the department approves a plan, under section 42051.2(b)(4). Section 42063 sets the clock: CAA resubmits within 30 calendar days, and if the new version still falls short, CalRecycle directs changes and requires another resubmission within 30 days.

Enforcement. If CAA does not make the directed changes, section 42063 requires CalRecycle to treat it as out of compliance and begin enforcement under Article 5, which starts at section 4208010. SPI has not yet confirmed whether the regulations add steps on disapproval beyond the statute.

The two open-ended options. A request for more information or a timeline for the decision would leave fees unsettled past day 75. Section 42051.2(b)(2) sets no period for either in the code text, so either response could carry the decision into 2027 without a refusal9.

Only approval or conditional approval starts the 90-day implementation clock; a refusal restarts it with a 30-day resubmission
CalRecycle responseWhat the code requiresNext step for CAAExample date, by SPI's calculation
ApproveReview for compliance with the chapter, PRC 42051.2(b)(2)Implement and post the plan within 90 days, PRC 42051.2(c)27 Mar 2027
Conditionally approveWritten explanation of noncompliant parts, PRC 42051.2(b)(3)Meet conditions and resubmit within 12 months; implement within 90 days27 Dec 2027 for resubmission
DisapproveWritten explanation, PRC 42051.2(b)(4) and 42063Resubmit within 30 days; out of compliance until found compliant26 Jan 2027
Disapprove a resubmissionDirect changes, PRC 42063Resubmit within 30 days; enforcement under Article 5 if changes not made30 days after the second decision
Ask for more informationAllowed under PRC 42051.2(b)(2)Supply the informationNo period stated in the code text
Set a decision timelineAllowed under PRC 42051.2(b)(2)Wait for the stated dateNo period stated in the code text

Source: California Public Resources Code sections 42051.2 and 42063; CalRecycle SB 54 page, consulted 23 Oct 2026; SPI calculation, checked 18 Nov 2026.

Example dates assume a decision on day 75, 27 December 2026, which CalRecycle has not announced. Dates are SPI's calculation. This summarises the code text and is not legal advice.

The 75 and 90 day question. CalRecycle’s page cites 75 days under 14 CCR 18980.6.1(b)(2), while the statute text in section 42051.2 gives 90 calendar days, which from 13 October runs to 11 January 2027, by SPI’s calculation. The Final Statement of Reasons ties the 90 days to the default track in 18980.6.1(a), and CalRecycle’s own page applies the 75 days to this plan5.

Publication after approval. The duty in section 42051.2(c) to post the plan online within 90 days of approval matters for buyers as well as producers. It is the point at which the approved budget and fee schedule become a public document that customers and suppliers can price against, rather than a filed proposal9.

SPI analysis

The shorter period appears to be one of the conditions attached to the June filing track, but until SPI reads the text of (b)(2) itself, planning should treat 27 December as the earliest decision point and 11 January as an outer marker, not as legal deadlines.

Industry reaction

“CalRecycle has 75 days to review the plan for compliance under 14 CCR 18980.6.1(b)(2).”

CalRecycle, Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, SB 54 programme page, consulted 23 October 2026

The sentence is the only official statement of the review period for this plan, and it names no decision date and no start point beyond the 13 October receipt.

“By recognizing the unique challenges across different material categories, our plan creates a structured strategy that provides the time and framework to overcome complex technical hurdles while making steady, measurable progress towards SB 54’s recycling goals.”

Circular Action Alliance, chief of staff, release on the revised California plan, 13 October 2026

That phased approach is what CalRecycle now has to test against the statute’s dated targets, starting with 10% less single-use plastic by 1 January 2027, the date in CalRecycle’s producer guidance.

“The revised plan provides greater clarity on proposed investments and implementation activities and lays out a practical path toward achieving the objectives established under SB 54.”

Circular Action Alliance, California executive director, release on the revised California plan, 13 October 2026

The same release says CAA will keep working with CalRecycle and other stakeholders during the review, and that the budget and fee chapters were expanded after more than 2,400 comments on the June draft.

“Beginning in July 2027, California will receive $500 million annually over ten years from plastic producers.”

California Environmental Protection Agency, SB 54 Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund page, consulted 23 October 2026

CalEPA’s fund page puts the total at $5 billion and says the money comes from companies that produce single-use plastic packaging and foodware sold in California, a payment that follows the statute rather than the plan decision. CalEPA lists four designated agencies for the money: CalEPA itself, the California Natural Resources Agency, the Strategic Growth Council and the California Department of Justice.

SPI has not yet confirmed a published response to the October plan from producer trade bodies, recyclers, local governments or environmental groups. SPI’s earlier report carries statements from Oceana and the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors on the litigation around SB 54.

