SPI LedgerNews analysis
EPR penalties compared: daily fines in US states, turnover fines in the UK, prison in Kenya and South Africa
EPR penalties for packaging range, in each market’s own currency, from a GBP 1,000 fixed penalty in the UK and fines of up to EUR 200,000 in Germany to USD 50,000 a day per violation in California, PHP 5,000,000 to PHP 20,000,000 per offence in the Philippines, and up to four years in prison in Kenya or 15 years in South Africa.
7
Currencies in the comparison
GBP, EUR, USD, INR, PHP, KES, ZAR; none converted
SPI count, Exhibit 1
2 of 8
Laws that set prison for the EPR breach itself
Kenya (up to 4 years) and South Africa (up to 15 years)
SWMA 2022 s. 32; GN R1184 reg. 13(1)
3 of 8
Laws that tie a money penalty to the size of the breach
UK unpaid fees or turnover, India compensation, Philippines twice the cost
Exhibit 2
Source: SPI count from the penalty clauses in Exhibit 1, texts re-read 6 November 2026 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
Counts are SPI's. Currencies are kept separate throughout this piece.
This SPI Ledger piece sets the penalty clauses of eight packaging EPR laws side by side, re-read in their official or official-source texts on 6 November 2026. Each amount stays in its own currency and its own rows; SPI does not convert, sum or rank across currencies.
| Market | Rule | Headline money penalty, as the text sets it | Currency | Prison for the breach | Who enforces |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | PR-GB-002 | Fixed penalty 1,000; variable penalty for unpaid fees: higher of 20% of fees or 5% of turnover; unlimited fine on conviction in England and Wales | GBP | No | Environment Agency, NRW, SEPA, DAERA |
| Germany | PR-DE-001 | Up to 200,000, 100,000 or 10,000 per administrative offence | EUR | No | Authority named by each Land's law |
| Oregon | PR-US-002 | Up to 25,000 per day (Class 1 violation for not joining a PRO) | USD | No | Oregon DEQ |
| California | PR-US-004 | Up to 50,000 per day per violation; 25,000 cap for qualifying small entities | USD | No | CalRecycle; Attorney General |
| India | PR-IN-001 | 10,000 to 1,500,000 (15 lakh), plus 10,000 a day; environmental compensation on top | INR | No (up to 3 years for not paying a penalty) | CPCB; State Pollution Control Boards |
| Philippines | PR-PH-001 | 5,000,000 to 20,000,000 by offence, or twice the cost of recovering the shortfall | PHP | No | DENR Pollution Adjudication Board |
| Kenya | PR-KE-002 | 2,000,000 to 4,000,000 | KES | Up to 4 years | NEMA; courts |
| South Africa | PR-ZA-001 | "An appropriate fine"; no rand amount set | ZAR | Up to 15 years | DFFE; courts |
Source: Official texts re-read 6 November 2026: SI 2024/1332; VerpackDG; Oregon DEQ and ORS 468.130; PRC 42081; EPA 1986 s. 15 (Jan Vishwas text); RA 9003 s. 49(g); SWMA 2022 and L.N. 176 of 2024; GN R1184 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
SPI summary, not legal advice. Each amount is in its own currency and is not comparable across rows. Oregon and California figures are ceilings; actual penalties are set case by case. California and Oregon statute text was read on an unofficial compilation (Public.Law).
Executive summary
EPR penalties are the sanctions a packaging EPR law attaches to not registering, not reporting, not paying fees or not meeting targets. SPI re-read the penalty clauses of eight laws on 6 November 2026, one per market in the UK, Germany, India, the Philippines, Kenya and South Africa and two US states, Oregon and California. This piece compares how each law punishes, not who must comply, which is in SPI’s producer definition piece, or which law applies where, which is in EPR legislation by country.
The amounts cannot be ranked against each other, because they sit in seven currencies and in different legal forms. What can be compared is the design. Exhibit 2 sorts the eight laws into four enforcement models: per-day civil penalties (Oregon, California), a civil sanctions ladder with criminal fines behind it (UK), administrative fines in fixed bands (Germany, and the Philippines with a cost multiple), and court-imposed fines with prison (Kenya, South Africa). India mixes a statutory penalty with environmental compensation tied to the missed target.
Three laws scale the money penalty to the size of the breach. In the UK, unpaid disposal fees trigger a variable penalty of the higher of 20% of the unpaid fees or 5% of reported turnover. In the Philippines, a missed target costs the fine band or twice the cost of recovering the shortfall, whichever is higher. In India, compensation is levied on the unmet quantity and part is refunded if the gap is closed within three years.
SPI analysis
The money is rarely the sharpest tool. Each law also gives the regulator a non-money sanction that stops trade: suspension of an Indian registration for one year, automatic suspension of a Philippine business permit on a third offence, a bar on placing products on the Kenyan market, revocation of a South African registration, and Germany’s ban on distributors handling packaging of unregistered producers (Exhibit 9). For a brand, those measures decide the business risk more than the fine ceiling.
SPI has found no published penalty decision against a packaging producer under any of the eight penalty clauses as of 6 November 2026. The record is still thin, so the texts, not case law, are the guide.
Key findings
- Of the eight laws, only Kenya and South Africa set a prison term for the EPR breach itself: up to four years under section 32 of Kenya’s Sustainable Waste Management Act, 2022, and up to 15 years under regulation 13(1) of South Africa’s GN R1184 (Exhibit 1).
- The UK’s fixed monetary penalty is GBP 1,000 (Schedule 13, para 2(1)), and it rises by 50% if unpaid after 56 days; unpaid disposal fees attract the higher of 20% of fees or 5% of turnover, or 2% of group turnover for a group registration (Exhibit 3).
