SPI LedgerNews analysis
California SB 343: the chasing arrows cutoff passed on 4 October 2026, but an injunction holds enforcement
California SB 343, now Public Resources Code section 42355.51, treats the chasing arrows or any recyclable claim as deceptive on products and packaging manufactured after 4 October 2026 unless the material type is collected by programmes serving at least 60% of Californians and sorted by facilities serving at least 60% of programmes; since 14 July 2026, however, a federal preliminary injunction in the US District Court for the Southern District of California (No. 3:26-cv-01675) has stopped the state from enforcing the law, while CalRecycle’s study duties continue.
4 Oct 2026
Labelling restriction applies to items made after
18 months after the 4 April 2025 final findings
PRC 42355.51(b)(2)(A); CalRecycle
14 Jul 2026
Enforcement halted since
preliminary injunction, S.D. Cal. No. 3:26-cv-01675
CalRecycle SB 343 page
35 of 91
Material types and forms meeting both 60% lines
June 2026 Table 2 data; 15 more sit in other programmes
SPI count of CalRecycle Tables 1 and 2
Source: PRC 42355.51; CalRecycle SB 343 page and Final Findings DRRR-2025-1750 with Table 2 updates; count by SPI (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Not legal advice. The injunction's terms are taken from CalRecycle and from press and law firm reports; SPI has not yet confirmed them against the court docket.
The cutoff therefore exists on paper but not in court. On CalRecycle’s latest Table 2 data, 35 of the 91 material types and forms it studied meet both 60% lines by SPI’s count, and two of them, non-CRV cartons, clear the sorting line by the width of a single county.
Executive summary
California’s SB 343 was written in 2021 to stop recyclable claims on packs that California’s system does not actually collect and sort. Its trigger was a study, not a calendar date: CalRecycle published the final findings of its material characterisation study on 4 April 2025, and the statute gave manufacturers 18 months, so the restriction reaches items manufactured after 4 October 2026. That date has now passed.
What has not passed is the court case. On 14 July 2026 the US District Court for the Southern District of California issued a preliminary injunction in a challenge brought by food and packaging trade associations (No. 3:26-cv-01675). CalRecycle states that the injunction only blocks enforcement of SB 343 and does not affect its duty to update the study in 2027. Press and law firm reports say the court found four parts of the test likely too vague and the statute likely to fail First Amendment review, and enjoined the Attorney General and those acting in concert with that office until further order. SPI has not yet confirmed the order’s terms against the docket.
The data under the law keeps changing. SPI counted CalRecycle’s two tables row by row: 35 of 91 material types and forms meet both 60% lines on the June 2026 data. Glass, steel, aluminium, most paper and the main PET, HDPE and PP rigids pass; every plastic film and bag, every polystyrene format and multi-material laminates miss both lines. Cartons have moved four times, from 47% of counties to 68%, 53% and now 62%, which is exactly 21 of the 34 surveyed counties, the minimum that clears 60%.
For brand owners the result is a two-speed position. Artwork that would fail SB 343 can lawfully stay on shelf while the injunction stands, but nothing in the public record says items made in this window are safe if the injunction is lifted. The next study in 2027 starts a fresh 18-month clock, and from 2032 SB 54 borrows SB 343’s recyclability standard for its own targets.
The practical moves are to log manufacture dates per batch, map each SKU to its CalRecycle row, hold compliant artwork ready, and budget for the 2027 study rather than for the injunction’s outcome alone. None of this is legal advice.
Key findings
- SB 343’s restriction applies to products and packaging manufactured after 4 October 2026, 18 months after CalRecycle’s final findings of 4 April 2025, and turns on manufacture date, not sale date (PRC 42355.51(b)(2)(A); CalRecycle FAQ, 13 August 2025).
- Enforcement has been enjoined since 14 July 2026 by the US District Court for the Southern District of California, No. 3:26-cv-01675; CalRecycle states the injunction only blocks enforcement and leaves the 2027 study duty intact.
- SPI analysis: on CalRecycle’s June 2026 data, 35 of 91 material types and forms meet both 60% lines, 33 miss both and 15 sit in other programmes such as CRV, by SPI’s count of Tables 1 and 2 (Exhibit 1).
- Non-CRV cartons moved from 47% of surveyed counties in April 2025 to 68% in August 2025, 53% in December 2025 and 62% in June 2026, as CalRecycle added and removed sorting facilities (Exhibit 6).
- SPI calculation: 60% of 34 surveyed counties is 20.4, so a pass needs 21; cartons sit at exactly 21, aluminium cans at 27 and the top rigids at 34, so losing one county would drop cartons below the line (Exhibit 7).
- Press and law firm reports say the court found four provisions likely vague (routine feedstock, the Basel Convention, the APR Design Guide and the ensure recyclability wording) and severable, leaving the 60/60 test standing on paper (Resource Recycling, 15 July 2026).
- The case is still at an early stage: a request by two non-profits to intervene was denied on 28 September 2026, a motion to add SB 54 claims is set for 16 November 2026 and a status conference for 15 December 2026, as reported by Keller and Heckman.
California SB 343 in one page: what the statute says
SB 343 (Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021) rewrote Public Resources Code section 42355.51, which already dealt with recyclability claims. The section on California’s legislative site today carries the history line of a 2022 clean-up amendment, Stats. 2022, Ch. 28 (SB 1380), effective 1 January 2023. SPI’s tracker records the rule as PR-US-011.