Who carries the cost while the plan is under review

Plastic packaging producers. Whatever CalRecycle decides on the plan, section 42064 of the Public Resources Code requires the PRO to pay $500 million a year into the Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund, “Commencing in the 2027 calendar year”, the code text says. CAA must recover it through a surcharge on participants that produce plastic covered material, based on market share, number of components and weight11.

Payment mechanics. The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration assesses the amount, and the surcharge is due 30 days from assessment, section 42064(b) says. CalEPA’s page says payments begin in July 2027. The section is repealed on 1 January 2037, and in 2030 the department may adjust the surcharge by regulation11.

Resin manufacturers. The PRO may collect up to $150 million a year from plastic resin manufacturers that sell to its participant producers, under section 42064(e)(2)(A). The PRO stays responsible for the full $500 million even if it collects less, section 42064(e)(2)(C) says.

Communities that receive the fund. CalEPA says 60% of the fund goes to monitoring and reducing environmental justice and public health impacts of plastics, with 75% of that share directly benefiting disadvantaged, low-income or rural communities. The other 40% goes to environmental impacts on terrestrial, aquatic and marine life and human health, half of it for those communities, in both cases “upon appropriation by the Legislature”12.

Carton producers. CalRecycle has published updated information on the collection and sortation of non-CRV cartons, gable-top and aseptic, its SB 54 page says. That information “will inform the next update to the Covered Material Categories List”, due by 1 January 20271. The current list on CalRecycle’s categories page is dated January 2026.

Independent and small producers. CalRecycle’s producer guidance lists separate routes for independent producers and small producers through its PEPRS registration system. The plan decision governs producers inside CAA’s programme; producers on the other routes have their own obligations, which this piece does not cover7.

CAA and its participants. CAA’s release says the plan directs recycling investment to areas of greatest need, including rural communities, and adds a Responsible End Markets Standard. Until CalRecycle rules, its fee schedule is a proposal; the 2027 budget figure of about $1.11 billion is reported by Packaging Dive and SPI has not yet confirmed it in the plan.

The USD 500 million mitigation fund payment is fixed in statute, while plan fees wait on CalRecycle's decision
GroupExposureFigureSource
CAA, recovered from plastic producersMitigation fund payment from 2027USD 500 million a yearPRC 42064(e)(1)
Plastic resin manufacturersOptional collection by the PROUp to USD 150 million a yearPRC 42064(e)(2)(A)
Environmental justice and public health usesShare of the fund60%, of which 75% for disadvantaged, low-income or rural communitiesCalEPA fund page
Environmental impact usesShare of the fund40%, of which 50% for those communitiesCalEPA fund page
Carton producersCategories list update informed by new carton dataBy 1 Jan 2027CalRecycle SB 54 page
Commenters on the planSecond public roundCloses 13 Nov 2026CalRecycle SB 54 page

Source: California Public Resources Code section 42064; CalEPA SB 54 Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund page; CalRecycle SB 54 and Covered Material Categories List pages; CAA release, checked 18 Nov 2026.

All amounts USD. Rows mix annual amounts, shares and dates, so they cannot be added up or ranked. The plan's budget and fee figures are left out because SPI has not yet confirmed them in the plan document.

The squeeze between day 75 and 1 January

The calendar is the constraint. CalRecycle received the plan 80 days before 1 January 2027, by SPI’s calculation, and holds 75 of them. CAA’s release says CalRecycle may approve, disapprove or conditionally approve the plan based on whether it meets state requirements for implementation by 1 January 2027, but the statute does not make that date a deadline for the decision13.

A refusal would push any approved plan into 2027. If CalRecycle disapproved on 27 December, a 30-day resubmission under section 42063 would run to 26 January 2027, by SPI’s calculation, before the department reviewed the new version. Section 42051.2(b)(4) keeps the PRO out of compliance until the plan is found compliant.

Other dates do not move with the plan. The 10% source reduction target applies from 1 January 2027 and 30% recycling from 1 January 2028, CalRecycle’s guidance says, and the mitigation fund payments begin in 2027 under section 42064. The categories list due by 1 January 2027 may also change which materials fall into which category1.

The target ladder rises quickly after that. CalRecycle’s producer guidance lists 10% less single-use plastic by 1 January 2027 and 30% recycled by 1 January 2028. It then sets 20% less and 40% recycled by 2030, and by 1 January 2032 a 25% cut, a 65% recycling rate and 100% recyclable or compostable packaging. Any month lost to a resubmission comes out of the run-up to the 2028 recycling step.

SPI analysis

The plan decision sets fees, but the targets, the fund and the categories list run on their own dates, so a late or conditional decision compresses the time producers have to price 2027 rather than delaying the obligations themselves.