- By SPI’s count, Germany’s section 66 VerpackDG lists 66 numbered offences: 10 carry fines of up to EUR 200,000, 23 up to EUR 100,000 and 33 up to EUR 10,000, and the 37 PPWR offences in section 66(2) apply only from 12 February 2027 (Exhibit 4).
- California’s ceiling is USD 50,000 per day per violation, but penalties start accruing only 30 calendar days after notice, and a corrective action plan of up to 24 months can stop them (Exhibit 5).
- By SPI’s calculation, the Philippines’ twice-the-cost alternative overtakes the first-offence ceiling of PHP 10,000,000 once recovering the shortfall would cost more than PHP 5,000,000 (Exhibit 11).
- SPI calculation: a California violation left for 90 days of accrual reaches a USD 4,500,000 ceiling; an Indian contravention continuing for 90 days reaches an INR 2,400,000 ceiling under section 15 (Exhibit 10, each in its own currency).
EPR penalties: four enforcement models
The first question about any EPR penalty is who imposes it. A civil or administrative penalty is set by the regulator and can be appealed; a criminal fine needs a prosecution and a court. Exhibit 2 places the eight laws by that test and by whether the amount scales with the breach.
| Model | How the penalty is imposed | Amount scales with the breach? | Laws |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per-day civil penalty | Regulator issues a notice and sets a penalty up to a daily ceiling | By days and violations | Oregon (ORS 468.130); California (PRC 42081) |
| Civil sanctions ladder with criminal fines behind | Regulator imposes fixed or variable penalties; prosecution for offences | Yes, for unpaid fees | United Kingdom (SI 2024/1332) |
| Administrative fines in fixed bands | Authority fines up to a band set by the offence | No, except the Philippine cost multiple | Germany (section 66 VerpackDG); Philippines (RA 9003 s. 49(g)) |
| Penalty plus target compensation | Adjudicating officer penalty; regulator levies compensation on the shortfall | Yes, compensation by unmet quantity | India (EPA s. 15; Schedule II clause 9) |
| Court fine and prison | Prosecution; the court sets the fine and any prison term | No | Kenya (SWMA s. 32); South Africa (GN R1184 reg. 13) |
Source: SPI framework from the penalty clauses in Exhibit 1 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
SPI framework, not a legal classification. A law is placed by its main money penalty for producers. India sits in two cells because its statutory penalty and its environmental compensation work separately.
The models track the regulators’ tools. Oregon DEQ and CalRecycle run civil penalty systems that already apply to other environmental duties; ORS 468.130 is Oregon’s general civil penalty schedule, which caps any penalty at USD 25,000 per day. The UK built a civil sanctions schedule into SI 2024/1332 itself. Germany uses the federal Ordnungswidrigkeiten law, with section 66(4) VerpackDG naming the authority under each Land’s law. Kenya and South Africa write offences into regulations and leave the fine to the court.
SPI analysis
The model predicts speed. A per-day or fixed civil penalty can be issued in weeks after a notice; a prosecution in Kenya or South Africa takes a court process. That is one reason both African regulators also hold administrative powers, revocation and market bars, that act faster than a conviction.
United Kingdom: a GBP 1,000 fixed penalty and a turnover test
The UK’s packaging EPR law is The Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging and Packaging Waste) Regulations 2024, SI 2024/1332, tracked as PR-GB-002 on the United Kingdom tracker page. Regulation 115 lists the producer offences: trading as a producer without being registered, missing the registration date, failing to keep records, failing to report data or to report it on time, and, for producers under regulation 25(2), failing the recycling obligation, the evidence duty or the certificate of compliance. A registered producer that breaks the information conditions in regulation 31(b) or (c) also commits an offence.
Regulation 119 sets the criminal penalty: a fine on conviction on indictment; on summary conviction a fine in England and Wales, and a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum in Scotland or Northern Ireland. No prison term is provided. SPI has not yet confirmed the current statutory maximum figure in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
| Sanction | Amount or term | Trigger | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed monetary penalty | GBP 1,000 | Offences such as record-keeping breaches | Schedule 13, para 2(1) |
| Late payment of a fixed penalty | Increase of 50% | Unpaid after 56 days with no appeal | Schedule 13, para 8(2) |
| Variable penalty, single producer | Higher of 20% of unpaid fees or 5% of reported turnover | Disposal and administration fees unpaid 50 days after the due date | Schedule 13, para 10(3) |
| Variable penalty, group registration | Higher of 20% of unpaid fees or 2% of group turnover | Same, for a holding company | Schedule 13, para 10(4) |
| Variable penalty for other offences | Up to the maximum fine for that offence, if any | Offences under regulations 115 to 118 | Schedule 13, para 10(2) |
| Fine on conviction, England and Wales | Unlimited | Offences under regulations 115 to 118 | Regulation 119 |
| Fine on summary conviction, Scotland and Northern Ireland | Up to the statutory maximum | Same | Regulation 119(b)(ii) |
Source: legislation.gov.uk: SI 2024/1332, regulations 115 and 119 and Schedule 13, as made, re-read 6 November 2026 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
GBP only. Regulations read as made; later amending instruments not reviewed. Notice of intent periods are 28 days for both fixed and variable penalties.
The process is written into the Schedule. Before a fixed or variable penalty, the regulator serves a notice of intent, and the producer has 28 days from receipt to make representations (paras 3 and 11). No criminal proceedings for the same act may start within those 28 days (paras 9 and 16), and a variable penalty notice gives at least 28 days to pay (para 14). SPI’s UK detail, including year 2 fees, is in SPI’s UK packaging regulations piece.
In practice: the Environment Agency’s 2026 monitoring plan.
