SPI LedgerNews analysis
Colgate recyclable tube: 98% of toothpaste SKUs switched, and how SB 343, UK RAM and PPWR grades treat it
The Colgate recyclable tube now carries about 98% of Colgate-Palmolive’s toothpaste SKUs worldwide and about 97% in North America, according to its 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, issued on 30 June 2026. The switch began in 2019, and the tube is sold in more than 70 countries.
~98%
Toothpaste SKUs moved to the recyclable tube, global
About 97% in North America
Colgate-Palmolive
27%
Post-consumer recycled plastic in packaging, 2025
Goal was at least 25%
Colgate-Palmolive
32%
Cut in virgin plastic against 2019, 2025
2030 goal is 33%
Colgate-Palmolive
Source: Colgate-Palmolive 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, pages 10 and 40 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Company figures for 2025, the latest year Colgate-Palmolive has reported. The SKU share counts product lines, not tubes sold or tonnes. Packaging progress excludes external co-packing and co-manufacturing, recent pet food acquisitions and minority-owned joint ventures.
That SKU share is a design fact, not a recycling outcome. Colgate’s own footnote warns that local programmes may not yet accept tubes, and the three rulebooks that will judge the tube each ask a different question: California’s SB 343 asks whether a label claim is backed by collection and sorting, the UK’s recyclability assessment methodology (RAM) asks whether the tube rates red, amber or green, and the EU’s PPWR asks what design grade it earns from 2030.
| Packaging measure | 2025 goal | 2024 result | 2025 result | Gap to 2025 goal (points) | 2030 goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Post-consumer recycled plastic in packaging | At least 25 | 21 | 27 | +2.0 | None stated |
| Packaging recyclable, reusable or compostable | 100 | Not given | 96 | -4.0 | All packaging designed for recycling |
| Cut in virgin plastic against 2019 | One third | 25 | 32 | -1.3 | 33 |
| Toothpaste SKUs on the recyclable tube | No report goal | Not given | ~98 | Not applicable | None stated |
Source: Colgate-Palmolive 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, pages 10, 13, 39 and 40; SPI calculation (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Gap = 2025 result minus 2025 goal, by SPI's calculation; a third is taken as 33.3%. The report gives no 2024 figure for the recyclable, reusable or compostable share in the pages SPI consulted; it gives 81% for 2019. The 2030 design goal is a different test from the 2025 recyclable, reusable or compostable share.
Executive summary
Colgate-Palmolive’s 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, issued on 30 June 2026 and covering progress to the end of 2025, says the company has moved about 98% of its toothpaste SKUs globally, and about 97% in North America, to its recyclable tube since 2019. The tube is available in more than 70 countries. Around it sit three portfolio numbers: 27% post-consumer recycled (PCR) plastic in packaging against a goal of at least 25%, 96% of packaging recyclable, reusable or compostable against a 100% goal, and a 32% cut in virgin plastic against 2019, where the goal was a third.
The 2030 goals are narrower and closer than the 2025 ones. Colgate keeps a 33% virgin plastic cut against 2019, one point beyond its 2025 result, and replaces the recyclable, reusable or compostable share with a new aim: all packaging designed for recycling. That second goal uses the same words as the EU’s Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR), whose design-for-recycling test applies from 1 January 2030 at the earliest.
The tube itself is a high-density polyethylene (HDPE) design. RecyClass, the European recyclability body, accepts it as compatible with HDPE recycling on conditions: a white PE body, PE closures and seals, and ethylene vinyl alcohol (EVOH) barrier capped at 5% of the tube’s weight. It also records mass losses of around 20% from a PET insert.
The rules read that design in different ways. In California, SB 343 enforcement has been blocked by a federal injunction since 14 July 2026, and CalRecycle’s study has seven HDPE rows but none for tubes. In the UK, RAM 2027 names some toothpaste tube designs as rigid plastic, which opens the door to a green rating, but only if the format is commonly collected. Under the PPWR the grade criteria do not yet exist; the Commission’s delegated acts are due by 1 January 2028.
For packaging suppliers and brand teams, the reading is that Colgate has finished the design work on almost every SKU and now depends on collection and sorting it does not control. The 2% of SKUs still to move matter less than the rating each market gives the 98%.
Key findings
- About 98% of Colgate’s toothpaste SKUs globally and about 97% in North America use the recyclable tube, in more than 70 countries (2025 SSI Report, page 40). The share counts SKUs, not tubes sold or tonnes.
- PCR plastic rose from 21% in 2024 to 27% in 2025, 2 points above the goal of at least 25% (page 10).
- Virgin plastic was 32% below 2019 in 2025, against 25% in 2024; the 2030 goal of 33% needs 1 more point over five years, or 0.2 points a year, by SPI’s calculation.
- Packaging recyclable, reusable or compostable was 96% in 2025, up from 81% in 2019, 4 points short of the 100% goal; reusable or refillable packaging was 1.1% by weight.
- RecyClass caps EVOH at 5% of the tube’s weight, the same 5% line at which RAM 2027 turns HDPE packaging red.
- SPI calculation: on PackUK’s illustrative year 2 plastic fees, a green rather than red rating is worth GBP 130 a tonne in 2026 to 2027, rising to about GBP 495 a tonne by 2028 to 2029 if the base fees held.
- In the Philippines the recovery target rises from 60% of the 2025 footprint at the end of 2026 to 80% from 2028, and rigid and flexible plastic cannot offset each other, so the tube’s classification matters there too.
