SPI LedgerNews analysis
Three West Coast foam laws reach the same clamshell through three different doors: a failed recycling rate, a fixed list and a vendor ban
Expanded polystyrene (EPS) cups, plates, bowls and clamshells can no longer be supplied into California, Washington or Oregon, but California bars only producers because the statewide 25% recycling rate was not met by 1 January 2025, Washington bars anyone selling or distributing a statutory list since 1 June 2024, and Oregon bars both sellers and food vendors from 1 January 2025 and adds a ban on foodware with intentionally added PFAS.
25%
California recycling rate EPS had to reach by 1 Jan 2025
Not met, so producers may not sell, distribute or import EPS food service ware
CalRecycle
USD 50,000
Highest statutory penalty ceiling of the three
Per day per violation, California, PRC 42081(a)
California Attorney General
1 Jun 2023
Earliest foam ban date of the three
Washington loose-fill packing peanuts; food service products followed on 1 Jun 2024
RCW 70A.245.070
Source: CalRecycle; RCW 70A.245.070; Enrolled SB 543 (Oregon); California Attorney General advisory, checked 12 Nov 2026.
Penalty ceilings in USD as set in each law. They count differently (per violation, per day), so they are not added together.
The three rules cover much the same clamshell but differ on coolers, packing peanuts, who can be fined and how penalties count, from up to USD 250 per violation in Washington to up to USD 50,000 per day per violation in California. This piece sets them side by side, using the SPI Regulation Tracker rule notes PR-US-005, PR-US-012 and PR-US-013 and the statutes and regulator pages behind them, consulted on 26 October 2026.
| Feature | California (SB 54) | Washington (RCW 70A.245.070) | Oregon (SB 543) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal trigger | Statewide EPS recycling rate not met | Fixed statutory ban | Fixed statutory ban |
| In force for foam food ware | 1 Jan 2025 | 1 Jun 2024 | 1 Jan 2025 |
| Who is barred | Producers only | Anyone selling or distributing; penalties aimed at manufacturers and distributors | Sellers and distributors; food vendors (use ban) |
| Coolers | Excluded | Banned, with medical and perishable-shipping exemptions | Single-use coolers banned |
| Packing peanuts | Excluded | Banned since 1 Jun 2023 | Banned |
| PFAS in foodware | Not part of the EPS provision | Separate law, RCW 70A.222.070 | Same law, ORS 459.474 |
| Penalty ceiling | Up to USD 50,000 per day per violation | Up to USD 250, then up to USD 1,000, per violation | Up to USD 500 per day (sellers), USD 100 per day (vendors) |
Source: CalRecycle EPS page and FAQ; RCW 70A.245.070; Enrolled SB 543; Oregon DEQ; California Attorney General advisory (2 Dec 2025), checked 12 Nov 2026.
USD. Summary of the statutes and regulator guidance as of 26 Oct 2026. Not legal advice; check with counsel for any specific product or role.
Executive summary
Foam food service ware is the single packaging format that all three US West Coast states have taken off the market. The outcome is the same for a takeout clamshell in Sacramento, Seattle or Portland, but the routes differ, and that matters for anyone who makes, imports, distributes or brands the items.
California never passed a flat ban. SB 54 (Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022) made continued sale of EPS food service ware conditional on producers showing that all EPS covered material in the state reached a 25% recycling rate by 1 January 2025, rising to 30% from 2028, 50% from 2030 and 65% from 2032 (CalRecycle FAQ). The rate was not shown, so since 1 January 2025 producers may not sell, offer for sale, distribute or import EPS food service ware in or into California. Retailers, distributors and restaurants that are not producers are outside the restriction (CalRecycle EPS page).
Washington and Oregon wrote fixed bans. Washington’s RCW 70A.245.070, from SB 5022 (Chapter 313, Laws of 2021), has barred EPS packing peanuts since 1 June 2023 and EPS food containers, plates, clamshells, cups and portable coolers since 1 June 2024. Oregon’s SB 543 (Chapter 73, Oregon Laws 2023) has, since 1 January 2025, stopped food vendors using foam containers for prepared food and stopped anyone selling foam containers, foam packing peanuts or foodware with intentionally added PFAS.
What the three leave out is close to identical: foam meat trays and egg cartons are outside all three, in different words (Exhibit 3). What they put in differs most on coolers and packing peanuts, and on liability. The penalty ceilings differ by a factor of 100 per day between California and Oregon sellers, and Washington counts per violation only after two certified notices (Exhibit 5).
SPI’s reading for leaders: run one West Coast specification that drops EPS food ware in all three states, but keep three liability maps. In California, own-label ranges create producer status for retailers and franchisors under CalRecycle’s 26 August 2026 guidance. In Oregon, the PFAS test reaches fibre packaging that replaced foam. And EPS that stays legal, such as meat trays and protective packaging, still carries the dearest lines in the Oregon and Colorado EPR fee schedules (Exhibit 10).
Key findings
- All three states bar EPS cups, plates and clamshells, from 1 June 2024 in Washington and 1 January 2025 in California and Oregon (RCW 70A.245.070; CalRecycle; Enrolled SB 543).
- California’s restriction rests on a 25% statewide recycling rate that CalRecycle says “has not been met”; the bar rises to 30% in 2028, 50% in 2030 and 65% in 2032 (CalRecycle EPS page and FAQ, consulted 26 October 2026).
- Foam trays for raw meat and egg cartons are outside all three rules: Washington and California name them, and Oregon excludes raw meat, fish, eggs and produce from “prepared food” (Enrolled SB 543, section 1).
- Coolers split the states: banned in Washington (with medical and perishable-shipping exemptions) and Oregon (single-use only), excluded in California (Exhibit 2).
- Penalty ceilings in USD run from up to 250 per violation in Washington to up to 500 per day for Oregon sellers and up to 50,000 per day per violation in California (RCW 70A.245.070; ORS 459.995 as amended by SB 543; PRC 42081(a)).