The Environment Agency’s packaging monitoring plan for England, published on 22 December 2025, describes an intelligence-led, risk-based approach. Its minimum monitoring covers registered producers and online marketplaces, approved compliance schemes and accredited reprocessors and exporters, and it includes chasing late or missing submissions and finding unregistered producers. The plan says the agency first works with a business to bring it into compliance and uses enforcement powers when that is not enough. It names civil sanctions as one of the funding sources for enforcement but gives no target number of inspections.
Germany: three VerpackDG fine bands and a February 2027 start
Germany’s VerpackDG has applied since 12 August 2026, alongside Regulation (EU) 2025/40, and is tracked as PR-DE-001 on the Germany tracker page. Section 66 sets the fines. Section 66(1) lists 29 offences against the VerpackDG itself, and section 66(2) lists 37 offences against the EU Regulation. Section 66(3) assigns each to one of three ceilings, and section 66(4) makes the competent authority the one named by Land law. SPI’s German packaging law piece covers the wider duties.
| Maximum fine (EUR) | Items in section 66(1) | Items in section 66(2) | Offences | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 200,000 | No. 3, 4, 10, 17, 18 | No. 23, 25, 26, 29, 32 | 10 | Not joining a system (s. 7(1)); running a system or organisation without approval; PPWR reuse targets (Art. 29) |
| 100,000 | No. 1, 5, 6, 8, 9, 11 to 16, 19 to 23, 25, 27 | No. 28, 33, 35 to 37 | 23 | Not registering, or registering late or incompletely (s. 6(1)) |
| 10,000 | The other 6 items | The other 27 items | 33 | Other duties in sections 66(1) and (2) |
Source: gesetze-im-internet.de: VerpackDG, section 66(1) to (4) and section 68(17), re-read 6 November 2026 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
EUR only. Counts of numbered items are SPI's. Section 66(2) applies only from 12 February 2027 (section 68(17)). Examples are SPI's plain-English summaries of the items.
The bands follow the money. The top band covers not joining a dual system, offering prohibited fees or benefits under section 7(6), running a system or other producer responsibility organisation without approval, and failing to collect or send for recovery the packaging named in sections 40 and 41. Not registering in LUCID sits one band lower, at up to EUR 100,000.
The SPI tracker data for PR-DE-001 records the section 66 amounts as not yet confirmed; the text on gesetze-im-internet.de, re-read on 6 November 2026, sets them as shown in Exhibit 4. A second route runs outside the fine schedule: distributors and fulfilment service providers may not handle packaging of producers that are not properly registered (SPI tracker data, PR-DE-001).
SPI analysis
The date in section 68(17) is the one to plan around. Until 12 February 2027 only the 29 national offences can be fined; after it, the PPWR reuse and refill duties in Articles 29, 32 and 33 enter the EUR 200,000 band. SPI’s reuse targets piece explains those duties.
US states: per-day civil penalties in Oregon and California
The two US laws in this comparison fine by the day. Oregon’s Recycling Modernization Act, PR-US-002, and California’s SB 54, PR-US-004, both set ceilings that multiply with time. SPI’s US state EPR overview covers the other states.
| Item | Oregon | California |
|---|---|---|
| Ceiling | USD 25,000 per day | USD 50,000 per day per violation |
| Reduced ceiling | None stated | USD 25,000 per day for entities meeting the small business criteria of PRC 42060(a)(5) |
| First non-egregious offence | Not stated | Department considers up to USD 25,000 per day (42081(c)(3)) |
| When accrual starts | Not stated on the DEQ page | 30 calendar days after notice (42081(a)(3)) |
| Way out before a penalty | Not stated on the DEQ page | Corrective action plan up to 24 months, extendable by 12 (42081(b)) |
| Where penalties go | Not stated on the DEQ page | Circular Economy Penalty Account (42081(a)(4)) |
| Second route | Not stated | Unfair Competition Law, up to USD 2,500 per violation (Attorney General) |
Source: Oregon DEQ, Producers of Covered Products; ORS 468.130 and PRC 42081 and 42060 (Public.Law, unofficial compilation); California Attorney General advisory, 2 December 2025; all re-read 6 November 2026 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
USD only. Ceilings, not expected penalties. SPI has not yet confirmed the Oregon Administrative Rule that classifies non-membership as Class 1, or the California text against leginfo.legislature.ca.gov.
Oregon. DEQ’s producers page says failing to register or become a member of a producer responsibility organization is a Class 1 violation that can result in fines of up to USD 25,000 per day. ORS 468.130(1), the state’s civil penalty schedule, sets the same USD 25,000 per day as the general ceiling. The page, re-read on 6 November 2026, also says producers that have not reported 2024 or 2025 supply data, or not paid 2025 or 2026 fees, to the Circular Action Alliance are likely out of compliance. SPI’s Oregon ORS 459A piece sets out DEQ’s other tools, including plan revocation and a sales ban.
California. Public Resources Code section 42081(a)(1) lets CalRecycle issue a notice of violation and impose an administrative civil penalty of up to USD 50,000 per day per violation. For a producer or PRO, a violation of section 42050 is counted by brand name, package or product line, form, covered material category and size, so one shortfall can be several violations. Subdivision (c) lists eight factors the department must weigh, from gravity and intent to the size and economic condition of the producer. The text was read on an unofficial compilation; SPI has not yet confirmed it against the legislature’s site.
In practice: California’s EPS foodware advisory.
On 2 December 2025 the Attorney General wrote to makers and brand owners of expanded polystyrene food service ware about SB 54. The advisory says SB 54 authorises administrative civil penalties of up to USD 50,000 per day per violation and that violations of SB 54 may be enforced under the Unfair Competition Law, which allows civil penalties of up to USD 2,500 for each violation. It is the clearest public statement so far that the state will pair the two routes.