Colgate recyclable tube: what the 2025 report shows
Colgate-Palmolive reports packaging in its annual Sustainability & Social Impact (SSI) Report. The 2025 edition was issued as of 30 June 2026 and covers progress through the end of 2025. The tube appears in two places. Page 9 lists it among the results of the company’s 2025 product footprint work, and page 40 gives the rollout figures.
The core text on page 40 is short. Since 2019, Colgate says, it has moved about 98% of its toothpaste SKUs globally and about 97% in North America to the recyclable tube, which is accessible in more than 70 countries. A footnote attached to the tube claim says that a reader’s community may not yet accept tubes for recycling, and tells readers to check locally. Page 41 adds that a partner company, Stina Inc., works across the tube recycling value chain in North America and Europe on tube recyclability.
Page 9 gives the tube’s footprint case. Colgate says the recyclable tube uses up to 26% less carbon and saves up to 40% water compared with its non-recyclable tube, based on a 2022 third-party study, and notes that the figures are not a full cradle-to-grave comparison. SPI has not yet confirmed the study’s method or boundary.
The tube began as a 2019 project. Colgate’s release on the first-of-its-kind tube said it chose HDPE, the No. 2 plastic used for milk jugs and other bottles, and that the Association of Plastic Recyclers (APR) in the US recognised the tube in June 2019 after more than five years of development. The same release said Tom’s of Maine would complete its switch in 2020, when the Colgate brand would start the transition in Europe and North America, and that Colgate was sharing the technology with competitors. Ledger 29, on home and personal care packaging, set Colgate’s 2025 portfolio figures beside Henkel, Reckitt and Kimberly-Clark; this piece stays with the tube and the rules that judge it.
What 98% of SKUs does and does not measure
The SPI Buyers Database profile of Colgate-Palmolive carried the same 98% and 97% figures, and the report confirms them. The figure is still easy to over-read. Exhibit 2 sets out what it covers.
| Question | What the report says | What it leaves open |
|---|---|---|
| How much of the range uses the tube? | ~98% of toothpaste SKUs globally | Share of tubes sold or of tube tonnage |
| How much in North America? | ~97% of toothpaste SKUs | SKU count; California share |
| Where is it sold? | More than 70 countries | Which countries; EU, UK, Philippines or Brazil shares |
| What is still to move? | About 2% of SKUs globally, 3% in North America (SPI calculation) | Which formats or brands make up the rest |
| Is it recycled? | Communities may not yet accept tubes | Collection and sorting rates by market |
| Which entities count? | Excludes co-packing, recent pet food acquisitions and minority-owned joint ventures | Whether third-party made tubes are recyclable |
Source: Colgate-Palmolive 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, pages 9, 10, 40 and 41; SPI analysis (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
SPI interpretation of the report's wording. Remaining SKUs are 100 minus the reported share, by SPI's calculation, and are approximate because Colgate reports the shares with a tilde. Colgate does not publish its count of toothpaste SKUs, tube tonnage or tube sales by market in the report.
Three readings follow. First, an SKU share weights a small travel tube the same as a family pack, so the share of tonnes could be higher or lower than 98%. Second, the boundary matters. Page 10 of the report excludes external co-packing and co-manufacturing, recent pet food acquisitions and minority-owned joint ventures from packaging progress, while a footnote on page 38 uses the phrase non-majority-owned joint ventures. SPI has not yet confirmed whether the two footnotes describe the same set. Third, the claim is about design. The report itself separates the tube from recycling in practice, which is the test regulators apply.
SPI analysis
For a supplier the finished 98% changes the commercial question. The remaining 2% is unlikely to drive tube volumes; the material choice in each new tube contract, and evidence that recyclers accept the tube in each market, will.
The 2030 goals: one point on virgin plastic, a new test on design
Colgate set its 2030 packaging goals on page 13 of the report: reduce virgin plastic by 33% against a 2019 baseline, and make all packaging designed for recycling. A third goal, under forests, commits to sourcing only deforestation- and conversion-free paper-based packaging materials. There is no 2030 recycled content goal and no 2030 reuse goal in the pages SPI consulted. Exhibit 3 turns the goals into the pace each needs.
| Measure | 2019 | 2024 | 2025 | 2030 goal | Gap from 2025 (points) | Needed a year | Recent step a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cut in virgin plastic against 2019 | 0 | 25 | 32 | 33 | 1.0 | 0.2 | 7.0 |
| Recyclable, reusable or compostable, then designed for recycling | 81 | Not given | 96 | 100 | 4.0 | 0.8 | 2.5 |
| PCR plastic in packaging | Not given | 21 | 27 | No goal | Not applicable | Not applicable | 6.0 |
Source: SPI calculation from Colgate-Palmolive 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, pages 10, 13, 39 and 40 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Needed pace = 2030 goal minus 2025 result, divided by five years. The recyclability row compares a 2025 recyclable, reusable or compostable share with a 2030 designed-for-recycling goal, which Colgate measures differently, so its pace is indicative only. Colgate gives no 2024 recyclability figure in the pages consulted, so the recent step uses the 2019 to 2025 average.
On these numbers the virgin plastic goal is close to met five years early. The 2025 step of 7 points was 35 times the yearly pace the 2030 goal needs. SPI analysis: the risk to the 33% line is not pace but growth and boundary. Colgate measures virgin plastic by weight, so volume growth, or acquisitions brought into the boundary, can push absolute virgin tonnes back up even while PCR rises. The report’s exclusion of recent pet food acquisitions is the kind of boundary choice that will matter when those businesses join the count.