The structure is simple to state and hard to apply (Exhibit 2). Subdivision (b)(1) deems a product or package that displays the chasing arrows, or any other statement that it is recyclable or should be recycled, to be making a deceptive claim unless it meets the statutory criteria and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock for new products or packaging. Subdivision (b)(2)(A) exempts items manufactured up to 18 months after CalRecycle publishes its first study, or before 1 January 2024, whichever is later.
Subdivision (c) lists what is not deceptive: the chasing arrows with a clearly visible line placed at a 45-degree angle across it, symbols required by other federal or state law, directions to compost, and a resin identification code placed inside a solid equilateral triangle. That last point matters for plastic packs, because the familiar resin code inside chasing arrows is not on the list.
| Part | What it does | Court treatment, as reported |
|---|---|---|
| (b)(1) | Deems the chasing arrows or a recyclable statement deceptive unless the criteria are met and the item routinely becomes feedstock | Routine feedstock wording found likely vague |
| (b)(2)(A) | Exempts items made up to 18 months after the first study (to 4 Oct 2026) | Not reported as at issue |
| (c)(1) to (c)(4) | Safe harbours: arrows with a 45-degree line, legally required symbols, compost directions, resin code in a solid triangle | Not reported as at issue |
| (d)(2) | Collected by programmes serving 60% of the population and sorted by facilities serving 60% of programmes, then reclaimed consistent with the Basel Convention | 60/60 test stands; Basel element found likely vague |
| (d)(3)(A) | Plastic packaging free of components, inks, adhesives or labels that prevent recyclability under the APR Design Guide | Found likely vague |
| (d)(3)(B) | Plastic and non-plastic items designed to ensure recyclability | Found likely vague |
| (d)(3)(C) and (D) | No listed intentionally added chemicals; no PFAS in plastic or fibre | Not reported as at issue |
| (d)(4) to (d)(6) | Alternative paths: 75% recycling rate, noncurbside programme at 60% (75% from 2030), other laws | Not reported as at issue |
Source: PRC 42355.51 (California Legislative Information); Resource Recycling, 15 July 2026; Saul Ewing, 21 July 2026; Steptoe (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Summary of the statute, not legal advice. The court column is as reported by press and law firms; SPI has not yet confirmed the order's terms against the docket.
The test itself is in subdivision (d). Under (d)(2) the material type and form must be collected for recycling by programmes that together serve at least 60% of the California population and sorted by large volume transfer or processing facilities that together serve at least 60% of statewide recycling programmes, which must send it to a reclaimer consistent with the Basel Convention. Under (d)(3) the item must also meet four design limits. CalRecycle’s FAQ of 13 August 2025 says a product is recyclable in California when it meets both (d)(2) and (d)(3).
Two of the four design limits were not reported as part of the court’s vagueness findings. Subdivision (d)(3)(C) excludes items containing an intentionally added chemical identified under the regulations that implement section 42370.2(g)(4), and (d)(3)(D) excludes plastic or fibre that contains perfluoroalkyl or polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). For a fibre bowl or a coated paper pack, the PFAS limit can therefore decide a claim even where the material row passes both 60% lines, and SPI’s PFAS food contact piece sets out the wider limits.
Three alternative paths sit beside the statewide test. Subdivision (d)(4) accepts a demonstrated recycling rate of at least 75%; (d)(5) accepts a noncurbside programme that recovers at least 60% of the item before 1 January 2030 and at least 75% after; and (d)(6) accepts compliance with another California law on recyclability or disposal. CalRecycle’s FAQ notes that its study cannot establish any of these paths, so a manufacturer relying on one needs its own evidence.
The Business and Professions Code adds a paper trail. The Senate Judiciary Committee’s analysis of the bill, prepared for its hearing of 6 April 2021 on the 17 March 2021 version, describes SB 343 bringing the chasing arrows and recycling directions into the Environmental Representations Law at section 17580, so that a person using them must keep written records of whether the item meets the statewide criteria in 42355.51, and amending section 17580.5 so that following the FTC Green Guides is no defence to a claim under the new rules. SPI has not yet confirmed the enacted wording of sections 17580 and 17580.5 against the code text.
The date: why 4 October 2026, and why manufacture date
The 4 October date comes from arithmetic, not from a fixed statutory deadline. CalRecycle published the SB 343 Material Characterization Study final findings (DRRR-2025-1750) on 4 April 2025, and 18 months later is 4 October 2026, a Sunday. The statute allowed 1 January 2024 as a floor if the study came early; it came late, so the later date governs.
CalRecycle’s FAQ of 13 August 2025 reads subdivision (b)(2)(A) the same way: whether the restriction applies depends on when an item is manufactured, not when it is sold.
That design gives stock made on or before 4 October 2026 a permanent pass, whenever it is sold. It also means the useful compliance record is a production date per batch, not a shelf date. By SPI’s calculation, 36 days of manufacture had fallen after the cutoff by 9 November 2026, and the injunction was granted 82 days before the cutoff arrived.
The clock repeats. CalRecycle must revise the study in 2027 and every five years after, and its SB 343 page says each new study opens a fresh window.