India: a statutory penalty plus environmental compensation
India’s packaging EPR sits in Schedule II of the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016, tracked as PR-IN-001 on the India tracker page. It works with two separate money tools: environmental compensation for missed targets, set under the Schedule, and the general penalty for contravening rules under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
| Tool | Amount or effect | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Environmental compensation | Levied on missed EPR targets under the polluter pays principle; no rupee rate in Schedule II | Schedule II, clauses 9.1 and 9.2 |
| Carry-forward | Unmet quantity carries forward for three years; paying does not discharge it | Clause 9.5 |
| Refund if the gap closes | 75% within one year, 60% within two, 40% within three; then retained | Clause 9.5 |
| Penalty for contravening the Rules | INR 10,000 to INR 1,500,000, plus INR 10,000 a day while it continues | EPA s. 15 (Jan Vishwas text) |
| Penalty for contravention by companies | INR 100,000 to INR 1,500,000, plus INR 100,000 a day while it continues | EPA s. 15A (Jan Vishwas Bill text) |
| Not paying a penalty within 90 days | Imprisonment up to three years, or a fine up to twice the penalty, or both | EPA s. 15F (Jan Vishwas Bill text) |
| Registration | Suspended for one year after a hearing for false information or non-compliance | Clause 6.4 |
Source: CPCB reply in NGT OA 22 of 2022 annexing G.S.R. 133(E) of 16 February 2022 (Hindi text, SPI translation); Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Bill as passed by the Lok Sabha, EPA entry; re-read 6 November 2026 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
INR only. One lakh is 100,000. Schedule II clauses translated by SPI from the Hindi annexure; SPI has not yet confirmed them against the official English gazette text. Section 15 and 15A wording is from the Bill as passed by the Lok Sabha; SPI has not yet confirmed the enacted text or its commencement date.
The compensation rate itself is set in CPCB guidelines under clause 9.2, not in the Schedule, and SPI has not yet confirmed the current rupee rates. CPCB levies compensation on entities operating in more than two states or union territories, and the State Boards and Pollution Control Committees on the rest (clauses 9.3 and 9.4).
The Jan Vishwas text matters for companies. SPI’s tracker data for PR-IN-001 cites the section 15 penalty, INR 10,000 to INR 15 lakh plus INR 10,000 a day. The Bill as passed by the Lok Sabha also inserts a section 15A for contraventions by companies, with a floor of INR 1 lakh and an additional INR 1 lakh a day, and a section 15D appeal to the National Green Tribunal within 60 days on deposit of 10% of the penalty. SPI has not yet confirmed which of the two provisions an adjudicating officer would apply to a brand owner. SPI’s India 2026 rules piece covers the 2026 targets.
The Philippines: PHP fine bands or twice the recovery cost
RA 11898, the Extended Producer Responsibility Act of 2022, added a paragraph (g) to Section 49 of RA 9003. It is tracked as PR-PH-001 on the Philippines tracker page. It covers an obliged enterprise that fails to register under Section 44-E or to comply with Section 44-F, and it rises with each offence.
The cost alternative is what makes the Philippine clause unusual. For a missed target under Section 44-F, the enterprise pays the same fines or a fine twice the cost of recovery and diversion of the footprint or its shortfall, whichever is higher. The fine band is therefore a floor for a target breach, not a ceiling. SPI’s tracker data adds that the National Ecology Center may require semi-annual reports on recovery costs, which the Pollution Adjudication Board can use as a basis for fines (DAO 2023-02, Sec. 9.2.4).
The 60% recovery target for the 2025 footprint falls due on 31 December 2026 (SPI tracker data, PR-PH-001). SPI’s RA 11898 piece covers the footprint rules and the reported penalty resolutions of the Pollution Adjudication Board.
Kenya and South Africa: court fines and prison terms
Kenya and South Africa are the two laws in this set where a conviction can mean prison. Both also give the regulator administrative powers that act before any court. SPI’s Kenya piece and South Africa piece go through each in depth; Exhibit 8 keeps the two currencies in separate rows.
| Market | Sanction | Amount or term | Currency | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kenya | General penalty for offences under the regulations | Fine of 2,000,000 to 4,000,000, or up to 4 years, or both | KES | SWMA s. 32, applied by reg. 22 |
| Kenya | Obstructing or giving false information to the Authority | Fine up to 1,000,000, or up to 5 years, or both | KES | SWMA s. 27(4) |
| Kenya | Cost order on conviction of a scheme or PRO | Cost of managing the unmet obligation | KES | Reg. 21(2) |
| Kenya | Administrative | Revocation or suspension of registration or licence; bar on placing the product on the market | no data | Regs. 13 and 15 |
| South Africa | Penalty on conviction | Up to 15 years, an appropriate fine, or both | ZAR | Reg. 13(1) |
| South Africa | Administrative, producer | Registration revoked and/or compelled to join another scheme | no data | Reg. 13(2) |
| South Africa | Administrative, PRO | Registration revoked | no data | Reg. 13(3) |
Source: NEMA: SWMA 2022, ss. 27(4), 31 and 32; L.N. 176 of 2024, regs. 13, 15, 20 to 22; GN R1184 of 2020 as amended to GN 5520 of 2024, regs. 12 and 13; re-read 6 November 2026 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
KES and ZAR rows are separate and not comparable. Kenya's Act read in NEMA's PDF copy; later amendments to sections 27, 31 or 32 not checked.
Kenya. Regulation 21 of L.N. 176 of 2024 makes five things offences: a scheme or PRO wilfully failing an obligation, placing a product on the market for a producer not in NEMA’s register, giving false information on quantities, and being a free rider, a producer outside a PRO that does not meet its own obligations. Regulation 22 applies the Act’s section 32 penalty to all of them. Appeals against NEMA decisions go to the National Environment Tribunal; section 31 of the Act sets a sixty-day window. Kenya is tracked as PR-KE-002 on the Kenya tracker page.