The design goal is the harder one to read. The 96% share mixes recyclable, reusable and compostable packaging, and the report does not say which test it uses for recyclable. The 2030 goal uses the words designed for recycling, which is the PPWR test under Article 6(2)(a). The EU grades will rest on criteria the Commission has not yet adopted, so Colgate’s 2030 goal and the EU test may not use the same yardstick.
In practice: toothbrush packs.
The tube is not the only format change. The report says new recyclable toothbrush packaging cuts plastic by 90% to 98% per package against the previous plastic blister, that it launched first on elmex and meridol toothbrushes in Europe, and that rollout on Colgate toothbrushes in North America began in 2025. Colgate’s August 2026 release says paper packs will be made across Colgate, elmex, meridol and Tom’s of Maine this year, with toothbrushes in nearly 200 countries following next year. A fibre pack moves the toothbrush into the paper stream, where each rulebook here has a well-defined route.
What makes the tube recyclable: the design conditions
The tube is recyclable only because every part of it is designed to pass with HDPE. RecyClass, which assesses packaging for European recyclers, tested Colgate’s tube, labelled S.-VF1 in its notice, under its recyclability evaluation protocol for HDPE containers, with laboratory work by the Institut für Kunststofftechnologie und -recycling. The notice gives no approval date. The file name of the approval letter linked from it carries the date 23 January 2020, and SPI has not yet confirmed that date as the date of approval. Exhibit 4 lists the conditions.
| Component | RecyClass condition | RAM 2027 rule for HDPE or PP packaging |
|---|---|---|
| Body | White, made of PE | Direct printing on clear or white HDPE or PP is red, except batch code or expiry date |
| Closures, liners, seals, valves | Made of PE | Caps of steel, aluminium, PS, PVC or thermoset are red |
| Barrier | EVOH limited to 5% of the tube's total weight | EVOH above 5% by weight is red |
| Insert | PET insert causes mass losses of around 20% | Not set out as an automatic red in the summary rules |
| Recyclate | Minimal difference from HDPE bottles without the tube | Not a RAM test |
Source: RecyClass: Colgate-Palmolive's recyclable toothpaste tube tested by RecyClass; Colgate-Palmolive release on the recyclable tube (2019); GOV.UK RAM 2027 materials assessment guidance (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
RecyClass lists these conditions among others; the full list is in its product approval letter. The RAM column is SPI's reading of the RAM 2027 HDPE and PP rules as they would apply to a tube with that feature; it is not a rating of Colgate's tube. Not legal advice.
The overlap is the useful part. RecyClass’s 5% EVOH cap and RAM 2027’s 5% red line are the same number, so a tube built to the RecyClass conditions clears the UK barrier rule by design. Two items carry more risk. The PET insert is a non-PE part that RecyClass accepted with a yield penalty, and RAM 2027 judges the full item. The second is decoration: RAM 2027 makes direct printing on white HDPE a red feature, and SPI has not yet confirmed whether a printed laminate tube counts as direct printing under that rule. That is a question for each tube’s specification, not for Colgate’s report.
SPI analysis
The same tube therefore carries three readings of one design: APR recognition in the US in 2019, RecyClass approval with conditions in Europe, dated only by a file name to January 2020, and a UK rating that each producer must assess for itself. None of these is a rule. Each rule below asks its own question.
Industry reaction
Colgate frames the tube as an engineering problem it solved by choosing the material recyclers already handle.
“Chosen because it is already widely recycled, HDPE had been thought to be too rigid to make a squeezable tube.”
In its 2025 report the company moves the emphasis from design to recycling practice across the whole category.
“We continue to share our recyclable tube technology, expertise and information with stakeholders and work to promote the recyclability of all tubes in practice and at scale.”
RecyClass sets the barrier limit that keeps the tube compatible with HDPE recycling.
“The use of EVOH as a functional barrier, on the other hand, must be limited to 5% of the total weight of the tube.”
California’s regulator points to the next data point that will decide labels.
“The law requires CalRecycle to revise the study in 2027 and every five years after that.”
SPI analysis
The company speaks of practice and scale, the recycler body of grams of barrier, and the regulator of a statewide study. The tube’s status in each market will be settled by the third of those.
A framework: SPI's five-rule tube test
SPI’s tracker records five rules that reach Colgate’s tube in the markets named in its Buyers Database profile. They ask four kinds of question: may the pack carry a claim, what rating sets its fee, what grade lets it be sold, and how much of it must be recovered. Exhibit 5 is SPI’s grid.
| Rule | Question it asks | Unit tested | What decides the tube | Status at 18 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| California SB 343, PR-US-011 | May the pack carry the chasing arrows or a recyclable claim? | Each product or package | Collection for 60% of Californians and sorting for 60% of programmes | Enforcement blocked by injunction since 14 Jul 2026 |
| UK EPR fee modulation, PR-GB-003 | Is the item red, amber or green? | Each household packaging item | RAM rules for rigid plastic and the commonly collected test | Fees modulated from 2026 to 2027; confirmed fees due |
| EU PPWR recyclability, PR-EU-010 | Does the pack reach grade C, then B? | Each packaging unit | Design-for-recycling criteria in delegated acts | Article 6(1) applies; graded test from 2030 at earliest |
| Philippines RA 11898, PR-PH-001 | Has the obliged enterprise recovered its footprint share? | Footprint by kilograms, rigid and flexible apart | Recovery or offset volumes, audited | 60% target for 2026 |
| Brazil Decree 11.413, PR-BR-001 | Can the company prove its reverse logistics target? | Mass returned to production, by invoice | Validated invoices behind recycling credits | Certificates in use; voluntary route |
Source: SPI tracker records PR-US-011, PR-GB-003, PR-EU-010, PR-PH-001 and PR-BR-001; CalRecycle SB 343 page; GOV.UK RAM 2027 guidance; SPI Buyers Database, Colgate-Palmolive profile (SPI summary), checked 13 Oct 2026.