- SPI calculation: over 90 days of continued supply, one restricted item could carry a ceiling of USD 4,500,000 in California, USD 45,000 in Oregon and, on SPI’s notice count, USD 2,250 in Washington (Exhibit 9).
- EPS that remains legal is the dearest plastic in the Oregon and Colorado 2026 fee schedules: foamed containers pay 138.0 cents a pound in Oregon and 172.0 cents in Colorado, 17.3 and 21.5 times corrugated board (CAA 2026 schedules; SPI calculator rows).
Three legal designs, one format
The three laws were written in different years for different reasons, and their drafting shows it. Washington’s 2021 act is a litter and recycling statute; its finding names “bans on problematic and unnecessary plastic packaging” as one route to better recycling, and its intent note refers to “prohibiting the sale and distribution of certain expanded polystyrene products” (RCW 70A.245.010, note). Oregon’s 2023 act is a product prohibition that pairs a format with a chemistry. California’s 2022 act is an extended producer responsibility (EPR) statute, and the EPS provision is a performance test inside it.
California: a rate test that failed. Public Resources Code (PRC) section 42057(i), added by SB 54, required producers to show that EPS reached a statewide recycling rate of at least 25% on and after 1 January 2025 (California Attorney General advisory, 2 December 2025). CalRecycle measures the rate across all EPS covered material, not per product or per producer: the weight recycled divided by the weight recycled plus the weight disposed (CalRecycle FAQ). Because that rate was not shown, producers “are restricted from selling, offering for sale, distributing, or importing EPS food service ware, in or into California”, and the FAQ says the position held as of 2026.
CalRecycle sent informational notices in September 2024 to “more than 50 likely EPS food service ware producers” and 25 related industry organisations (CalRecycle implementation report, May 2025). Its EPS page dates that notice to 11 September 2024 and a second, saying the rate had not been met, to 6 August 2025; the Attorney General’s advisory also lists a follow-up notice on 4 April 2025.
Washington: a statutory list. RCW 70A.245.070 prohibits selling or distributing listed EPS products “in or into” Washington, so it reaches out-of-state suppliers shipping to Washington customers. The act was signed on 17 May 2021 and took effect on 25 July 2021, after final Senate passage of 31 to 18 on 19 April 2021 (SB 5022 bill summary). The ban came in two phases: loose-fill packing peanuts from 1 June 2023, food service products and portable coolers from 1 June 2024. The same act set postconsumer recycled content floors for plastic beverage and household containers and trash bags, which the US recycled-content and labelling piece covers, so they are not repeated here.
Oregon: a vendor ban plus a sale ban. Enrolled SB 543 has three operative sections. Section 2 stops a food vendor using a polystyrene foam container to sell, offer, serve or dispense prepared food. Section 3 stops any person selling, offering for sale or distributing foam containers or foam packing peanuts “in or into this state”. Section 4 does the same for foodware containers with intentionally added PFAS. All three became operative on 1 January 2025 (Enrolled SB 543, section 7). Oregon DEQ cites the codified provisions as ORS 459.465 to 459.477.
SPI analysis
California’s design is the only one of the three that could in principle reopen the market. If CalRecycle found that all EPS covered material met the rate then in force, producers could sell again; Washington and Oregon would each need a new act. Exhibit 7 shows how far the rate has to climb, and why SPI treats a return as unlikely within current planning horizons.
What counts as food service ware
The core items are the same in all three states: cups, plates, bowls, clamshells and lidded containers (Exhibit 2). The edges differ, and they are where compliance teams lose time.
| EPS item | California | Washington | Oregon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cups and lids | Barred | Barred (cups) | Barred |
| Plates and bowls | Barred | Barred | Barred |
| Clamshells and hinged containers | Barred | Barred | Barred |
| Trays for prepared food | Barred | Barred (Ecology list) | Barred |
| Trays for raw meat, fish or produce | Excluded | Exempt | Outside (not prepared food) |
| Egg cartons | Excluded | Exempt | Outside (raw eggs not prepared food) |
| Portable or single-use coolers | Excluded | Barred, with exemptions | Single-use barred; solid-shell reusable excluded |
| Loose-fill packing peanuts | Excluded | Barred since 1 Jun 2023 | Barred |
| Other protective EPS packaging | Excluded | Not listed | Excluded if used solely to protect items in transit |
Source: CalRecycle EPS page, FAQ and 26 Aug 2026 guidance; RCW 70A.245.070; Washington Ecology EPS ban page; Enrolled SB 543; Oregon DEQ, checked 12 Nov 2026.
Barred = may not be sold or distributed (and in Oregon, not used by food vendors for prepared food). California applies to producers only. Washington Ecology lists trays and bowls as banned; RCW 70A.245.070 names food containers, plates, clamshells and cups.
California’s list comes from two definitions. EPS is defined in PRC 42041(k) and single-use food service ware in PRC 42041(e)(1)(B), and CalRecycle’s 26 August 2026 guidance lists the items as “trays, plates, bowls, clamshells, lids, cups, and hinged or lidded containers”. Its EPS page excludes packing peanuts, void fill, sports equipment, ice chests and household insulation, and its FAQ adds egg cartons, foam coolers and foam trays used to sell pre-packaged raw meat.
Washington defines EPS broadly, as blown polystyrene and expanded and extruded foams (RCW 70A.245.010(7)), and defines a food service product as a product for one-time use with food or drink (RCW 70A.245.010(9)). The ban itself names food containers, plates, clamshell-style containers and hot and cold beverage cups. Ecology’s EPS ban page goes further in plain language and lists containers, plates, bowls, clamshells, trays and cups. SPI reads the trays and bowls on Ecology’s list as its interpretation of “food containers” rather than separate statutory terms.