How the California review compares with Oregon and Colorado

CAA is the PRO in all three states, so the earlier reviews show how long the step from approval to start has taken. In Oregon, tracked as PR-US-002, CAA filed drafts in March and September 2024 and a final draft in December 2024, and DEQ announced approval on 21 February 2025, its release says. The plan’s requirements began on 1 July 202514.

That left 130 days between DEQ’s announcement and the start, by SPI’s calculation. DEQ’s release described the approval without conditions and said service changes would ramp up over several years.

Oregon’s regulator also saw three versions of the plan before approving it: two drafts in March and September 2024 and the final draft in December 202414. California’s process has produced two, the June draft to the Advisory Board and the October plan to CalRecycle, so any third version would come only through a conditional approval or a disapproval.

In Colorado, tracked as PR-US-003, CDPHE’s executive director approved CAA’s programme plan in December 2025, and producers pay dues from January 2026, CDPHE says. The page also says producers have been barred since July 2025 from selling covered products unless they take part in the programme, and that CAA must begin implementing by summer 202615.

California’s sequence is tighter. A decision on day 75 would leave five days before CAA’s 1 January 2027 target, by SPI’s calculation, against 130 days in Oregon and about a month in Colorado. California also carries a statutory fund payment that neither of the other states has.

California's review leaves the least time between decision and start of the three CAA states
StepOregon (PR-US-002)Colorado (PR-US-003)California (PR-US-004)
RegulatorDEQCDPHECalRecycle
Final plan filedDecember 2024Not stated on CDPHE page13 Oct 2026
DecisionApproval announced 21 Feb 2025Approved December 2025Pending, 75-day review
StartPlan requirements from 1 Jul 2025Dues from January 20261 Jan 2027 target
Decision to start130 daysAbout one month5 days if decided on day 75
Statutory fund on topno datano dataUSD 500 million a year from 2027

Source: Oregon DEQ release, 21 Feb 2025; CDPHE Producer Responsibility Program page; CalRecycle SB 54 page, consulted 23 Oct 2026; CAA release, 13 Oct 2026; SPI calculation, checked 18 Nov 2026.

Different laws, regulators and programme designs. Gaps are SPI's calculation and are shown side by side for timing only; no fee or cost figures are compared or summed here.

SPI analysis

Oregon and Colorado both gave producers a full fee year to learn from before California, and CAA’s California plan is the first of its three where the regulator’s review window and the start date nearly touch.

What it means for you

SPI analysis

These points are for planning and are not legal advice; check with counsel on producer status, contract terms and how any decision applies to you.

  • Brand owners: plan 2027 California budgets on two cases, an approved plan by late December and a resubmission into late January, and add the mitigation fund surcharge to plastic lines in both.
  • Retailers: own-brand ranges can make a retailer the producer. Use the comment window to 13 November to raise questions on any plan terms that touch private label.
  • Converters: customers will ask for category-level costs once fees are final. Watch the categories list due by 1 January 2027, since a change of category changes the fee line.
  • Carton producers: CalRecycle’s new collection and sortation data on gable-top and aseptic cartons feeds the next categories list, so check where your formats may land.
  • Resin manufacturers: the PRO may collect up to $150 million a year from you under section 42064, so expect contact from CAA on the mechanics before July 2027.
  • Compliance teams: mark 6 November, 13 November, 27 December and 11 January, and record which period, 75 or 90 days, CalRecycle applies in its decision.
  • Finance teams: treat the mitigation fund as a fixed 2027 cost and the plan fees as a range until CalRecycle rules.

Follow PR-US-004 and the other US rules in the SPI Regulation Tracker for the United States, model costs in the SPI EPR & Plastic Tax Calculator, and read what CAA’s plan contains and US state packaging EPR.

What to watch next

  • 6 Nov 2026: SB 54 Advisory Board meets, 10:00 to 16:00, at CalEPA headquarters, 1001 “I” St., Sacramento, and online.
  • 13 Nov 2026: public comments on CAA’s plan close; email packaging@calrecycle.ca.gov, subject “PRO Plan Comments”.
  • 27 Dec 2026: 75 days from receipt, by SPI’s calculation; CalRecycle has given no decision date.
  • 1 Jan 2027: next Covered Material Categories List due; CAA’s start target; 10% source reduction target.
  • 11 Jan 2027: 90 calendar days from receipt under the statute text, by SPI’s calculation.
  • 26 Jan 2027: resubmission deadline if CalRecycle disapproved on 27 December, by SPI’s calculation.
  • 27 Mar 2027: implementation deadline if CalRecycle approved on 27 December, by SPI’s calculation.
  • 1 Jul 2027: mitigation fund payments begin in July 2027, CalEPA says.