SPI business analysis of published information, not an assessment of compliance and not legal advice. Penalties are in their own currencies and are not comparable across rows. The Philippine and Brazilian rows depend on the status of Colgate's local companies, which SPI has not yet confirmed.
The grid sorts the rules into two families. California, the UK and the EU look at the pack: its design, its label, its rating. The Philippines and Brazil look at the system: tonnes collected and proved. SPI analysis: a recyclable tube helps directly in the first family. In the second it helps only through cheaper recovery, because a tube that HDPE recyclers buy is easier to collect and certify than a laminate that no one buys.
California SB 343: no tube row in the study, and an injunction
SB 343 amended Public Resources Code section 42355.51 so that the chasing arrows, or any statement suggesting recyclability, may appear on a product or package only if it is collected and processed for recycling in California. CalRecycle’s FAQ sets the statewide test: acceptance by programmes serving at least 60% of Californians, and sorting by large volume facilities serving at least 60% of programmes, plus design limits and reclamation consistent with the Basel Convention. The restriction applies to items manufactured after 4 October 2026.
Enforcement is on hold. CalRecycle’s page says a preliminary injunction issued on 14 July 2026 in California League of Food Producers v. Bonta, No. 3:26-CV-01675 in the Southern District of California, blocks enforcement of SB 343, and that the 4 October 2026 date may be affected by the litigation. CalRecycle’s study duties continue. SPI’s Ledger 126 on SB 343 covers the case and the study in full; Exhibit 6 adds the rows that matter to a tube.
| MT&F code | Row name | Table 1 collection | Table 2 sorting |
|---|---|---|---|
| PL09 | HDPE clear beverage bottles, non-CRV | 99 | 100 |
| PL10 | HDPE clear beverage bottles, CRV | 99 | SAP |
| PL11 | HDPE buckets, food | 88 | 100 |
| PL12 | HDPE buckets, non-food | 88 | 100 |
| PL13 | Other HDPE clear single-use rigids | 92 | 100 |
| PL14 | HDPE pigmented single-use rigids | 92 | 100 |
| PL15 | Other HDPE multi-use rigids | 88 | 100 |
Source: CalRecycle, SB 343 Material Characterization Study Final Findings 2023/2024, DRRR-2025-1750, Tables 1 and 2 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Table 1 is the share of Californians with curbside access whose programme accepts the material type and form (MT&F); Table 2 is the share of surveyed counties served by sorting facilities. SAP means subject to another programme. CalRecycle makes no product-by-product determination; the MT&F a tube belongs to is for the manufacturer to establish. Not legal advice.
The table shows the opportunity and the gap. If a white HDPE tube belonged in PL14, pigmented single-use rigids, it would sit in a row that clears collection at 92% and sorting at 100%. But no row names tubes, and CalRecycle’s FAQ says it makes no product-by-product determination and suggests the APR Design Guide size-sorting tests to assign a material type and form. A squeezed, flattened tube behaves differently on a sorting line from a pigmented bottle, which is exactly what those tests examine. SPI has not yet confirmed which row CalRecycle or Colgate would assign.
The SPI Buyers Database profile records that about 97% of Colgate’s North American toothpaste SKUs use the tube. SPI analysis: Colgate’s own footnote, that communities may not yet accept tubes, is the kind of qualifier SB 343’s alternative paths in section 42355.51(d)(4) to (d)(6) deal with; whether any qualifier is enough under the statute is a legal question this piece does not answer. The practical point for 2027 is timing. The next full study is due in 2027, and manufacturers get 18 months after each study to bring claims in line, so the tube’s California row may be settled by fieldwork that has not yet been done. SB 54 then adopts SB 343’s recyclability standards under section 42050(b) from 2032, so the same row will matter for EPR.
UK RAM: rigid by name, rated by collection
UK packaging extended producer responsibility (EPR) charges large producers disposal fees on household packaging, modulated by a red, amber or green rating from the 2026 assessment year. PackUK’s modulation statement uplifts only red packaging, by a factor of 1.2 in 2026 to 2027, 1.6 in 2027 to 2028 and 2.0 in 2028 to 2029, and uses the extra money for an equal percentage discount on green; amber pays the base fee. SPI’s Ledger 42 on RAM ratings explains the mechanism.
RAM 2027, published on 1 July 2026 and last updated on 20 August 2026, applies to packaging supplied in 2027; RAM 1.1 still governs 2025 and 2026 data. The 2027 materials guidance is explicit about tubes. It defines rigid plastics as structures that do not flex easily or change shape much as the contents are used, and it lists tubes, including mono-material laminates, among rigid formats, giving some toothpaste tube designs as the example. Flexible plastics must be rated red unless a take-back scheme supports amber, and cannot be green. Exhibit 7 sets out the tests a tube then meets.