Oregon’s scope turns on “prepared food”, defined in Enrolled SB 543 as food or a beverage that “An individual may consume immediately or without the need for further or additional preparation.” A polystyrene foam container is “a cooler or foodware container that is” made of polystyrene foam, made to serve or contain prepared food, and ordinarily used once. The definition excludes multi-use coolers enclosed by a solid shell, trays or containers used solely to store, ship or transport food that is not prepared food, and packing material other than peanuts used solely to protect items in transit.
SPI analysis
A packaging buyer can treat the barred core as one list across all three states. The two items to map state by state are coolers and peanuts: a single-use EPS cooler sold through a grocery chain is barred in Washington and Oregon but outside California’s restriction, and EPS peanuts in an e-commerce carton are barred in Washington and Oregon but sit inside California’s wider SB 54 EPR programme as covered material.
What is left out, and what cannot be exempted
Exemptions are where the three laws read most differently and act most alike. Exhibit 3 sets them out.
| Exemption route | California | Washington | Oregon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raw meat, fish, poultry, produce packaging | Raw meat trays excluded (FAQ) | Exempt by statute | Outside prepared food |
| Egg cartons | Excluded (FAQ) | Exempt by statute | Outside prepared food |
| Medical and biological coolers | Coolers excluded | Exempt by statute | Single-use coolers barred |
| Coolers for shipping perishables from a store or wholesaler | Coolers excluded | Exempt by statute | Single-use coolers barred |
| Party-size exemption | Small producers, retailers and wholesalers under PRC 42060 | None in the section | None; DEQ cannot create exemptions |
| Non-producers | Not subject | Covered if selling or distributing | Covered if selling, distributing or a food vendor |
| Existing stock | Producer restriction since 1 Jan 2025 | No sell-through (Ecology) | No sell-through (DEQ) |
| Tribal lands | Not addressed on CalRecycle pages | Ban does not apply (Ecology) | Not addressed on DEQ pages |
Source: CalRecycle FAQ; CalRecycle Final Statement of Reasons; RCW 70A.245.070; Washington Ecology EPS ban page; Enrolled SB 543; Oregon DEQ fact sheet, checked 12 Nov 2026.
Exemption means the item or party is outside the rule as written. SPI has not yet confirmed the full terms of PRC 42060; the USD 1,000,000 figure is from CalRecycle's small business discussion.
California’s size exemption sits in PRC 42060, which CalRecycle describes as covering small producers, retailers and wholesalers based on “size, revenue, number of retail locations, and market share” (CalRecycle FAQ). CalRecycle’s Final Statement of Reasons for the SB 54 regulations describes small businesses with gross sales of less than USD 1,000,000 in the state as able to be considered small producers, retailers or wholesalers. SPI has not yet confirmed the full statutory thresholds in PRC 42060, and a business relying on them should read the section with counsel.
Washington’s exemptions are fixed in the statute, with no petition route. Packaging for raw, uncooked or butchered meat, fish, poultry or seafood, vegetables and fruit, and egg cartons are not food service products for the ban. Portable coolers for drugs, medical devices or biological materials, or for shipping perishables from a wholesale or retail establishment, are exempt (RCW 70A.245.070). Ecology adds that the ban does not apply on tribal lands and that stock bought earlier cannot be sold: “This law bans the sale and distribution of EPS materials, even if businesses or entities have previously purchased stocks” (Ecology EPS ban page).
Oregon states the reverse in plain terms. DEQ’s fact sheet answers the question of industry exemptions with: “No, the law does not exempt any specific industries, and it does not authorize DEQ to make exemptions.” Yet the definitions do the work that exemptions do elsewhere. Raw meat, fish, eggs and produce are not “prepared food” if they “have not been prepared for immediate consumption”, and trays used solely to store, ship or transport non-prepared food are outside the container definition (Enrolled SB 543, section 1).
SPI analysis
For a grocery or meat supplier the outcome is close across the three states: a foam tray under raw chicken is outside all three rules. The difference is the evidence. In Washington a statutory exemption is cited; in Oregon the use itself has to show the food is not prepared food, so a tray used for a ready-to-eat deli item is barred while the same tray under raw meat is not.
Who is liable: producer, distributor or food vendor
Liability is the largest real difference between the three regimes, and Exhibit 4 maps it by role.
| Role | California | Washington | Oregon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | Restricted where it is the producer | Restricted; a defined manufacturer for penalties | Restricted as seller |
| Brand owner or licensee, including private label | May be the producer (26 Aug 2026 guidance) | Restricted if it sells or distributes | Restricted if it sells or distributes |
| Importer into the state | Restricted as producer | Restricted; imports count as manufacturer | Restricted (in or into this state) |
| Distributor or wholesaler | Not subject unless a producer | Restricted; domestic distributors count as manufacturer | Restricted |
| Retailer selling packs | Not subject unless a producer | Restricted (Ecology names retailers) | Restricted as seller |
| Restaurant or food vendor using foam | Not subject unless a producer | Restricted (Ecology names restaurants, schools, institutions) | Use ban, ORS 459.468 |
| Regulator | CalRecycle, with the Attorney General | Department of Ecology | DEQ; rules by the Environmental Quality Commission |
Source: CalRecycle EPS page and 26 Aug 2026 guidance; California Attorney General advisory; RCW 70A.245.070; Washington Ecology; Enrolled SB 543; Oregon DEQ, checked 12 Nov 2026.
Not legal advice. Producer status in California follows PRC 42041(w) and 14 CCR 18980.1.1.
In California only producers are restricted. CalRecycle says retailers, distributors and restaurants may not be producers under PRC 42041(w) and, where they are not, “are not subject to the restriction”; consumers may still see EPS in stores because “only businesses defined as producers under the law are subject to the restrictions” (CalRecycle EPS page). The August 2026 guidance narrows that safe ground: an owner or licensee of a branded or trademarked EPS item “may be considered a ‘producer'”, which reaches private-label cups and containers sold or used by retailers and chains.