South Africa. Regulation 12 of GN R1184, in the version consolidated to GN 5520 of 2024, makes it an offence for a person or a PRO to breach regulations 4(1) and (2), 5, 5A, 5B, 6, 7(1) to (7), 7A, 8(1)(a) to (e), 8(2)(a) to (e), 9(3), 10 or 11. Regulation 13(1) sets imprisonment of up to 15 years, an appropriate fine, or both; the regulations name no rand amount. South Africa is tracked as PR-ZA-001 on the South Africa tracker page.
In practice: NEMA’s 2023 compliance notice.
NEMA’s public notice of 30 August 2023, reported by the Kenya News Agency, gave producers 60 days to submit their EPR plans under the Sustainable Waste Management Act and said inspection and enforcement had started. It came more than a year before L.N. 176 of 2024 set the detailed offences, which shows the agency using the Act’s section 13 duty on its own.
Beyond fines: sanctions that stop trade
Six of the eight laws have at least one sanction that does not cost money directly but can stop a product being sold. Exhibit 9 lists them. None has a currency, so they can be compared directly.
| Market | Non-money sanction | Stops trade? | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | Publication of enforcement action | SPI has not yet confirmed a market bar | SI 2024/1332, reg. 126 (SPI tracker data) |
| Germany | Distributors and fulfilment providers may not handle packaging of unregistered producers; confiscation under section 67 | Yes | VerpackDG ss. 13 and 67 (SPI tracker data) |
| Oregon | Plan suspension or revocation; court action to prohibit sale of a covered product | Yes | ORS 459A.962, as summarised in SPI's Oregon piece |
| California | Corrective action plan instead of penalty | No, it pauses penalties | PRC 42081(b) |
| India | Registration suspended for one year after a hearing | Yes | Schedule II, clause 6.4 |
| Philippines | Automatic suspension of business permit on a third offence | Yes | RA 9003 s. 49(g)(3) |
| Kenya | Bar on placing affected product and packaging on the market; licence revocation | Yes | L.N. 176 of 2024, reg. 15 |
| South Africa | Registration revoked; producer compelled into another scheme | Yes | GN R1184, reg. 13(2) |
Source: Texts in Exhibit 1, re-read 6 November 2026; SPI tracker data for Germany section 13 and Oregon (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
SPI summary, not legal advice. 'Stops trade' means the sanction can prevent the producer's packaged products being placed on or handled in the market. SPI has not yet confirmed whether SI 2024/1332 gives UK regulators a market bar for producers.
SPI analysis
For a brand owner, the trade stoppers sit higher on the risk register than the fines. A Philippine third offence suspends the business permit itself, and Kenya’s regulation 15 lets NEMA bar a product from the market. Germany’s handling ban works without any authority acting at all: a marketplace or fulfilment provider that checks LUCID will refuse an unregistered producer’s goods.
What triggers an EPR penalty: registration, data, fees or targets
The eight laws do not punish the same failures. Some reach every step of the producer cycle; others name only one or two. The table below maps four common breaches against the texts SPI re-read, with “not stated” where the provision cited does not name the breach.
| Breach | United Kingdom | Germany | Oregon | California | India | Philippines | Kenya | South Africa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Not registering | Offence, reg. 115(1)(a) and (b) | Fine up to EUR 100,000, s. 66(1) no. 1 | Class 1 violation | Penalty under 42081 | Registration rules; s. 15 penalty | Fine band, s. 49(g) | Offence, reg. 21(3) for those placing products | Offence, reg. 12 (reg. 4) |
| Not joining a scheme or PRO | Not stated | Fine up to EUR 200,000, s. 66(1) no. 3 | Class 1 violation | Penalty under 42081 | Not applicable, no PRO model | Not stated | Free rider offence, reg. 21(5) | Compelled to join another scheme, reg. 13(2) |
| Late or false data | Offence, reg. 115(1)(c) to (e) | Within the s. 66 bands | Not stated on the DEQ page | Penalty under 42081 | Registration suspension, clause 6.4 | Falsification named in s. 49(g) (SPI tracker data) | False quantities offence, reg. 21(4) | Offence, reg. 12 (reg. 8) |
| Unpaid fees | Variable penalty, Sch. 13 para 10(3) | Not stated | Likely out of compliance, per DEQ | Penalty under 42081 | Not applicable | Not applicable | Treated as non-compliant (SPI Kenya piece) | Offence, reg. 12 (reg. 7) |
| Missed target | Offence, reg. 115(3)(a) | Fine up to EUR 200,000 for collection and recovery duties, s. 66(1) no. 17 and 18 | Not stated | Penalty under 42081 | Environmental compensation, clause 9 | Band or twice the cost, s. 49(g) | Cost order on conviction, reg. 21(2) | Not stated as a separate offence |
Two patterns stand out. First, registration is a punishable breach everywhere, which is why SPI’s EPR legislation hub lists the register for each market. Second, only the UK, India and the Philippines attach a dedicated money rule to the target itself; elsewhere a missed target is folded into a general offence or, in Germany, into the duties of the systems that collect on producers’ behalf.
Due process: notices, grace periods and appeals
The route from breach to penalty differs as much as the amounts. The UK requires a notice of intent and gives 28 days for representations before a fixed or variable penalty, and bars criminal proceedings for the same act during those 28 days (Schedule 13, paras 3, 9, 11 and 16). California makes penalties accrue only 30 calendar days after notice, and lets the department accept a corrective action plan of up to 24 months instead of a penalty, extendable by 12 months in certain circumstances (PRC 42081(a)(3) and (b)).
India’s Jan Vishwas text moves the general penalty from the criminal courts to an adjudicating officer of at least Joint Secretary rank in the central government, or a state Secretary, with an appeal to the National Green Tribunal within 60 days, on deposit of 10% of the penalty (sections 15C and 15D of the Bill text). Penalties are credited to an Environmental Protection Fund under section 16 of that text. SPI has not yet confirmed whether that fund has been notified.