| RAM 2027 stage or rule | What it says | Effect on a tube |
|---|---|---|
| Rigid or flexible | Tubes including mono-material laminates are rigid; some toothpaste tubes are named | Assessed as rigid plastic; multi-material tubes not named |
| Collection | Rigid PE, PP and PET green if collected at kerbside by at least 75% of UK local authorities | Decides green or not; tubes need to count as commonly collected |
| Not commonly collected | Amber only with take-back evidence at every stage; otherwise red | Default red without collection or take-back |
| Barrier | EVOH above 5% by weight in HDPE or PP is red | A RecyClass-compliant tube passes |
| Decoration | Direct printing on clear or white HDPE or PP is red, except batch or expiry codes | Turns on how the tube is printed |
| Size | Green needs at least 40 mm in at least 2 dimensions | A full-size tube passes; small parts must reattach |
| Chemicals | More than 1 part per million total PFAS is automatically red | Applies to every item |
Source: GOV.UK (PackUK), RAM 2027 materials assessment guidance, published 1 July 2026, updated 20 August 2026 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
SPI summary of selected RAM 2027 rules as they bear on a plastic tube; not every rule is shown and this is not a rating of any company's tube. An item is reported red if it is assessed red at any stage. RAM 1.1 applies to 2025 and 2026 data and SPI has not yet confirmed its wording on tubes. Not legal advice.
SPI analysis
The guidance gives a mono-material tube the best possible starting point, rigid plastic with green available, and then hands the decision to collection. RAM’s commonly collected test is about local authority kerbside acceptance. SPI has not yet confirmed whether UK councils’ accepted-materials lists, as RAM applies them, cover plastic tubes. If they do not, an HDPE tube is red by default in 2027 unless a take-back scheme meeting RAM’s coverage test supports amber. The SPI Buyers Database profile expected the recyclable tube to support a better UK fee band; on RAM 2027’s wording that holds only if the collection test is met.
The fee calendar runs on a lag. Year 2 fees for 2026 to 2027 rest on 2025 data rated under RAM 1.1. GOV.UK’s guidance on disposal fees, last updated on 28 October 2026, links only illustrative year 2 fees for 2026 to 2027, and PackUK’s operational plan puts the initial notice of liability for 2026 to 2027 by the end of November 2026. SPI has not yet confirmed confirmed year 2 fees at 18 November 2026.
Scenarios: the tube's UK fee under three ratings
Exhibit 8 prices one illustrative block of 1,000 tonnes of plastic tubes under each rating. It uses PackUK’s year 2 illustrative plastic fees of GBP 415 a tonne green, GBP 455 amber and GBP 545 red, published on 16 December 2025, which PackUK says are subject to change. Colgate does not publish its UK tube tonnage; the 1,000 tonnes is a unit for scale, not an estimate.
| Rating case | 2026 to 2027 fee a tonne | 2026 to 2027 on 1,000 t | 2027 to 2028 on 1,000 t | 2028 to 2029 on 1,000 t |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| High: green (commonly collected, all rules met) | 415 | 415,000 | 415,000 | 415,000 |
| Base: amber (take-back evidence) | 455 | 455,000 | 455,000 | 455,000 |
| Low: red (not collected, no take-back) | 545 | 545,000 | 728,000 | 910,000 |
| Red minus green | 130 | 130,000 | 313,000 | 495,000 |
Source: SPI calculation from GOV.UK (PackUK), Year 2 illustrative waste disposal fees (16 December 2025) and the PackUK modulation statement factors in PR-GB-003 (SPI summary), checked 13 Oct 2026.
GBP only. 2026 to 2027 uses the published illustrative fees. Later years hold the amber base at GBP 455 and green at GBP 415 and apply the red factors of 1.6 and 2.0; real base fees and the green discount will change. Illustrative 1,000 tonnes; Colgate's UK tonnage is not published. Not a forecast and not tax or legal advice.
The gap grows because only the red factor rises. SPI calculation: holding the base fees, the cost of a red rating over green rises from GBP 130 a tonne to GBP 313 in 2027 to 2028 and GBP 495 in 2028 to 2029, about 3.8 times in two years. The 2028 to 2029 year is also the first charged on 2027 supply, rated under RAM 2027, so the tube’s classification as rigid and its collection status land in the year the red factor reaches 2.0.
SPI analysis
For a brand with a near-complete tube switch, the amber case is the likely planning line until UK kerbside collection of tubes is documented. Amber needs a take-back scheme with collection points within 5 miles of at least 75% of the UK population or a postal service reaching 75% of addresses, and traceability through every stage, according to the RAM 2027 overview as summarised in Ledger 42. That makes the tube a candidate for an industry take-back scheme, which is the role Colgate’s report gives its partner on tube recycling.
PPWR grades: the tube against the 70%, 80% and 95% lines
Article 6(1) of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 says all packaging placed on the market shall be recyclable, and the Commission reads it as applying from 12 August 2026. The measurable test comes later. Article 6(2)(a), design for material recycling, applies from 1 January 2030 or 24 months after the Article 6(4) delegated acts enter into force, whichever is later; the acts are due by 1 January 2028. Recital 28 sets performance grades A, B and C, treats packaging below grade C as technically non-recyclable and raises the floor to grade B from 1 January 2038. Recital 35 foresees EPR fees modulated by grade. SPI’s tracker record PR-EU-010 holds the dates, and Ledger 66 on PPWR grades sets out the Annex II thresholds from unofficial reproductions of the text.
| Grade | Score line | Market access | Reading against RecyClass's ~20% mass loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 95% or more | Allowed | A score built on yield alone would not reach A |
| B | 80% or more | Allowed, and the floor from 1 Jan 2038 | Yield of about 80% sits on the B line |
| C | 70% or more | Allowed until 31 Dec 2037 | Clears C |
| Below C | Under 70% | Technically non-recyclable; not allowed | Not reached on yield alone |
Source: Regulation (EU) 2025/40, recitals 28 and 35 as recorded in PR-EU-010; Annex II Table 3 thresholds as set out in SPI Ledger 66; RecyClass notice on Colgate's tube; SPI analysis (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Thresholds from unofficial reproductions of Annex II Table 3, not yet confirmed against the Official Journal. The scoring method is for the Article 6(4) delegated acts, which do not yet exist. The RecyClass column is an SPI illustration of a yield figure beside the score lines, not a grade and not an assessment of Colgate's tube.