Washington’s statute defines a manufacturer, for the EPS section, as any person or entity that produces restricted products, or imports or domestically distributes them for sale in the state (RCW 70A.245.070). Ecology’s guidance applies the ban to “any person, firm, association, partnership, corporation” that sells or distributes covered products, and its 2024 release named retailers, restaurants, coffee shops, drive-throughs, health care and correctional facilities, institutions, government entities and schools. Its report-a-violation section says civil penalties may go to manufacturers and distributors.
Oregon splits liability by act. A food vendor, “a business, organization or other person that sells prepared food or offers prepared food for sale to the public”, carries the use ban; any person carries the sale ban. Rulemaking sits with the Environmental Quality Commission, which “may adopt rules necessary to implement sections 1 to 4” (Enrolled SB 543, section 5), and DEQ imposes penalties.
In practice: McDonald’s.
The SPI Packaging Buyers Database records 13,706 McDonald’s restaurants in the US at year-end 2025, buying bags, cups and clamshells, and maps them to all three foam rules (PR-US-005, PR-US-012, PR-US-013) as well as the Oregon, Colorado and California EPR programmes. The profile records 82% of primary guest packaging as fibre-based globally at year-end 2024 and 99.82% of guest packaging items free of intentionally added fluorinated compounds at the end of 2024, against a goal of 100% by the end of 2025. For a franchised chain, the California question is who owns or licenses the brand on each item; the Oregon question is the PFAS status of the fibre that replaced foam. SPI has found no published end-2025 PFAS figure as of 26 October 2026.
Penalties and enforcement, in USD
Each state sets a different penalty unit, so the ceilings in Exhibit 5 are compared only as ceilings, never added.
| State | Who | Ceiling (USD) | Unit | Precondition | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | Producer | 50,000 | Per day per violation | None stated | PRC 42081(a) |
| California | Producer (Attorney General action) | 2,500 | Per violation | Court action under the Unfair Competition Law | Bus. & Prof. Code 17200 et seq. |
| Washington | First penalty | 250 | Per violation | Written notification and at least two notices by certified mail | RCW 70A.245.070 |
| Washington | Manufacturer penalised before | 1,000 | Per violation | As above | RCW 70A.245.070 |
| Oregon | Seller or distributor (foam, peanuts, PFAS foodware) | 500 | Per day | None stated | ORS 459.995(1)(i) |
| Oregon | Food vendor using foam for prepared food | 100 | Per day | None stated | ORS 459.995(1)(h) |
Source: California Attorney General advisory (2 Dec 2025), citing PRC 42081(a) and Bus. & Prof. Code 17200; RCW 70A.245.070; Enrolled SB 543, section 6 (ORS 459.995(1)(h) and (i)); Oregon LPRO fact sheet (29 Aug 2024), checked 12 Nov 2026.
USD. Statutory maximums, not typical fines. Oregon penalties are imposed in the manner of ORS 468.135. Not legal advice.
California has the steepest ceiling and two enforcers. The Attorney General’s advisory states that “SB 54 authorizes the imposition of administrative civil penalties up to $50,000 per day per violation” and adds Unfair Competition Law penalties of up to USD 2,500 per violation, enforceable by the Attorney General. CalRecycle, for its part, “prioritizes education and compliance assistance” and calls enforcement “the last step in the compliance process” (CalRecycle FAQ). It runs an EPS Public Reporting System through which Californians report where they see EPS food service ware, and uses the reports to send compliance information to producers who may not know they are affected.
Washington has the lightest ceiling and the most procedure. Ecology must provide written notification of non-compliance and send at least two notices of violation by certified mail before it assesses a penalty. Penalty money goes to the model toxics control operating account, and penalties can be appealed to the Pollution Control Hearings Board (RCW 70A.245.070). Ecology said in May 2024 that it would focus first on educating businesses, and its page describes educational letters, resources and technical assistance before fines.
Oregon’s penalties run per day and were added to ORS 459.995 by section 6 of SB 543. DEQ’s own foodware pages do not set out enforcement procedures, and SPI has found no enforcement action reported there as of 26 October 2026.
In practice: CalRecycle.
CalRecycle’s route to enforcement runs through notices rather than raids. It notified potential producers of the rate on 11 September 2024 and that the rate had not been met on 6 August 2025, and says it continues to send such letters (CalRecycle EPS page). The Attorney General’s Environmental Justice and Protection Section followed with an advisory to producers on 2 December 2025, asking them to consult compliance staff and counsel. SPI has not yet confirmed any penalty assessed under PRC 42081(a) for EPS food service ware.
The timeline: 2021 to 2032
Exhibit 6 sets every dated step in one line, soonest first.
- Washington
- California
- Oregon
- California, Oregon
- Washington SB 5022 signed, Chapter 313, Laws of 2021Washington
- Washington act takes effectWashington
- California SB 54 signed, Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022California
- Oregon SB 543 passes the House after Senate passage on 3 Apr 2023Oregon
- Washington bans EPS packing peanutsWashington
- Washington bans EPS food service products and portable coolersWashington
- CalRecycle notifies potential producers of the 25% rateCalifornia
- California 25% rate unmet, producer restriction applies; Oregon foam and PFAS bans operativeCalifornia, Oregon
- CalRecycle notifies producers the rate has not been metCalifornia
- Attorney General enforcement advisory to EPS producersCalifornia
- CalRecycle private-label EPS guidanceCalifornia
- 2028California required rate rises to 30%California
- 2030California required rate rises to 50%California
- 2032California required rate rises to 65%, and annually afterCalifornia
Source: SB 5022 bill summary; RCW 70A.245.070; California Attorney General advisory; CalRecycle EPS page and FAQ; Enrolled SB 543; Washington Ecology, checked 12 Nov 2026.