“After CalRecycle publishes each new study, manufacturers will have 18 months to ensure the updated information supports the use of the chasing arrows recycling symbol on their products.”
CalRecycle held an informational workshop on the scope and design of the next facility-based study on 29 September 2026, and says it does not expect to publish a new version of the complete report until 2027 (Exhibit 3).
- past
- next
- 2021SB 343 enacted as Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021past
- Preliminary study findings publishedpast
- Final findings DRRR-2025-1750 published; 18-month clock startspast
- First Table 2 update: cartons to 68% of countiespast
- Second Table 2 update: cartons to 53%past
- Trade associations file suit, S.D. Cal. No. 3:26-cv-01675, as reportedpast
- Third Table 2 update: cartons to 62%past
- Preliminary injunction blocks enforcement of SB 343past
- End of 18-month window; restriction covers items made after this datepast
- Hearing on motion to add SB 54 claims, as reportednext
- Attorney-only status conference, as reportednext
- 2027Second material characterisation study duenext
Source: PRC 42355.51; CalRecycle SB 343 page, FAQ, final findings and Table 2 updates; Saul Ewing; Keller and Heckman (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Category shows whether the date is past or next from 9 November 2026. Court dates after 14 July 2026 are as reported by law firms; SPI has not yet confirmed them on the docket.
Show the data
| Date | Label | Category | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | SB 343 enacted as Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021 | past | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
| 2023-12-28 | Preliminary study findings published | past | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
| 2025-04-04 | Final findings DRRR-2025-1750 published; 18-month clock starts | past | https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Publications/137532 |
| 2025-08-08 | First Table 2 update: cartons to 68% of counties | past | https://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/CALRECYCLE/bulletins/3ed21c5 |
| 2025-12-22 | Second Table 2 update: cartons to 53% | past | https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/137764 |
| 2026-03-17 | Trade associations file suit, S.D. Cal. No. 3:26-cv-01675, as reported | past | https://www.saul.com/insights/alert/sb-343-enjoined-federal-court-blocks-enforcement-californias-truth-recycling-law |
| 2026-06-24 | Third Table 2 update: cartons to 62% | past | https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/139153 |
| 2026-07-14 | Preliminary injunction blocks enforcement of SB 343 | past | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
| 2026-10-04 | End of 18-month window; restriction covers items made after this date | past | https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/131148 |
| 2026-11-16 | Hearing on motion to add SB 54 claims, as reported | next | https://www.khlaw.com/insights/sb-343-court-removes-ene-conference-calendar-while-considering-request-add-sb-54-claims |
| 2026-12-15 | Attorney-only status conference, as reported | next | https://www.khlaw.com/insights/sb-343-court-removes-ene-conference-calendar-while-considering-request-add-sb-54-claims |
| 2027 | Second material characterisation study due | next | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
SPI has not yet confirmed the 2021 signing date from a legislative source; CalRecycle’s page gives only the year and chapter.
What the material characterisation study shows
CalRecycle’s study, run with Cascadia Consulting Group, combined surveys of local programmes, surveys of large volume transfer and processing facilities (LVTPs) and sampling at those facilities. The final report records 37 LVTPs surveyed by phone, 29 of which sort on site and 24 of which were visited, and 565 samples: 459 hand-sorted and 106 characterised visually across August 2023 and January to February 2024. Surveyed facilities serve 34 of California’s 58 counties, which hold 93% of the population.
The report sets out its results as two tables over 91 material types and forms (MT&F). Table 1 gives the share of Californians whose curbside programme accepts each MT&F. Table 2 gives the share of the 34 surveyed counties served by an LVTP that sorts it into a viable outflow. CalRecycle stresses that neither table decides recyclability: the study leaves out where sorted material goes and how a pack is designed, both of which the statute also tests.
SPI took both tables and placed every row in one of five groups (Exhibit 4). The pattern by material is stark. Glass, metal and the core of the fibre stream pass where they are not already in another programme; plastic splits in half; and the mixed and other group, from textiles to laminates, passes nowhere.
LowerHigher(shade by fifths of all values in the table)
| Class | Meet both | Sorted below 60% | Collected below 60% | Below on both | Other programme | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fibre | 9 | 1 | 0 | 4 | 1 | 15 |
| Glass | 4 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 4 | 9 |
| Metal | 8 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 4 | 14 |
| Plastic | 14 | 4 | 3 | 14 | 4 | 39 |
| Other | 0 | 0 | 0 | 12 | 2 | 14 |
Source: CalRecycle Final Findings DRRR-2025-1750, Tables 1 and 2, with Table 2 update of 24 June 2026; classification by SPI (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Fibre includes the three carton rows (X01 to X03), which CalRecycle classes as fibre. Other covers household hazardous waste, tires, bulky items, mattresses, textiles and mixed-material rows X04 to X13. A zero means no MT&F falls in that group.
The five rows that are collected widely but sorted below 60% are the most instructive, because they show where curbside acceptance runs ahead of facility practice. Clean molded paper fibre is accepted for 94% of Californians but sorted in 0% of surveyed counties; PET multi-use rigids reach 85% and 0%; LDPE clear beverage bottles 75% and 0%; LDPE clear single-use rigids 73% and 44%; and LDPE pigmented rigids 73% and 0%.