The exhibit is a sensitivity, not a forecast. Annex II Table 4, as Ledger 66 records, lists design parameters such as additives, labels, closures, adhesives, colorants, inks and separability; the weighting that turns them into a score is still to be written. SPI analysis: a yield of about 80% next to a grade B line of 80% shows why tube makers will read the delegated acts closely. A mono-PE tube with a PET insert could land either side of a grade boundary depending on how inserts are weighted. The 2038 step to grade B is the one that would bite, and Colgate’s 2030 goal of all packaging designed for recycling will be measured against grades it cannot yet see.
Three EU points sit beside the grade. First, SPI has not yet confirmed which Annex II Table 1 category a PE tube falls into, PE rigid or PE flexible; RAM 2027 treats mono-material tubes as rigid, but the EU table is a separate list. Second, the UK and EU systems are separate: PR-GB-003 records that a green UK rating does not establish an EU grade. Third, until Article 6(2)(a) bites, manufacturers keep meeting the essential requirements carried over from Directive 94/62/EC, using standards such as EN 13430:2004, according to Commission Notice C/2026/3084.
Philippines and Brazil: recovery, not design
The SPI Buyers Database profile records operating companies of Colgate-Palmolive in the Philippines and Brazil in the company’s subsidiary list. In both markets the rule counts tonnes recovered rather than grades.
Philippines. Republic Act No. 11898, the Extended Producer Responsibility Act of 2022, obliges large enterprises to recover or offset a rising share of their plastic packaging footprint. Exhibit 10 shows the path. SPI has not yet confirmed that Colgate’s Philippine company is a large enterprise under the Act’s asset test, so the targets are shown as they apply to any obliged enterprise.
The tube’s classification matters here as well. Section 44-C(a) of the amended Act places sachets, labels and laminates among flexible packaging, while section 44-C(b) covers rigid packaging for home and personal care. Under the implementing rules, DAO 2023-02, rigid and flexible recovery cannot offset each other. SPI analysis: a tube treated as rigid in the UK may be treated as a laminate in the Philippines; SPI has not yet confirmed how DENR classes a mono-PE tube. Missing a target costs PHP 5,000,000 to PHP 10,000,000 for a first offence, or twice the cost of recovering the shortfall, whichever is higher, under section 49(g).
Brazil. Decree 11.413 of 13 February 2023 gives companies with a reverse logistics duty under Article 33 of Law 12.305 three certificates to prove their targets: recycling credits for mass already returned to production, structuring project certificates and future mass credits. Use is voluntary, credits rest on electronic invoices validated by an accredited third party with the Federal Revenue Service, and only invoices from the current or previous fiscal year count. The fine for failing a reverse logistics obligation is BRL 5,000 to BRL 50 million under Article 62 XII of Decree 6.514 of 2008. SPI analysis: an HDPE tube that recyclers buy produces sale invoices that can back recycling credits; a laminate that goes to landfill does not. SPI has not yet confirmed what share of Colgate’s Brazilian toothpaste uses the recyclable tube.
Pace and position: where the tube leaves Colgate
Exhibit 11 brings the dates together. The tube’s status in each market turns on decisions due between November 2026 and 2030, most of them outside Colgate’s control.
- past
- next
- APR recognises Colgate's HDPE tubepast
- RecyClass approval letter for HDPE streams, dated only by its file name; SPI has not yet confirmed the datepast
- CalRecycle final findings start the SB 343 18-month clockpast
- Colgate's 2025 SSI Report: ~98% of toothpaste SKUs on the tubepast
- PackUK publishes RAM 2027, naming some toothpaste tubes as rigidpast
- Injunction blocks SB 343 enforcementpast
- PPWR Article 6(1) appliespast
- UK 2026 to 2027 notices of liability due by end of monthnext
- Philippine target: 60% of the 2025 footprintnext
- UK red factor rises to 1.6next
- CalRecycle's next full SB 343 study due during 2027next
- PPWR delegated acts on grades duenext
- Earliest PPWR design test; Colgate's 2030 goalsnext
Source: Colgate-Palmolive reports and releases; RecyClass; CalRecycle; GOV.UK (PackUK); SPI tracker records PR-US-011, PR-GB-003, PR-EU-010, PR-PH-001 and PR-BR-001 (SPI summary), checked 18 Nov 2026.
Category shows past or next from 18 November 2026. Not legal advice.