Dates as given by each official source, consulted 26 Oct 2026. California's 2028, 2030 and 2032 rate steps apply on and after each year.
Show the data
| Date | Label | Category | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021-05-17 | Washington SB 5022 signed, Chapter 313, Laws of 2021 | Washington | /data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-012/ |
| 2021-07-25 | Washington act takes effect | Washington | no data |
| 2022-06-30 | California SB 54 signed, Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022 | California | /data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-005/ |
| 2023-04-26 | Oregon SB 543 passes the House after Senate passage on 3 Apr 2023 | Oregon | /data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-013/ |
| 2023-06-01 | Washington bans EPS packing peanuts | Washington | no data |
| 2024-06-01 | Washington bans EPS food service products and portable coolers | Washington | no data |
| 2024-09-11 | CalRecycle notifies potential producers of the 25% rate | California | no data |
| 2025-01-01 | California 25% rate unmet, producer restriction applies; Oregon foam and PFAS bans operative | California, Oregon | no data |
| 2025-08-06 | CalRecycle notifies producers the rate has not been met | California | no data |
| 2025-12-02 | Attorney General enforcement advisory to EPS producers | California | no data |
| 2026-08-26 | CalRecycle private-label EPS guidance | California | no data |
| 2028 | California required rate rises to 30% | California | no data |
| 2030 | California required rate rises to 50% | California | no data |
| 2032 | California required rate rises to 65%, and annually after | California | no data |
California's rate ladder
The rate test is what keeps California’s restriction alive, and it steepens (Exhibit 7).
The test covers all EPS covered material, including packaging as well as food service ware, so a single producer with a strong take-back scheme for its own cups cannot meet it alone (CalRecycle FAQ). Producers may submit recycling data at any time but must meet the rate in force when they submit, which means a 2028 submission would need 30% (PR-US-005, citing the CalRecycle FAQ). CalRecycle’s May 2025 report to the Legislature gives no measured EPS rate and states only that the requirement has not been met.
SPI analysis
For planning, SPI treats California’s restriction as a ban with no expiry date. The rate needed rises 5 points by 2028 and 40 points by 2032 from a starting point that was not shown, across a material that the regulator measures statewide. A business case that depends on EPS returning to California should be priced at zero.
A framework: trigger, target and test
To turn the three laws into product decisions, SPI sorts each rule by three questions: what triggers the bar, whom it targets, and what test decides whether an item is in. Exhibit 8 applies the device.
| Question | California | Washington | Oregon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trigger: why is the item barred? | A statewide rate is not met | The statute lists it | The statute defines it |
| Target: who must act? | The producer (maker, brand owner or licensee, importer) | Anyone selling or distributing in or into the state | Sellers, distributors and food vendors |
| Test 1: is it EPS? | PRC 42041(k) | Blown, expanded or extruded polystyrene foam | Polystyrene foam |
| Test 2: is it in scope? | Single-use food service ware item | Listed product, not an exempt use | Container for prepared food, or peanuts, or a single-use cooler |
| Test 3: second chemistry test? | No | Separate PFAS law | Yes, intentionally added PFAS |
| Archetype | Performance bar | List bar | Use and chemistry bar |
| First check for a supplier | Who owns the brand on the item | Is the item on the list or an exempt use | Is the food prepared food, and was PFAS added |
Source: SPI analysis of CalRecycle guidance, RCW 70A.245.070 and Enrolled SB 543, checked 12 Nov 2026.
SPI's organising device, drawn from the three statutes. Each row is answered for a given item before stock moves into the state. Not legal advice.
Performance bar (California). The question that decides a California shipment is not what the item is but who the producer is. A distributor that does not own a brand and is not the importer can usually rely on CalRecycle’s statement that non-producers are not subject; a retailer with its own label on a foam cup cannot.
List bar (Washington). The question is whether the item is on the statutory list and whether its use is exempt. Because the bar covers anyone who sells or distributes, an out-of-state wholesaler shipping into Washington carries it as much as a Seattle restaurant.
Use and chemistry bar (Oregon). The question is how the item is used and what is in it. A foam container is legal under raw fish and barred under sushi, and a fibre bowl that replaced foam is barred if PFAS were intentionally added.
SPI analysis
The framework explains why a single West Coast specification is easy to write and hard to prove. One rule, no EPS food ware and no intentionally added PFAS in prepared-food packaging, satisfies all three item tests. The evidence differs: a producer map for California, a list and exemption register for Washington, and use records plus PFAS declarations for Oregon.
Scenarios: what a missed SKU could cost
To show how the penalty units differ, SPI priced the statutory ceiling for one restricted item supplied for 30, 90 and 365 days before it is withdrawn (Exhibit 9). These are ceilings, not predictions: regulators in all three states describe education first, and no assessed EPS penalty is reported on their pages.
| Case | Days supplied | California producer (USD) | Oregon seller (USD) | Oregon food vendor (USD) | Washington, assessed penalties (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 30 | 1,500,000 | 15,000 | 3,000 | 250 |
| Base | 90 | 4,500,000 | 45,000 | 9,000 | 2,250 |
| High | 365 | 18,250,000 | 182,500 | 36,500 | 11,250 |
Source: SPI calculation from PRC 42081(a) (via California Attorney General advisory), ORS 459.995(1)(h) and (i) (Enrolled SB 543) and RCW 70A.245.070, checked 12 Nov 2026.
USD, one currency. Assumes one item counts as one violation, and for Washington that one penalty is assessed per notice cycle: low 1 first penalty; base 1 first plus 2 repeat; high 1 first plus 11 repeat (monthly). California's UCL penalties are not modelled. Ceilings only; actual penalties are set case by case.