In Kenya, appeals against NEMA’s decisions go to the National Environment Tribunal under section 31 of the Act, which sets a sixty-day window; regulation 20 of L.N. 176 of 2024 points to section 31 without its own period. In the Philippines, the Pollution Adjudication Board of the DENR hears violations under Section 49 of RA 9003 (SPI tracker data, PR-PH-001). Germany’s administrative fines follow the federal law on administrative offences, with the Land authority as the body that imposes them (section 66(4) VerpackDG). South Africa’s regulations route offences to the courts and leave revocation and compulsory transfer with the Department (regs. 13(2) and (3)).
SPI analysis
The grace periods are short and fixed. A producer that receives a UK notice of intent or a California notice of violation has about four weeks before the next step, so the time to assemble registration and reporting evidence is before any notice arrives.
The enforcement record so far
The texts are new and the published record is thin. SPI’s tracker data, data as of 14 October 2026, and the sources re-read on 6 November 2026 show the following.
- United Kingdom: regulation 126 allows publication of enforcement action, but no notice under SI 2024/1332 was known to SPI by mid-October 2026 (SPI tracker data, PR-GB-002).
- Germany: SPI has found no published fine under the VerpackDG since it took effect on 12 August 2026 (SPI tracker data, PR-DE-001).
- Oregon: DEQ says producers that have not reported 2024 or 2025 supply data or paid 2025 or 2026 fees are likely out of compliance; SPI has not identified a published penalty against a producer.
- California: the Attorney General’s advisory of 2 December 2025 is the main public enforcement step so far, aimed at EPS food service ware.
- India: CPCB’s April 2025 reply in NGT OA 1179 of 2024 defends its rules for multilayer packaging before the tribunal (SPI tracker data, PR-IN-001); SPI has not yet confirmed the total compensation levied.
- Philippines: SPI has not found a published Pollution Adjudication Board decision under Section 49(g) (SPI tracker data, PR-PH-001).
- Kenya and South Africa: SPI has not confirmed any published conviction under L.N. 176 of 2024 or GN R1184.
Scenarios: how per-day penalties build up
Two of the eight laws, California and India, write a daily rate into the penalty, and Oregon’s ceiling is set by the day. Exhibit 10 shows how far the ceilings climb over 30, 90 and 365 days of one continuing violation. Each currency has its own rows, and the rows must not be read against each other.
| Law | Currency | Rate | 30 days | 90 days | 365 days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oregon, Class 1 | USD | 25,000 a day | 750,000 | 2,250,000 | 9,125,000 |
| California, standard ceiling | USD | 50,000 a day | 1,500,000 | 4,500,000 | 18,250,000 |
| California, small entity or first non-egregious offence | USD | 25,000 a day | 750,000 | 2,250,000 | 9,125,000 |
| India, section 15 | INR | 1,500,000 plus 10,000 a day | 1,800,000 | 2,400,000 | 5,150,000 |
| India, section 15A (companies, Bill text) | INR | 1,500,000 plus 100,000 a day | 4,500,000 | 10,500,000 | 38,000,000 |
Source: SPI calculation from Oregon DEQ and ORS 468.130; PRC 42081(a) and (c); EPA 1986 ss. 15 and 15A (Jan Vishwas Bill text) (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
SPI calculation. Ceilings, not expected penalties. Assumes one violation and continuous days of accrual; for California the days count from the start of accrual, 30 days after notice. India rows add the daily amount to the maximum single penalty of INR 1,500,000; section 15A is from the Bill text and not yet confirmed as enacted. Rows in different currencies are not comparable.
The ceilings are theoretical. California’s statute requires the department to weigh eight factors, including prompt correction and the producer’s size, and the Oregon DEQ sets actual penalties through its penalty rules. The calculation shows the shape: within one currency, a California violation left for a year reaches by SPI’s calculation twice the Oregon ceiling, and India’s companies provision, if it applies, multiplies the daily element tenfold compared with section 15.
When the penalty scales with the breach
The UK and the Philippines both use a “whichever is higher” test, so the size of the business or of the shortfall decides which leg applies. Exhibit 11 works through three cases for each, with SPI’s assumed inputs, one currency per block.
| Case | Currency | Assumed input | Fee or cost leg | Turnover or band leg | Higher leg applies |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UK, single producer | GBP | Turnover 5,000,000; unpaid fees 100,000 | 20,000 | 250,000 | 250,000 |
| UK, single producer | GBP | Turnover 2,000,000; unpaid fees 600,000 | 120,000 | 100,000 | 120,000 |
| UK, group registration | GBP | Group turnover 500,000,000; unpaid fees 3,000,000 | 600,000 | 10,000,000 | 10,000,000 |
| Philippines, first offence, missed target | PHP | Shortfall recovery cost 2,000,000 | 4,000,000 | 5,000,000 to 10,000,000 | Band, 5,000,000 to 10,000,000 |
| Philippines, first offence, missed target | PHP | Shortfall recovery cost 8,000,000 | 16,000,000 | 5,000,000 to 10,000,000 | 16,000,000 |
| Philippines, first offence, missed target | PHP | Shortfall recovery cost 25,000,000 | 50,000,000 | 5,000,000 to 10,000,000 | 50,000,000 |
Source: SPI calculation from SI 2024/1332, Schedule 13, para 10(3) and (4), and RA 9003 s. 49(g) as inserted by RA 11898 (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
SPI calculation with assumed inputs, not company data. UK: penalty is the higher of 20% of fees unpaid 50 days after the due date or 5% of reported turnover (2% of group turnover for a group registration). Philippines: fine is the offence band or twice the cost of recovery and diversion of the shortfall, whichever is higher; first-offence band PHP 5,000,000 to PHP 10,000,000. GBP and PHP rows are not comparable.