Show the data
| Date | Label | Category | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019-06 | APR recognises Colgate's HDPE tube | past | https://www.colgatepalmolive.com/en-us/news/first-of-its-kind-recyclable-toothpaste-tube |
| 2020-01 | RecyClass approval letter for HDPE streams, dated only by its file name; SPI has not yet confirmed the date | past | https://recyclass.eu/news/colgate-palmolives-recyclable-toothpaste-tube-tested-by-recyclass |
| 2025-04-04 | CalRecycle final findings start the SB 343 18-month clock | past | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
| 2026-06-30 | Colgate's 2025 SSI Report: ~98% of toothpaste SKUs on the tube | past | https://www.colgatepalmolive.com/content/dam/cp-sites-aem/corporate/corporate/common/pdf/cp-2025-ssi-report.pdf |
| 2026-07-01 | PackUK publishes RAM 2027, naming some toothpaste tubes as rigid | past | https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/assess-packaging-recyclability-recyclability-assessment-methodology-ram-2027/ram-2027-materials-assessment-guidance |
| 2026-07-14 | Injunction blocks SB 343 enforcement | past | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
| 2026-08-12 | PPWR Article 6(1) applies | past | https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:C_202603084 |
| 2026-11-30 | UK 2026 to 2027 notices of liability due by end of month | next | https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/packuk-operational-plan/packuk-operational-plan-2026-to-2027 |
| 2026-12-31 | Philippine target: 60% of the 2025 footprint | next | https://ldr.senate.gov.ph/legislative-issuance/republic-act-no-11898 |
| 2027-04-01 | UK red factor rises to 1.6 | next | https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/extended-producer-responsibility-for-packaging-modulated-disposal-fees/packuk-extended-producer-responsibility-epr-for-packaging-producer-disposal-fees-modulation-statement |
| 2027-12-31 | CalRecycle's next full SB 343 study due during 2027 | next | https://calrecycle.ca.gov/wcs/recyclinglabels/ |
| 2028-01-01 | PPWR delegated acts on grades due | next | https://green-forum.ec.europa.eu/packaging-and-packaging-waste-regulation-implementation_en |
| 2030-01-01 | Earliest PPWR design test; Colgate's 2030 goals | next | https://www.colgatepalmolive.com/content/dam/cp-sites-aem/corporate/corporate/common/pdf/cp-2025-ssi-report.pdf |
What leaders should do now
- Tube suppliers to Colgate and other oral care brands, in 2027 tube contracts: specify white PE bodies, PE closures and EVOH at 5% or less by weight, the RecyClass conditions that also clear RAM 2027’s barrier rule (Exhibits 4 and 7).
- UK packaging compliance teams, before the 2027 H1 RAM submission on 1 October 2027: document whether each tube counts as commonly collected under RAM 2027 and, if not, which take-back route supports amber, since a red tube costs about GBP 313 a tonne more than green in 2027 to 2028 on illustrative fees.
- Packaging engineers, ahead of the PPWR delegated acts due by 1 January 2028: score the PET insert and decoration of each tube design against the Annex II parameters, so a near-miss at the 80% grade B line is known before 2030.
- US label teams, while the SB 343 injunction holds: map each tube SKU to a CalRecycle material type and form using APR size-sorting tests, and keep alternative artwork ready for the 2027 study.
- Philippine and Brazilian operations, by 31 December 2026 and the 30 July 2027 entity reports: class tubes as rigid or flexible for recovery accounting, and collect the HDPE sale invoices that back recycling credits.
- Sustainability reporting teams, in the 2026 report: publish the tube share by tonnes and by market, and state which test sits behind the designed-for-recycling figure, so the 2030 goal can be read against the EU grades.
Questions for your board
- What share of our tube volume, by tonnes rather than SKUs, is mono-PE, and which markets does it sit in?
- Do our tubes count as commonly collected under RAM 2027, and what does red cost us at a 2.0 factor in 2028 to 2029?
- Which component of our tube would decide its PPWR grade, and how close is it to the 80% line?
- Which California material type and form do our tubes belong to, and who has tested them?
- Are tubes counted as rigid or flexible in our Philippine recovery plan?
- Does our 2030 design goal use the same test as the EU grades?
What to watch
- By 30 Nov 2026: PackUK’s initial 2026 to 2027 notices of liability and confirmed year 2 fees, replacing the illustrative GBP 415 to GBP 545 plastic fees used here.
- 31 Dec 2026: Philippine obliged enterprises must recover or offset 60% of their 2025 plastic packaging footprint.
- 1 Apr 2027: the UK red factor rises to 1.6 for 2027 to 2028.
- During 2027: CalRecycle’s next full SB 343 study, which starts a new 18-month window for claims; the injunction case continues.
- 1 Oct 2027: first RAM 2027 submissions, for packaging supplied in the first half of 2027.
- 1 Jan 2028: PPWR Article 6(4) delegated acts on design-for-recycling criteria and grades due.
- Date not set: Colgate-Palmolive’s 2026 SSI Report; the 2025 edition was issued on 30 June 2026.
Methodology
- Data used: Colgate-Palmolive’s 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report (issued 30 June 2026), its 2019 release on the recyclable tube and its August 2026 release on toothbrush packaging; the RecyClass notice on Colgate’s tube; CalRecycle’s SB 343 page and final findings DRRR-2025-1750; GOV.UK pages on RAM 2027, year 2 illustrative fees and disposal fees. All consulted on 18 November 2026.
- SPI data: SPI Buyers Database profile for Colgate-Palmolive and tracker records PR-US-011, PR-GB-003, PR-EU-010, PR-PH-001 and PR-BR-001, data as of 14 October 2026. The profile lists no sources, so every Colgate figure here was taken from Colgate-Palmolive’s own report or pages; where the profile and the source differ, the source is used.
- Company figures: Colgate’s figures are its own. The report states third-party assurance for greenhouse gas and certain energy, waste and water data and does not state assurance for packaging data in the pages SPI consulted.