SPI calculation: California’s daily ceiling (USD 50,000) is 100 times Oregon’s seller ceiling (USD 500) and 500 times Oregon’s food vendor ceiling (USD 100). Over 365 days the California ceiling for one item, USD 18,250,000, is 100 times the Oregon seller figure. In Washington, the base case of USD 2,250 assumes Ecology assesses a first penalty of USD 250 and two repeat penalties of USD 1,000 after its notices; the per-violation unit means time alone does not raise the figure.
The scenario shows where the exposure concentrates. A brand owner or importer that keeps a private-label foam line in California faces the largest ceiling of the three, on the reading in CalRecycle’s August 2026 guidance. A wholesaler supplying Oregon faces a per-day penalty for each banned line, and the USD 500 ceiling applies equally to PFAS foodware, which is harder to spot than foam.
Where EPS still sits in EPR fee schedules
EPS that is still legal, such as foam meat trays, egg cartons where sold and protective cushioning, remains a covered material in Oregon’s and Colorado’s packaging EPR programmes and pays the dearest plastic lines in both 2026 schedules (Exhibit 10). The Oregon and Colorado fee schedule piece covers the full 2026 and 2027 tables; this section looks only at the polystyrene rows.
| Covered material type | Oregon 2026 final (cents per lb) | Oregon (USD per tonne) | Colorado 2026 final (cents per lb) | Colorado (USD per tonne) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PS (#6) expanded or foamed hinged containers, plates, cups, tubs, trays and other foamed containers | 138.0 | 3,042.38 | 172.0 | 3,791.95 |
| PS (#6) white expanded or foamed cushioning | 72.0 | 1,587.33 | 156.0 | 3,439.21 |
| PS (#6) coloured expanded or foamed cushioning | 138.0 | 3,042.38 | 172.0 | 3,791.95 |
| PS (#6) rigid non-expanded | 97.0 | 2,138.48 | 78.0 | 1,719.6 |
| Corrugated cardboard (reference) | 8.0 | 176.37 | 8.0 | 176.37 |
Source: Circular Action Alliance: 2026 Oregon Producer Fee Schedule (29 Oct 2025) and 2026 Colorado Producer Dues Schedule (13 Oct 2025); corrugated rows from the SPI EPR & Plastic Tax Calculator, checked 13 Oct 2026.
USD. Cents per pound as printed; USD per tonne = cents per lb x 22.0462. Oregon final = base, with no SIM portion on these rows. Colorado final includes passive malus. Ratios are within each state.
The two schedules treat foam differently. In Oregon, white EPS cushioning carries “PRO” acceptance status and pays 72.0 cents a pound, 52% of the foamed container line, while the container and coloured cushioning lines have no acceptance status and pay 138.0 cents. In Colorado, the foamed container line is a base of 160.2 cents plus an 11.8 cent not-on-list malus, coloured cushioning is 160.2 cents plus 6.6 and 5.2 cents of malus, and white cushioning, on the alternative list, pays 156.0 cents (CAA 2026 schedules).
The 2027 schedules move the two states apart. Ledger 30 records Oregon’s foamed container line falling to USD 0.74 a pound final (base USD 1.13) and Colorado’s rising to USD 2.09, so the gap between the two states widens on the very line Oregon has banned for prepared food.
Who pays differs too. For food serviceware in Oregon’s EPR programme, “The obligated “producer” is the person that first sells the food serviceware into Oregon” (DEQ producer obligations summary, updated February 2025). That is closer to Washington’s distributor-based foam liability than to California’s brand-owner test.
In practice: Circular Action Alliance.
CAA, the producer responsibility organisation for both states, prints a separate foamed container line even in Oregon, where SB 543 bars foam containers for prepared food. Foam trays for raw meat, which fall outside SB 543’s prepared food definition, are one format that could still report under it; SPI has not yet confirmed which foamed formats producers report under the line. In Colorado, a separate 2021 law, HB21-1162, has barred retail food establishments from distributing EPS containers for ready-to-eat food since 1 January 2024, with stock bought earlier usable until it runs out (Colorado General Assembly).
SPI analysis
A switch out of EPS where it remains legal is a fee decision as well as a ban decision. On the 2026 rates a tonne of foamed trays costs USD 3,042.38 in Oregon and USD 3,791.95 in Colorado, against USD 176.37 for a tonne of corrugated board in both. Packaging teams should price the replacement material in each schedule rather than assume a saving, because a fibre or PET alternative may weigh more per unit.
The PFAS overlay
Oregon’s law is the only one of the three that puts a chemistry test in the same act as the foam ban, and that is the trap for buyers moving out of foam (Exhibit 11).
| Feature | Oregon (ORS 459.474) | Washington (RCW 70A.222.070) |
|---|---|---|
| Test | PFAS intentionally added to a foodware container for prepared food | PFAS intentionally added to food packaging, by category after Ecology findings |
| Start | 1 Jan 2025, all prepared-food foodware | 1 Feb 2023 wraps, plates, food boats, pizza boxes; 1 May 2024 bags, bowls, flat serviceware, open-top and closed containers |
| Durable items | Covered in some circumstances | Not stated on Ecology's page |
| Items for food preparation | Outside the restriction | Not stated on Ecology's page |
| Penalty | Up to USD 500 per day | Separate penalty regime, not compared here |
Source: Enrolled SB 543, section 4; Oregon DEQ; RCW 70A.222.070; Washington Ecology blog (April 2024), checked 12 Nov 2026.
California's food packaging PFAS rules are outside SB 54's EPS provision and are not compared here. Not legal advice.
DEQ says the PFAS restriction applies only where a container is used to serve or hold prepared food and PFAS were intentionally added, and that in some circumstances it reaches durable foodware; items used for other purposes, such as food preparation, are outside it (Oregon DEQ). Washington’s food packaging PFAS rules sit in RCW 70A.222.070, which ties each prohibition to Ecology’s findings on safer alternatives; Ecology’s April 2024 post dates the restrictions to 1 February 2023 and 1 May 2024 by category. California’s food packaging PFAS rules sit outside SB 54’s EPS provision and are not compared here. The PFAS rules for food-contact packaging in the EU are covered in the quick-service restaurant piece.