The three rows sorted widely but collected below 60% are mixed or unknown plastic (38% and 100%), mixed plastic multi-use items (51% and 100%) and PP multi-use, which has no Table 1 value. For these the gap is the bin, not the facility.
Exhibit 5 sets out the formats packaging buyers ask about most.
| MT&F | Code | Table 1 collection (%) | Table 2 sorting (%) | Both lines met |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Uncoated corrugated cardboard | F01 | 99 | 100 | Yes |
| Folded paper containers and paperboard | F06 | 98 | 94 | Yes |
| PET clear bottles, non-CRV | PL01 | 99 | 100 | Yes |
| PET thermoformed clamshells and containers | PL05 | 88 | 100 | Yes |
| PP clear single-use rigids | PL22 | 78 | 94 | Yes |
| Aluminium cans and lids, non-CRV | M01 | 96 | 79 | Yes |
| Aluminium foil sheets | M05 | 81 | 79 | Yes |
| Steel or aluminium aerosol containers | M10 | 71 | 100 | Yes |
| Gable-top cartons, non-CRV | X02 | 74 | 62 | Yes |
| Clean molded paper fibre | F08 | 94 | 0 | No |
| PS thermoformed clamshells and containers | PL25 | 40 | 0 | No |
| Plastic bags designed for disposal | PL36 | 28 | 56 | No |
| Other plastic film | PL35 | 29 | 0 | No |
| Mailing pouches and shipping envelopes | X04 | 29 | 0 | No |
| Other multi-material laminate, single-use | X05 | 35 | 0 | No |
Source: CalRecycle Final Findings DRRR-2025-1750, Tables 1 and 2; carton rows from the Table 2 update of 24 June 2026 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Table 1 is the percent of population with curbside access accepting the MT&F; Table 2 is the percent of the 34 surveyed counties served by sorting LVTPs. CRV containers are subject to another programme and not shown. Meeting both lines does not by itself make a claim lawful.
For flexible packaging the finding is binary: every film and bag row (PL32 to PL36) misses the collection line, and only bags designed for disposal reach more than half of counties on sorting. SPI’s flexible packaging recyclability piece covers the wider design question; under SB 343 the immediate point is that curbside film claims have no statewide path, so a film claim would need a (d)(5) noncurbside programme with its own recovery evidence.
Cartons: four editions of one table
No row shows the moving target better than cartons. CalRecycle has used its power under 42355.51(d)(1)(B)(iii) to publish information that was not available during the study three times since April 2025, each time for the same two rows: non-CRV gable-top cartons (X02) and non-CRV aseptic containers (X03).
| Edition | Counties served | Share of counties (%) | Above 60% | Reason given |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Final findings, 4 Apr 2025 | 16 | 47 | No | Study data |
| Update, 8 Aug 2025 | 23 | 68 | Yes | Sacramento Recycling and Transfer Station counties added |
| Update, 22 Dec 2025 | 18 | 53 | No | Operator letter: facility no longer sorts cartons into paper grades |
| Update, 24 Jun 2026 | 21 | 62 | Yes | Three more LVTPs sort cartons into PSI Grade 52 bales |
Source: CalRecycle Final Findings DRRR-2025-1750 (April 2025); bulletin of 8 August 2025; letters of 22 December 2025 and 24 June 2026 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Counties served out of 34 surveyed counties. Table 1 collection access is 74% for gable-top and 72% for aseptic cartons in every edition. CalRecycle states that none of these updates is a recyclability determination.
The December 2025 change followed a letter of 15 December 2025 from the operator of the Sacramento facility saying it no longer sorted cartons into any paper grade and sent them to landfill as residuals. The June 2026 change added three facilities that confirmed sorting into PSI Grade 52 bales: the Western Placer Waste Management Authority MRF in Roseville, Pacific Recycling Solutions in Ukiah and Cold Canyon Landfill in San Luis Obispo. In each letter CalRecycle repeats that it is not making a recyclability determination.
SPI analysis
The thresholds are counted in whole counties, and 60% of 34 is 20.4, so an MT&F needs 21 counties to pass. Cartons now hold exactly 21. Exhibit 7 shows how much room each passing group has before the line.
The mechanism behind these swings is written into the statute. Subdivision (d)(1)(B)(iii) lets CalRecycle publish information that was not available during the most recent study, and each of the three letters cites it. That gives facility operators and material groups a route to move a row between full studies, upward when a facility starts sorting a grade and downward when it stops, as the December 2025 letter shows. It also means a row can change without notice to the brands that rely on it, so the edition of Table 2 used for each claim is worth recording.
The point for planners is not cartons alone. Any MT&F within a few counties of the line can flip on one facility’s sorting decision, and the 2027 study will re-measure every row from new fieldwork. A claim that is supportable today on Table 2 is a claim on a dataset that has changed three times in 15 months.
The injunction: what the court record and official sources show
Two layers of evidence exist for the order of 14 July 2026, and SPI keeps them apart. The first is official: CalRecycle’s SB 343 page names the case by court and number and states its effect.
“The injunction only blocks enforcement of SB 343.”
CalRecycle adds that the injunction does not affect its obligation to update the study in 2027 and every five years after, and that the 4 October 2026 compliance date may be affected by the litigation. Its FAQ separately makes clear that the agency itself has no enforcement role.
“CalRecycle does not have enforcement authority pursuant to SB 343.”