FAQ

When did CalRecycle receive CAA's SB 54 plan?

CalRecycle says it received Circular Action Alliance’s producer responsibility plan on 13 October 2026. It has 75 days to review it for compliance under 14 CCR 18980.6.1(b)(2).

When will CalRecycle decide on the plan?

CalRecycle has not published a decision date. Counted from 13 October, 75 days runs to 27 December 2026, by SPI’s calculation, and the 90 days in the statute text to 11 January 2027.

How do I comment on CAA's California plan?

CalRecycle takes comments until 13 November 2026. Email packaging@calrecycle.ca.gov with the subject line “PRO Plan Comments”.

What happens if CalRecycle disapproves the plan?

Section 42063 of the Public Resources Code requires a written explanation and gives CAA 30 calendar days to resubmit. A second refusal brings directed changes and another 30-day resubmission, with enforcement if changes are not made.

When does the Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund start?

CalEPA says California will receive $500 million a year for ten years from plastic producers, beginning in July 2027. Section 42064 requires the PRO to pay it from the 2027 calendar year.

Sources

  1. CalRecycle, SB 54: Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, undated page (consulted 2026-10-23)
  2. CalRecycle, Packaging Producer Responsibility Advisory Board, undated page (consulted 2026-10-23)
  3. CalRecycle, SB 54 Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act Regulations, rulemaking page, regulations approved 1 May 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  4. CalRecycle, Final Regulation Text: Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act Regulations, approved 1 May 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  5. CalRecycle, SB 54 Regulations: Final Statement of Reasons, undated (consulted 2026-10-23)
  6. CalRecycle, Public Notice: SB 54 Permanent Regulations Final OAL Approval, 12 May 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  7. CalRecycle, Producer Guidance, updated 1 May 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  8. CalRecycle, SB 54 Covered Material Categories List, list dated January 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  9. California Public Resources Code, section 42051.2, text via california.public.law (consulted 2026-10-23)
  10. California Public Resources Code, section 42063, text via california.public.law (consulted 2026-10-23)
  11. California Public Resources Code, section 42064, text via california.public.law (consulted 2026-10-23)
  12. California Environmental Protection Agency, SB 54 Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund, undated page (consulted 2026-10-23)
  13. Circular Action Alliance, Circular Action Alliance Submits Revised California Program Plan to CalRecycle, 13 October 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  14. Oregon Department of Environmental Quality, DEQ approves Producer Responsibility Organization program plan, advances Plastic Pollution and Recycling Modernization Act, 21 February 2025 (consulted 2026-10-23)
  15. Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, Producer Responsibility Program, undated page (consulted 2026-10-23)

Secondary (context only)

  1. Packaging Dive, CAA shares revised California EPR program plan, announces CEO change, 14 October 2026 (consulted 2026-10-23)

Go deeper

More from SPI News

All articles
  1. South Africa · Packaging EPR targets

    South Africa packaging EPR targets: DFFE proposes two more years at 2026 levels and a 5% glass reuse target

    Notice 8146 would keep the year 5 targets of the paper and packaging scheme for 2 years after it commences and set a flat 5% reuse target for beverage glass; the 30-day…

    15 min read

  2. United Kingdom · Packaging EPR

    UK EPR glass exemption: glass sold to pubs leaves packaging fees in April 2027, and fees could fall 40%

    Glass drinks containers sold directly to licensed hospitality venues stop paying UK packaging EPR fees from April 2027, worth up to 6p a beer bottle and 10p a wine bottle, while a…

    14 min read

  3. United States · Packaging EPR

    SB 54 source reduction baseline: CalRecycle resets 2023 at 1.03 million tons from half of producers

    CalRecycle's updated SB 54 source reduction baseline puts 2023 plastic at 1.03 million tons and 222 billion components, drawn from 2,127 producers; comments on Circular Action Alliance's plan close today, 13 November…

    14 min read

ClosingAsk the SPI team

Ask the SPI team

What changes for your packaging next quarter?

Tell us your markets and materials. The SPI team walks you through the rules and buyer commitments that affect them.

Prefer email? Write to sales@strategicpackaginginsights.com.

Questions people bring
  1. Q1

    Which packaging rules apply to us in each market we sell in?

    We map each market's EPR, tax, ban, recycled-content, labelling and deposit rules against your materials and formats, and show which are in force, adopted or only proposed.

  2. Q2

    What could EPR fees and plastic taxes cost us next year?

    We apply published fee tables and tax rates to your tonnages and recycled content, and show the result as scenarios with every rate sourced.

  3. Q3

    Can you tell us when a rule changes?

    Yes. The free tracker alerts cover rule changes by country; a monitoring retainer adds monthly notes on what the changes mean for your portfolio.