The UK arithmetic is simple: 20% of fees beats 5% of turnover only when the unpaid fees exceed a quarter of turnover, or for a group, when they exceed a tenth of group turnover, by SPI’s calculation. For most producers the turnover leg will apply, which means the variable penalty for unpaid fees is set more by the size of the company than by the size of the debt.
The Philippine arithmetic runs the other way. By SPI’s calculation, twice the recovery cost passes the first-offence ceiling of PHP 10,000,000 once the shortfall would cost more than PHP 5,000,000 to recover, and passes the third-offence ceiling of PHP 20,000,000 once it would cost more than PHP 10,000,000. For a large enterprise with a big footprint gap, the cost leg, not the band, is the exposure.
Industry reaction
“When we identify a business that does not comply, we will work with them to bring them into compliance.”
Environment Agency, England, Packaging producer responsibility monitoring plan 2026, published 22 December 2025
“The Attorney General takes seriously the need to comply with SB 54.”
California Attorney General, enforcement advisory to producers of EPS food service ware, 2 December 2025
“The Authority has commenced inspection and enforcement on compliance to this Act.”
The three statements show three postures. The Environment Agency puts compliance support first and enforcement second. California’s Attorney General signals a willingness to enforce alongside CalRecycle. NEMA announced enforcement under the Act before its detailed EPR regulations existed.
What leaders should do now
- Compliance leads, by 31 December 2026: list, for each market in Exhibit 1, the offence that would apply to each of your current gaps (registration, data, fees, targets), and the regulator that would act.
- Finance teams, by the 2027 budget cycle: record penalty ceilings in each market’s own currency, as in Exhibits 10 and 11, and never add them into one group figure; check the treatment with counsel and auditors.
- German operations, before 12 February 2027: map which of your packaging falls under the PPWR reuse duties that enter the EUR 200,000 band of section 66 on that date.
- Philippine teams, before 31 December 2026: estimate the cost of recovering any shortfall against the 60% target, since twice that cost may exceed the fine band.
- US state teams, now: keep evidence that registration and reporting with Oregon’s and California’s PRO are complete, since both states’ penalties accrue by the day.
- Supply and marketplace managers, by 31 March 2027: confirm that every partner and distributor in Germany, Kenya and the Philippines can see your registration, as those markets can stop trade without a fine.
Questions for your board
- In which markets could a gap in our EPR compliance lead to prison, not just a fine?
- Where does our exposure scale with turnover or with the cost of a shortfall, rather than a fixed band?
- Which of our products could be barred from a market or a marketplace for a registration gap?
- Do we hold each penalty ceiling in its own currency, without adding them into one figure?
- Who receives regulator notices in each market, and how fast do they reach us?
- What changes in Germany on 12 February 2027, and are we ready for it?
What to watch
- Nov 2026: PackUK sends year 2 notices of liability for disposal fees under SI 2024/1332 (SPI tracker data, PackUK operational plan).
- 31 Dec 2026: Philippine obliged enterprises must recover 60% of their 2025 plastic packaging footprint (SPI tracker data, PR-PH-001).
- 12 Feb 2027: section 66(2) VerpackDG fines for the 37 PPWR offences start to apply (section 68(17)).
- 30 Jun 2027: Indian annual EPR returns for 2026-27 are due on the CPCB portal (SPI tracker data, PR-IN-001, clause 10.6).
- 31 Oct 2027: in Germany, organisations for packaging outside system participation need authorisation (SPI tracker data, PR-DE-001).
- past
- next
- California SB 54 registration steppast
- VerpackDG and section 66(1) fines applypast
- PackUK year 2 notices of liabilitynext
- Philippines 60% recovery targetnext
- Section 66(2) VerpackDG fines applynext
- India annual EPR returns duenext
- Germany: authorisation for other PROsnext
Source: SPI tracker data, PR-US-004, PR-PH-001, PR-IN-001 and PR-DE-001; VerpackDG section 68(17); PackUK operational plan (SPI summary), checked 22 Nov 2026.
Dates as given in each source. Past means before 6 November 2026.
Show the data
| Date | Label | Category | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-06-01 | California SB 54 registration step | past | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/ |
| 2026-08-12 | VerpackDG and section 66(1) fines apply | past | https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/verpackdg/__66.html |
| 2026-11 | PackUK year 2 notices of liability | next | https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/packuk-operational-plan/packuk-operational-plan-2026-to-2027 |
| 2026-12-31 | Philippines 60% recovery target | next | https://ldr.senate.gov.ph/legislative-issuance/republic-act-no-11898 |
| 2027-02-12 | Section 66(2) VerpackDG fines apply | next | https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/verpackdg/__68.html |
| 2027-06-30 | India annual EPR returns due | next | https://www.greentribunal.gov.in/sites/default/files/news_updates/2222_0.pdf |
| 2027-10-31 | Germany: authorisation for other PROs | next | https://www.verpackungsregister.org/en/i-want-to-know-what-will-change-from-12-august |
Methodology
- Data used: the enforcement sections of SPI’s rule depth files PR-GB-002, PR-DE-001, PR-US-002, PR-US-004, PR-IN-001, PR-PH-001, PR-KE-002 and PR-ZA-001, data as of 14 October 2026.
- Re-read sources: on 6 November 2026 SPI re-read each penalty provision: SI 2024/1332 regulations 115 and 119 and Schedule 13 on legislation.gov.uk; VerpackDG sections 66 and 68 on gesetze-im-internet.de; the Oregon DEQ producers page; ORS 468.130 and PRC 42081 and 42060 on Public.Law, an unofficial compilation; the California Attorney General advisory; the Jan Vishwas Bill as passed by the Lok Sabha (PRS copy); the Hindi Schedule II text annexed to CPCB’s 2022 NGT reply; RA 11898 on the Senate’s LDR; Kenya’s Act (NEMA copy) and L.N. 176 of 2024 (Gazette copy); and GN R1184 as consolidated to GN 5520 of 2024.