The second layer is reported. The further terms below are as reported by the named publications, and SPI has not yet confirmed them against the docket (Exhibit 8).
| Point | What is stated | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Court and number | US District Court, Southern District of California, No. 3:26-cv-01675 | CalRecycle (official) |
| Date | Preliminary injunction issued 14 July 2026 | CalRecycle (official) |
| Effect | Blocks enforcement of SB 343 only; study duties continue | CalRecycle (official) |
| Who is enjoined | The Attorney General and those in privity or acting in concert, until further order of the court | As reported by Packaging Dive, Farella Braun and Martel, Steptoe |
| Reach beyond plaintiffs | Not limited to the plaintiffs (Saul Ewing); practical reach outside the plaintiff coalition an open question (Resource Recycling) | As reported; reports differ |
| Private enforcers | Read as covered through privity by Kahn, Soares and Conway; called unresolved by Steptoe | As reported; reports differ |
| Grounds | Four provisions likely vague; statute likely fails the Central Hudson commercial speech test | As reported by Resource Recycling, Saul Ewing |
| Severability | Each vague provision severable; 60/60 test treated as central | As reported by Resource Recycling, Steptoe |
| Bond | No security bond required of the plaintiffs | As reported by Resource Recycling |
| Items made during the injunction | Not addressed in the reports or official sources cited | SPI has not yet confirmed |
Source: CalRecycle SB 343 page; Resource Recycling (15 July 2026); Packaging Dive (15 July 2026); Farella Braun and Martel (15 July 2026); Kahn, Soares and Conway (20 July 2026); Saul Ewing (21 July 2026); Steptoe (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Not legal advice. Reported terms have not yet been confirmed by SPI against the order on the court docket. Where reports differ, both readings are shown.
Reports agree on the core. Resource Recycling and Saul Ewing describe four provisions found likely unconstitutionally vague under the Fourteenth Amendment: the requirement that an item routinely becomes feedstock, the Basel Convention reclaiming reference, the APR Design Guide reference and the wording that items be designed to ensure recyclability. On the First Amendment, Saul Ewing reports the court found the state had not shown the restrictions would materially advance its interests and that the law was not narrowly tailored, citing evidence that manufacturers could remove truthful labels rather than redesign packs.
The reports differ on reach. Saul Ewing writes that the court did not limit the injunction to the plaintiffs, so the state cannot enforce SB 343 against any business while the case is pending; Resource Recycling calls the order’s practical scope for companies outside the plaintiff coalition an open question. On private suits, Kahn, Soares and Conway reads privity with the Attorney General as reaching private enforcers, while Steptoe says enforcement by other actors raises separate, unresolved issues. SPI reports both readings and takes no view on which is right.
The plaintiffs are trade associations; Keller and Heckman counts 21, Resource Recycling a 20-member coalition, and Packaging Dive names the Flexible Packaging Association and the American Forest and Paper Association as lead plaintiffs among more than a dozen groups; CalRecycle’s page names the case after the California League of Food Producers.
The docket since July: slow, and widening
The case has moved slowly since the order, and in a direction that matters for SB 54 as much as SB 343 (Exhibit 9). The events below are as reported by Keller and Heckman; SPI has not yet confirmed them on the docket.
| Date | Event, as reported | Status at 9 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| 25 Aug 2026 | Early neutral evaluation (ENE) conference moved from 24 Sep to 28 Oct 2026 | Superseded |
| 23 Sep 2026 | ENE moved again, to 4 Nov 2026 | Superseded |
| 28 Sep 2026 | Intervention by Earth Island Institute and Californians Against Waste denied; amicus briefs permitted | Decided |
| 8 Oct 2026 | Plaintiffs seek leave to file a second amended complaint adding two defendants and ten SB 54 claims | Pending |
| 23 Oct 2026 | ENE conference vacated | Decided |
| 16 Nov 2026 | Hearing on the motion for leave, no personal appearances | Next |
| 15 Dec 2026 | Attorney-only status conference | Next |
Source: Keller and Heckman (24 September, 29 September and 27 October 2026) (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
As reported; SPI has not yet confirmed these entries against the court docket. SB 54 aspects are covered in SPI Ledger 72.
Keller and Heckman reports that the court found the two non-profits’ motion timely and their interest protectable, but held that the Attorney General adequately represents them. It also notes that a denial of intervention as of right can be appealed to the Ninth Circuit; SPI has not yet confirmed any appeal by the non-profits or by the state as of 9 November 2026. The SB 54 claims, and the separate multistate SB 54 case, are covered in SPI’s California SB 54 regulations piece, so this article does not repeat them.