- Calculations: labelled SPI calculation. Gaps and paces subtract and divide Colgate’s rounded percentages. UK fees multiply illustrative 1,000 tonne blocks by PackUK’s illustrative fees and factors. Money is in one currency at a time; nothing is summed or compared across GBP, PHP or BRL.
- Cut-off: 18 November 2026.
- Limitations: SPI has not yet confirmed Colgate’s toothpaste SKU count or tube tonnage by market, the method of the 2022 tube footprint study, the date and current validity of the RecyClass approval, the California material type and form for tubes, whether UK councils’ accepted lists cover tubes for RAM purposes, the PPWR Annex II category for a PE tube, the Philippine large-enterprise status of Colgate’s local company or the tube’s share in Brazil. Nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice.
FAQ
Is the Colgate toothpaste tube recyclable?
Colgate designs its tube from HDPE, the plastic used in milk jugs, and says about 98% of its toothpaste SKUs use it. Whether a tube is recycled depends on local collection: Colgate’s own report says communities may not yet accept tubes. RecyClass accepts the design in HDPE recycling on conditions, including EVOH at 5% or less.
How many Colgate toothpastes use the recyclable tube?
About 98% of Colgate-Palmolive’s toothpaste SKUs worldwide and about 97% in North America had moved to the recyclable tube by the end of 2025, according to its 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report. The switch began in 2019 and the tube is available in more than 70 countries. The share counts SKUs, not tonnes.
What are Colgate-Palmolive's 2030 packaging goals?
Colgate’s 2030 goals are a 33% cut in virgin plastic against 2019 and all packaging designed for recycling. It also aims to source only deforestation- and conversion-free paper-based packaging. At the end of 2025 virgin plastic was 32% below 2019, and 96% of packaging was recyclable, reusable or compostable, a related but different measure.
Can you put the Colgate recyclable tube in the recycling bin?
Only where the local programme accepts tubes. Colgate’s report tells readers their community may not yet accept tubes and to check locally. In California, SB 343 limits recyclable claims to items collected and sorted for most residents, though an injunction has blocked enforcement since 14 July 2026, and CalRecycle’s study has no tube row.
How does UK EPR rate a plastic toothpaste tube?
RAM 2027, for packaging supplied in 2027, treats tubes including mono-material laminates as rigid plastic, naming some toothpaste tubes. Rigid PE can be green if collected at kerbside by at least 75% of UK councils and other rules are met. Otherwise the tube is red, or amber with take-back evidence.
Will toothpaste tubes meet the EU PPWR recyclability rules?
The PPWR’s graded design test applies from 1 January 2030 at the earliest, using criteria the Commission must adopt by 1 January 2028. Packaging below grade C will be technically non-recyclable, and grade B becomes the floor in 2038. A tube’s grade will depend on how components such as inserts and barriers are scored.
Sources
- Colgate-Palmolive, 2025 Sustainability & Social Impact Report, issued 30 June 2026, consulted 2026-11-18.
- Colgate-Palmolive, first-of-its-kind recyclable toothpaste tube, 2019, consulted 2026-11-18.
- Colgate-Palmolive, Reimagining toothbrush packaging, August 2026, consulted 2026-11-18.
- RecyClass, Colgate-Palmolive’s recyclable toothpaste tube tested by RecyClass, consulted 2026-11-18.
- CalRecycle, SB 343 Accurate Recycling Labels, consulted 2026-11-18.
- CalRecycle, SB 343 Material Characterization Study Final Findings 2023/2024, DRRR-2025-1750, April 2025, consulted 2026-11-18.
- CalRecycle, SB 343 Frequently Asked Questions, August 2025, as recorded in PR-US-011, data as of 2026-10-14.
- GOV.UK (PackUK), RAM 2027 materials assessment guidance, updated 20 August 2026, consulted 2026-11-18.
- GOV.UK (PackUK), PackUK publishes recyclability assessment methodology RAM 2027, 1 July 2026, consulted 2026-11-18.
- GOV.UK (PackUK), Year 2 illustrative waste disposal fees, 16 December 2025, consulted 2026-11-18.
- GOV.UK, Waste disposal fees for large producers under EPR for packaging, updated 28 October 2026, consulted 2026-11-18.
- GOV.UK (PackUK), Producer disposal fees modulation statement, as recorded in PR-GB-003, data as of 2026-10-14.
- GOV.UK, PackUK operational plan 2026 to 2027, as recorded in PR-GB-003, data as of 2026-10-14.
- EUR-Lex, Commission Notice C/2026/3084, Guidance document for Regulation (EU) 2025/40, as recorded in PR-EU-010, data as of 2026-10-14.
- EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2025/40, recitals 28 to 35, as recorded in PR-EU-010, data as of 2026-10-14.
- European Commission Green Forum, PPWR implementation timeline, as recorded in PR-EU-010, data as of 2026-10-14.
- Senate of the Philippines, Republic Act No. 11898, as recorded in PR-PH-001, data as of 2026-10-14.
- FAOLEX, DENR Administrative Order No. 2023-02, as recorded in PR-PH-001, data as of 2026-10-14.
- Planalto, Decreto nº 11.413, de 13 de fevereiro de 2023, as recorded in PR-BR-001, data as of 2026-10-14.
- Planalto, Decreto nº 6.514, de 22 de julho de 2008, as recorded in PR-BR-001, data as of 2026-10-14.
- SPI Regulation Tracker, PR-EU-010 and linked records PR-US-011, PR-GB-003, PR-PH-001 and PR-BR-001, data as of 2026-10-14.
- SPI Packaging Buyers Database, Colgate-Palmolive profile, data as of 2026-10-14.