- Counting rules: Exhibit 4 counts numbered items in section 66(1) and (2). Exhibits 10 and 11 are SPI calculations from the texts, with stated assumptions, one currency at a time. No amount is converted, summed, averaged or ranked across currencies.
- Not yet confirmed: the statutory maximum figure in Scotland and Northern Ireland; the Oregon Administrative Rule behind the Class 1 classification; California’s text against the legislature’s site; CPCB’s current compensation rates; the enacted wording and commencement of EPA sections 15 and 15A; the official English text of Schedule II clauses 6.4 and 9; any published penalty decision under the eight clauses. Nothing here is legal advice; check with counsel or the regulator.
FAQ
What are EPR penalties?
EPR penalties are the sanctions a packaging extended producer responsibility law sets for not registering, not reporting, not paying fees or missing targets. They range from fixed civil penalties, such as the UK’s GBP 1,000, to per-day fines in Oregon and California, fines by offence in the Philippines, and court fines with prison in Kenya and South Africa.
What is the penalty for not complying with EPR in India?
India uses two tools. Environmental compensation is levied on missed plastic packaging EPR targets, with 75%, 60% or 40% refunded if the gap closes within one, two or three years. Contravening the Rules also carries an Environment (Protection) Act penalty of INR 10,000 to INR 15 lakh, plus INR 10,000 a day.
What are the EPR fines in the UK?
Under SI 2024/1332, a fixed monetary penalty is GBP 1,000, rising by 50% if unpaid after 56 days. Unpaid disposal fees attract a variable penalty of the higher of 20% of the unpaid fees or 5% of reported turnover. Offences such as trading unregistered carry an unlimited fine on conviction in England and Wales.
What are the fines under the German packaging law VerpackDG?
Section 66 of the VerpackDG sets maximum fines of EUR 200,000, EUR 100,000 or EUR 10,000 per offence. Not joining a dual system sits in the top band and not registering in LUCID in the middle band. The 37 PPWR offences in section 66(2) apply only from 12 February 2027.
What is the SB 54 penalty in California?
Public Resources Code section 42081 lets CalRecycle impose administrative civil penalties of up to USD 50,000 per day per violation, or USD 25,000 for qualifying small entities. Penalties accrue only 30 days after notice, and a corrective action plan of up to 24 months can stop them. The Attorney General can add Unfair Competition Law penalties.
Can you go to prison for EPR non-compliance?
In two of the eight laws SPI compared, yes. Kenya’s Sustainable Waste Management Act, 2022 provides up to four years in prison, a fine of KSh 2 million to KSh 4 million, or both. South Africa’s EPR Regulations provide up to 15 years, an appropriate fine, or both. The other six set fines or civil penalties.
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk: SI 2024/1332, regulation 115, offences by producers, consulted 2026-11-06.
- legislation.gov.uk: SI 2024/1332, regulation 119, penalties, consulted 2026-11-06.
- legislation.gov.uk: SI 2024/1332, Schedule 13, civil sanctions, consulted 2026-11-06.
- GOV.UK: Packaging producer responsibility monitoring plan 2026, Environment Agency, consulted 2026-11-06.
- gesetze-im-internet.de: VerpackDG, section 66, Bußgeldvorschriften, consulted 2026-11-06.
- gesetze-im-internet.de: VerpackDG, section 68, transitional provisions, consulted 2026-11-06.
- Oregon DEQ: Producers of Covered Products, consulted 2026-11-06.
- Public.Law: ORS 468.130, schedule of civil penalties (unofficial compilation), consulted 2026-11-06.
- Public.Law: California Public Resources Code section 42081 (unofficial compilation), consulted 2026-11-06.
- Public.Law: California Public Resources Code section 42060 (unofficial compilation), consulted 2026-11-06.
- California Attorney General: SB 54 enforcement advisory to producers of EPS food service ware, 2 December 2025, consulted 2026-11-06.
- PRS Legislative Research: Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Bill as passed by the Lok Sabha, consulted 2026-11-06.
- National Green Tribunal: CPCB reply in OA 22 of 2022, annexing G.S.R. 133(E) of 16 February 2022, consulted 2026-11-06.
- Senate of the Philippines LDR: Republic Act No. 11898, Extended Producer Responsibility Act of 2022, consulted 2026-11-06.
- NEMA: Sustainable Waste Management Act, 2022, consulted 2026-11-06.
- Kenya Gazette Supplement No. 196: L.N. 176 of 2024, EPR Regulations, 2024 (Kenya Clearing House Mechanism copy), consulted 2026-11-06.
- Kenya News Agency: NEMA issues 60-day Extended Producer Responsibility compliance notice, consulted 2026-11-06.
- Southern African Legal Information Institute: EPR Regulations, 2020 (GN R1184), as amended to GN 5520 of 2024, consulted 2026-11-06.
- SPI Packaging Regulation Tracker: enforcement sections of eight rule depth files, data as of 14 October 2026, consulted 2026-10-14.
Go deeper
- SPI dataSPI Regulation Tracker79 packaging rules in 25 jurisdictions: EPR, PPWR, SB 54, SB 343, plastic taxes, bans and deposit return, each with its official source and dates.
- SPI LedgerPlastic is a fifth of the tonnage but half or more of the EPR bill in most schemes SPI pricedOn one 100-tonne household packaging basket, 2026 EPR fees come to about EUR 61 to EUR 375 per tonne across the euro schemes Strategic Packaging Insights…