A framework: SPI's six claim lanes
The statute and the data together let a brand team sort every California SKU into one of six lanes before deciding what the artwork should say (Exhibit 10). The lanes come from the five data groups of Exhibit 4, with passing rows split by their margin, and they apply whether or not the injunction holds, because the 2027 study and SB 54’s 2032 standard both use the same test.
| Lane | MT&F | Examples | Planning stance while enjoined |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Clear pass | 33 | Cardboard, PET and HDPE bottles, PP rigids, cans, glass jars | Keep claim; document row and design limits |
| 2. Thin pass | 2 | Non-CRV gable-top and aseptic cartons | Keep claim; hold fallback artwork for the 2027 study |
| 3. Collected, not sorted | 5 | Molded fibre, PET multi-use, LDPE rigids | Fallback artwork ready; facility data to watch |
| 4. Sorted, not collected | 3 | Mixed plastic, PP multi-use | Fallback artwork ready; programme data to watch |
| 5. Below both lines | 33 | Films, PS, laminates, mailing pouches, textiles | Plan to drop claim or use a noncurbside path |
| 6. Other programme | 15 | CRV beverage containers, tires, mattresses | Follow the other programme's rules; SPI has not yet confirmed how SB 343 treats each |
Source: SPI analysis of PRC 42355.51 and CalRecycle Final Findings DRRR-2025-1750, Tables 1 and 2, with the Table 2 update of 24 June 2026 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Planning framework only, not a legal interpretation. Lanes 1 and 2 still need the (d)(3) design limits and Basel reclaiming, and items in any lane may use an alternative path in (d)(4) to (d)(6) with their own evidence.
SPI analysis
On these counts, 61.5% of the 91 MT&F rows have no statewide path on current data (lanes 3 to 6), and among rows not in another programme, 53.9% do (lanes 3 to 5: 41 of 76), by SPI’s calculation. The share says nothing about tonnage or SKUs, since one row such as cardboard carries far more packaging than another such as treated wood.
In practice: Amazon.
SPI’s Buyers Database profile notes that, as shipper of record, Amazon is the likely producer of its mailers, paper bags and void fill under SB 54, and that SB 343 governs recyclable claims on its mailers. On CalRecycle’s tables, paper bags and kraft paper (F05) sit in lane 1 at 97% and 94%, while mailing pouches and shipping envelopes (X04) sit in lane 5 at 29% and 0%. The same parcel can therefore hold one format with a statewide path and one without.
In practice: Colgate-Palmolive.
SPI’s profile records that about 97% of Colgate’s North American toothpaste SKUs use its recyclable tube and that the company names Hill’s pet food film as hard to recycle; the film depends on store drop-off. Store drop-off is not curbside, so a Hill’s film claim in California would need the (d)(5) noncurbside path. SPI has not yet confirmed which MT&F row CalRecycle would assign to the tube; CalRecycle’s FAQ says it gives no product-specific categorisation.
In practice: Walmart.
SPI’s profile records that How2Recycle labels covered 92% of Walmart US private-brand food and consumables sales reported by suppliers in calendar 2023. A label programme of that reach turns SB 343 into an artwork question for a whole private-label range at once, which is why the row mapping in Exhibit 10 is worth doing centrally rather than SKU by SKU.
Scenarios: what decides a California claim in 2027 and 2028
Two things will decide whether a claim is supportable: the court’s final answer and the 2027 study’s numbers. Exhibit 11 sets them side by side. The legal column describes possible outcomes reported by law firms, not predictions; the data column is an SPI calculation from Table 2.
| Scenario | Counties change per row | MT&Fs meeting both lines | Rows that drop out |
|---|---|---|---|
| High: sorting expands | +3 | 35 | None (no new row clears both lines) |
| Base: June 2026 data | 0 | 35 | no data |
| Low: one county lost | -1 | 33 | Gable-top and aseptic cartons |
| Stress: five counties lost | -5 | 31 | Cartons, other ferrous and non-ferrous metal |
| Severe: seven counties lost | -7 | 27 | Cartons, other metals, aluminium cans, bottles and foil |
Source: SPI calculation from CalRecycle Final Findings DRRR-2025-1750, Table 2, and the Table 2 update of 24 June 2026; outcome descriptions from Saul Ewing and Steptoe (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Assumption: a uniform change of counties served for every MT&F, with Table 1 unchanged, an SPI simplification; the real study will move rows unevenly. Low, base and high are data scenarios only. Not legal advice and not a forecast of the court's ruling.
The high case adds nothing because the rows nearest the sorting line, such as bags designed for disposal at 56%, also fail the collection line. Growth in the pass list therefore needs both more curbside acceptance and more sorting.
The legal outcomes are simpler to state. Saul Ewing writes that if the plaintiffs prevail a permanent injunction may follow, and if they do not the injunction will dissolve; Steptoe notes the state may seek appellate review or keep litigating the merits. Reports of the order suggest a middle reading is also possible, in which the four vague provisions fall away and the 60/60 test survives, which is the test Exhibits 4 to 11 measure. Every outcome leaves the 2027 study in place.
Who could enforce, and what links to SB 54
Enforcement routes matter because the injunction is aimed at one office. Exhibit 12 lists the routes named in the public sources cited.
| Route | Basis | Position during the injunction |
|---|---|---|
| California Attorney General | PRC 42358(a) and (b) | Enjoined until further order |
| Local jurisdictions and district attorneys | PRC 42358(a) and (b) | Covered if in privity or concert, as reported; SPI has not yet confirmed |
| Business and Professions Code remedies | PRC 42358(c); BPC 17580, 17580.5 | Committee analysis cites existing penalties up to USD 2,500 per violation (BPC 17536) |
| Private and consumer claims | Unfair Competition Law and related statutes, per committee analysis | Read as covered by Kahn, Soares and Conway; unresolved per Steptoe |
| CalRecycle | None under SB 343 | No enforcement authority; study duties continue |
Source: CalRecycle FAQ (13 August 2025); PR-US-011 rule note; California Senate Judiciary Committee analysis (6 April 2021 hearing); Kahn, Soares and Conway; Steptoe (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Not legal advice. Penalty amounts under PRC 42358 are not stated here because SPI has not yet confirmed them from the statute. Business and Professions Code figures are those the committee analysis cites for existing law in 2021, in USD.