SPI analysis
The fibre clamshell that replaced foam in 2024 and 2025 is now the item to check. In Oregon a supplier’s declaration that no PFAS were intentionally added is the practical evidence, and the per-day penalty runs on the seller, not only the restaurant.
Industry reaction
“To date, this recycling rate requirement has not been met.”
CalRecycle pairs that line with the statement that statewide sales and distribution restrictions have applied since 1 January 2025, and that required rates will rise over the next several years.
“The Attorney General takes seriously the need to comply with SB 54.”
California Attorney General, Environmental Justice and Protection Section, enforcement advisory to EPS food service ware producers, 2 December 2025
“Single-use plastic foam products are cheap to buy, but their environmental cost is high”
Ecology’s release cited its 2022 litter study, which estimated about 1 million pieces of EPS cups, bowls and clamshells and 191 million pieces of other EPS foam accumulating statewide each year.
“No, the law does not exempt any specific industries, and it does not authorize DEQ to make exemptions.”
What leaders should do now
- Compliance leads for California, by 31 December 2026: record, for every EPS item still sold anywhere in the business, who manufactures it and who owns or licenses the brand, and withdraw any California line where your company is the producer under PRC 42041(w) and 14 CCR 18980.1.1.
- Retail and franchise own-label teams, now: audit private-label foam cups, plates and containers against CalRecycle’s 26 August 2026 guidance, since an owner or licensee of a branded item may be the producer.
- Distributors and wholesalers shipping into Washington and Oregon, by the next stock count: remove EPS food ware, packing peanuts and banned coolers from those channels, and keep an exemption register for raw meat, produce, egg carton and medical cooler uses.
- Food vendors and buyers in Oregon, before the 2027 tender: collect supplier declarations that no PFAS were intentionally added to each prepared-food container, including fibre items that replaced foam and durable items used to serve food.
- Packaging development teams, at the next specification review: write one West Coast standard with no EPS food ware and no intentionally added PFAS in prepared-food packaging, then add each state’s evidence pack (Exhibit 8).
- Finance teams, ahead of 2027 EPR invoices: price any EPS still placed in Oregon and Colorado at the CAA foam lines, and compare the replacement material per unit, not per tonne.
- Legal and public affairs teams, from 2028: track CalRecycle rate findings at each step (30% in 2028, 50% in 2030, 65% in 2032), and check with counsel before planning any EPS return.
Questions for your board
- Do we know, item by item, whether we are the producer of any EPS food service ware sold into California?
- Which own-label foam items, if any, still reach California, Washington or Oregon, and through which distributors?
- Have the fibre items that replaced foam been declared free of intentionally added PFAS for Oregon?
- Where we still use EPS legally, such as meat trays or protective packaging, what does it cost us in Oregon and Colorado EPR fees?
- Who receives and answers a Washington Ecology notice of violation, and how fast?
- Is our West Coast packaging specification one document, with a separate evidence pack per state?
What to watch
- 17 Dec 2026: National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors’ opening brief due in its Ninth Circuit appeal over Oregon’s packaging EPR law (SPI News, 22 October 2026).
- 1 Jan 2027: producers must participate in an approved SB 54 plan in California, the EPR programme in which EPS that is not food service ware remains covered material (CalRecycle Final Statement of Reasons).
- Jan 2027: CAA’s 2027 schedules apply in Oregon and Colorado, with Oregon’s foamed container line at USD 0.74 a pound final and Colorado’s at USD 2.09 (Ledger 30).
- 2028: California’s required EPS recycling rate rises to 30% (CalRecycle FAQ).
- 2030: the California rate rises to 50% (CalRecycle FAQ).
- 2032: the California rate rises to 65%, and applies annually after (CalRecycle FAQ).
Methodology
- Data used: SPI Regulation Tracker rule notes PR-US-005, PR-US-012 and PR-US-013, three of the 79 rules in the US tracker; the statutes and regulator pages listed in the Sources, consulted on 26 October 2026; CAA’s 2026 Oregon and Colorado schedules; and the SPI Packaging Buyers Database McDonald’s profile.
- Counting rules: penalties are statutory ceilings in USD as written in each law; per-day and per-violation units are never added together; CAA cents per pound are converted at 1 cent per lb = USD 22.0462 per tonne; fee ratios are within one state.
- Scenarios: Exhibit 9 assumes one item counts as one violation and, for Washington, one assessed penalty per notice cycle. These are SPI assumptions; regulators decide how violations are counted.
- Where sources differ: where Washington Ecology’s guidance lists items the statute does not name (trays, bowls), both are shown and the statute is treated as the rule. Oregon definitions and penalties are taken from the enrolled bill; DEQ’s pages are used for interpretation.
- Cut-off: 26 October 2026.
- Limitations: SPI has not yet confirmed the full terms of PRC 42060 or whether Oregon’s 2026 legislative session amended ORS 459.465 to 459.477. Local ordinances are noted only as context. This piece is not legal advice; check with counsel for any specific product, role or state.
FAQ
Is EPS foam takeout packaging banned in California?
Producers may not sell, offer for sale, distribute or import EPS food service ware into California since 1 January 2025, because the required 25% statewide recycling rate was not met. Retailers, distributors and restaurants that are not producers are not subject, but a brand owner or licensee may be a producer.
When did Washington's EPS ban start?
EPS packing peanuts have been banned for sale and distribution since 1 June 2023. EPS food containers, plates, clamshells, cups and portable coolers followed on 1 June 2024 under RCW 70A.245.070, with exemptions for raw meat, seafood and produce packaging, egg cartons and some coolers.
Does Oregon's SB 543 cover coolers and packing peanuts?