The link to SB 54 runs one way. Under PRC 42050(b), SB 54 uses SB 343’s recyclability standard to decide whether covered packaging is recyclable for its 2032 requirement, but CalRecycle’s FAQ says its SB 54 determinations are not liability assessments under SB 343 (PR-US-004). A pack can therefore count as recyclable for EPR while its label claim is judged separately, and an SB 343 ruling could later shape how the SB 54 standard is read. SPI’s Ledger on US recycled content and labelling laws compares SB 343 with the FTC Green Guides, which this piece does not repeat.
Industry reaction
Supporters of the law have stressed what it does not do.
“SB 343 is a straightforward truth-in-advertising law. It does not prohibit companies from making environmental marketing claims.”
The same statement said companies that invested in redesigns should not have to compete against businesses making claims without that investment. On the other side, Packaging Dive and Resource Recycling report that the Flexible Packaging Association was still reviewing the injunction and maintains that SB 343 restricts its members’ ability to give recycling information, and that the American Forest and Paper Association called the ruling a significant win and said paper-based packaging is among the most recyclable material in the country. Neither report carries a statement from CalRecycle or from the Attorney General’s office on the ruling.
What leaders should do now
- Regulatory and supply teams, by 31 December 2026: record manufacture dates by batch for every California SKU with a recyclable claim made after 4 October 2026, since the restriction follows manufacture date and nothing public says items made during the injunction are excused.
- Packaging engineering, by 31 March 2027: map each SKU to its CalRecycle MT&F row and lane (Exhibit 10), using the June 2026 Table 2 and APR size-sort tests where CalRecycle suggests them, and file the edition used.
- Brand and design teams, by 31 March 2027: keep approved fallback artwork without the chasing arrows, or with a 45-degree line or a resin code in a solid triangle, for lanes 2 to 5, ready to run if enforcement resumes.
- Legal and regulatory teams, from 16 November 2026: track the hearing on adding SB 54 claims and the 15 December 2026 status conference, and ask counsel to read the order itself on the docket; this article is not legal advice.
- Sustainability teams, during 2027: engage with CalRecycle’s second study, submit facility or programme evidence for thin or near rows such as cartons, and plan for a new 18-month window after it is published.
- Teams using store drop-off or take-back, by mid-2027: assemble (d)(5) recovery evidence, at least 60% before 2030 and 75% after, for any film or flexible claim that cannot use the curbside test.
- Finance, at the 2027 budget round: carry SB 343 artwork change as a contingent cost tied to the court and the 2027 study, separately from SB 54 fees.
Questions for your board
- How many of our California SKUs made after 4 October 2026 carry the chasing arrows, and in which of the six lanes do they sit?
- Do we hold batch-level manufacture dates that would stand up if enforcement resumed?
- Which of our formats depend on a row, such as cartons, that clears the line by one county?
- Is fallback artwork approved, and how long would a changeover take across plants?
- Are we relying on a reading of the injunction’s reach that our counsel has checked against the order?
- What evidence are we giving CalRecycle for the 2027 study?
What to watch
- 16 Nov 2026: hearing on the motion to add SB 54 claims to the SB 343 case, as reported by Keller and Heckman.
- 15 Dec 2026: attorney-only status conference in No. 3:26-cv-01675, as reported.
- 2027: CalRecycle’s second material characterisation study and a new 18-month window after it (PR-US-011).
- 2027 onward: any Ninth Circuit appeal of the preliminary injunction or of the intervention ruling; none reported by 9 November 2026.
- 1 Jan 2030: the (d)(5) noncurbside recovery threshold rises from 60% to 75%.
- 1 Jan 2032: SB 54’s recyclable or compostable requirement, which uses SB 343’s standard under PRC 42050(b) (PR-US-004).
Methodology
- Data used: PRC 42355.51 as shown on California Legislative Information; the California Senate Judiciary Committee analysis for the 6 April 2021 hearing; CalRecycle’s SB 343 page, FAQ of 13 August 2025, final findings report DRRR-2025-1750 and Table 2 updates of 8 August 2025, 22 December 2025 and 24 June 2026; reports of the injunction and docket by Resource Recycling, Packaging Dive, Saul Ewing, Farella Braun and Martel, Kahn, Soares and Conway, Steptoe and Keller and Heckman; SPI rule notes PR-US-011 and PR-US-004 and SPI Buyers Database profiles of Amazon, Colgate-Palmolive and Walmart.
- Counting rules: SPI placed each of the 91 MT&F rows in one group using Table 1 and Table 2 values of 60% or more; a row shown as subject to another programme in either table is in that group; a row with no applicable value counts as below the line. Carton rows use the 24 June 2026 values. County margins use Table 2 percent x 34, which matches the counts printed in the report.
- Court record: the order’s existence, court, number, date and effect come from CalRecycle. Its reasoning and reach come from the press and law firm reports named in each exhibit. SPI has not yet confirmed the order’s terms against the court docket or an official court copy.
- Currency: USD only, where money appears.
- Cut-off: 9 November 2026.
- Limitations: SPI has not yet confirmed the penalty amounts in PRC 42358, the enacted wording of BPC 17580 and 17580.5, the 2021 signing date, the docket entries after 14 July 2026 or how SB 343 treats each MT&F in another programme. Meeting both 60% lines is not a recyclability finding. This is not legal advice.
FAQ
What is California SB 343?
SB 343 is California’s 2021 law on recyclable claims, now Public Resources Code section 42355.51. It treats the chasing arrows or any statement that an item is recyclable as deceptive unless the material type is collected by programmes serving 60% of Californians, sorted by facilities serving 60% of programmes and meets design limits, with alternative paths for high recovery rates.
When does SB 343 take effect?
The labelling restriction applies to products and packaging manufactured after 4 October 2026, which is 18 months after CalRecycle published its final study findings on 4 April 2025. The date depends on manufacture, not sale, so stock made earlier is outside the rule. Enforcement has been halted by a federal preliminary injunction since 14 July 2026.
Is SB 343 enforceable right now?
No. On 14 July 2026 the US District Court for the Southern District of California issued a preliminary injunction in No. 3:26-cv-01675, and CalRecycle says it only blocks enforcement of SB 343. Reports say the Attorney General is enjoined until further order. How far it reaches other enforcers is read differently by different law firms.
Which materials meet the SB 343 60% test?
On CalRecycle’s June 2026 data, 35 of 91 material types meet both 60% lines by SPI’s count, including cardboard, paperboard, PET and HDPE bottles, PP rigids, aluminium and steel cans, non-CRV glass and non-CRV cartons. All plastic films and bags, polystyrene formats and multi-material laminates miss both lines, and design limits also apply.
Are cartons recyclable under SB 343?
CalRecycle makes no recyclability determinations. Its June 2026 update shows non-CRV gable-top and aseptic cartons sorted by facilities serving 62% of surveyed counties, or 21 of 34, with curbside access of 74% and 72%. That clears both 60% lines, but only by one county, and the figure has changed three times since April 2025.
What happens to SB 343 if the injunction is lifted?
If the injunction dissolves, the restriction would again be enforceable for items manufactured after 4 October 2026, and the public sources cited do not say whether items made during the injunction would be excused. If the plaintiffs win, a permanent injunction may follow, law firms report. Either way, CalRecycle’s 2027 study goes ahead.
Sources
- California Legislative Information, Public Resources Code section 42355.51, consulted 2026-11-09.
- California Senate Judiciary Committee, SB 343 (Allen) analysis for the hearing of 6 April 2021, consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, SB 343: Accurate Recycling Labels, consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, SB 343 Frequently Asked Questions (13 August 2025), consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, SB 343 Material Characterization Study Final Findings 2023/2024, DRRR-2025-1750 (April 2025), consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, Table 2 update bulletin (8 August 2025), consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, Table 2 update letter (22 December 2025), consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, Statement on update to SB 343 Final Findings Report (23 December 2025), consulted 2026-11-09.
- CalRecycle, Table 2 update letter (24 June 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Resource Recycling, Federal judge blocks California Truth in Recycling (SB 343) enforcement (15 July 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Packaging Dive, SB 343 preliminary injunction granted (15 July 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Farella Braun and Martel, Federal court enjoins the California AG from enforcing SB 343 (15 July 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Kahn, Soares and Conway, Court grants preliminary injunction in SB 343 case (20 July 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Saul Ewing, SB 343 enjoined: federal court blocks enforcement of California’s Truth in Recycling law (21 July 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Steptoe, California court blocks enforcement of SB 343 Truth in Recycling law, consulted 2026-11-09.
- Keller and Heckman, Further delay in SB 343 legal challenge (24 September 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Keller and Heckman, Court denies intervention request in SB 343 challenge (29 September 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- Keller and Heckman, SB 343 court removes ENE conference from calendar while considering request to add SB 54 claims (27 October 2026), consulted 2026-11-09.
- SPI Regulation Tracker, PR-US-011 (SB 343) and PR-US-004 (SB 54) rule notes, data as of 2026-10-14.
- SPI Packaging Buyers Database, Amazon, Colgate-Palmolive and Walmart profiles, data as of 2026-10-14.
- SPI Ledger 38, US recycled content and labelling laws beyond EPR, consulted 2026-11-09.
- SPI Ledger 72, California SB 54 permanent regulations, consulted 2026-11-09.
Go deeper
- SPI Regulation TrackerPR-US-011
- SPI LedgerFlexible plastic is the format brands are furthest from making recyclable, and most EPR tables already charge it a premiumFlexible plastic packaging trails rigid by a wide margin on recyclability (Unilever reports 75% of its rigid plastic packaging but 15% of its flexible plastic packaging…
- SPI LedgerPackaging deadlines from 2026 to 2030 cluster in 2026 and on 1 January 2030Between 2026 and 2030, 21 of the 79 rules in the SPI Regulation Tracker take effect, and adding the staged steps inside rules gives 70 dated…
- SPI dataSPI Buyers DatabasePublic packaging targets of brand owners and retailers, each with reported progress, status and company source. Free to filter and download as CSV.