Yes. Since 1 January 2025 no one may sell or distribute polystyrene foam containers, which include single-use coolers, or foam packing peanuts in or into Oregon. Reusable coolers enclosed by a solid shell are excluded, as is other polystyrene used solely to protect items in transit.
Are foam meat trays and egg cartons still allowed?
Generally yes in all three states. Washington exempts them by statute, CalRecycle’s FAQ excludes egg cartons and raw meat trays, and Oregon excludes raw meat, fish, eggs and produce not prepared for immediate consumption from prepared food.
What are the penalties for selling EPS food ware?
California: up to USD 50,000 per day per violation for producers, plus Unfair Competition Law penalties up to USD 2,500 per violation. Washington: up to USD 250, then USD 1,000, per violation after two certified notices. Oregon: up to USD 500 per day for sellers and USD 100 per day for food vendors.
Could EPS food ware return to California?
Only if producers show that all EPS covered material meets the rate in force: 30% from 2028, 50% from 2030 and 65% from 2032. CalRecycle says the 25% rate due in 2025 has not been met.
Sources
- CalRecycle, Expanded Polystyrene (EPS) Food Service Ware Requirements, https://calrecycle.ca.gov/packaging/packaging-epr/eps/, consulted 2026-10-26.
- CalRecycle, Requirements for Expanded Polystyrene Food Service Ware (FAQ), https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/130851, consulted 2026-10-26.
- CalRecycle, Compliance Guidance for Owners or Licensees of Private-Label EPS Food Service Ware (26 August 2026), https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/139651, consulted 2026-10-26.
- California Attorney General, Ban on EPS Food Service Ware, enforcement advisory to producers (2 December 2025), https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/attachments/press-docs/SB%2054%20Foam%20Ban%20Enforcement%20Advisory%2012.2.25%5B1%5D.pdf, consulted 2026-10-26.
- CalRecycle, Building California’s Circular Economy: SB 54 Implementation Report to the Legislature (May 2025), https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/130194, consulted 2026-10-26.
- CalRecycle, SB 54 regulations, Final Statement of Reasons, https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/Web/138862, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington State Legislature, RCW 70A.245.070, Expanded polystyrene prohibitions, https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=70A.245.070, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington State Legislature, RCW 70A.245.010, Definitions, with the 2021 c 313 finding and intent note, https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=70A.245.010, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington State Legislature, SB 5022 (2021) bill summary, https://app.leg.wa.gov/billsummary?BillNumber=5022&Year=2021&Initiative=false, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington Department of Ecology, Expanded polystyrene ban, https://ecology.wa.gov/waste-toxics/reducing-recycling-waste/plastics/2021-plastic-pollution-laws/expanded-polystyrene-ban, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington Department of Ecology, news release, Most EPS foam containers banned from sale and distribution in WA starting June 1 (29 May 2024), https://ecology.wa.gov/about-us/who-we-are/news/2024/may-29-eps-foam-clamshell-containers-plates-bowls-cups-trays-and-coolers-are-banned-for-sale, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington Department of Ecology, Food packaging laws seek to reduce litter and PFAS contamination (April 2024), https://ecology.wa.gov/blog/april-2024/food-packaging-laws-seek-to-reduce-litter-and-pfas-contamination, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Washington State Legislature, RCW 70A.222.070, https://app.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=70A.222.070, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Oregon Legislature, Enrolled Senate Bill 543 (SB 543-A, 2023), https://apps.oregonlegislature.gov/liz/2023R1/Downloads/MeasureDocument/SB543, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Oregon Legislature, SB 543 measure overview (Chapter 73, Oregon Laws 2023), https://olis.oregonlegislature.gov/liz/2023R1/Measures/Overview/SB543, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Oregon Legislative Policy and Research Office, Senate Bill 543 fact sheet (29 August 2024), https://www.oregonlegislature.gov/committees/2023I1-SEE/WorkgroupDocuments/Senate%20Bill%20543%20Fact%20Sheet.pdf, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Oregon DEQ, Foodware Containers and Polystyrene Foam, https://www.oregon.gov/deq/mm/production/pages/polystyrene.aspx, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Oregon DEQ, Foodware Containers and Polystyrene Foam fact sheet, https://www.oregon.gov/deq/mm/Documents/mmFoodwarePolyFS.pdf, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Oregon DEQ, Recycling Modernization Act producer obligations summary (updated February 2025), https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Documents/RMAProducerObligationsSummary.pdf, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Circular Action Alliance, 2026 Oregon Producer Fee Schedule (published 29 October 2025), https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64260ed078c36925b1cf3385/t/693b2c9103be112d168e1b19/1765485713621/OR+2026+Fee+Schedule+Public.pdf, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Circular Action Alliance, 2026 Colorado Producer Dues Schedule (published 13 October 2025), https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64260ed078c36925b1cf3385/t/693b45923163e42ba98d634f/1765492118120/CO+2026+Dues+Schedule+Public.pdf, consulted 2026-10-26.
- Colorado General Assembly, HB21-1162, Management of Plastic Products, https://www.leg.colorado.gov/bills/hb21-1162, consulted 2026-10-26.
- SPI Regulation Tracker, rule notes PR-US-005, PR-US-012 and PR-US-013, and SPI EPR & Plastic Tax Calculator corrugated rows, /data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/, consulted 2026-10-26.
- SPI Packaging Buyers Database, McDonald’s profile (citing McDonald’s published reports), /data/packaging-buyers-database/, consulted 2026-10-26.
- SPI Ledger, Oregon and Colorado EPR fee schedules for 2026 and 2027, line by line, and US recycled-content and labelling laws beyond EPR, /insights/oregon-colorado-epr-fee-schedules-line-by-line/ and /insights/us-recycled-content-labelling-laws-beyond-epr/, consulted 2026-10-26.
Go deeper
- SPI dataSPI Buyers DatabasePublic packaging targets of brand owners and retailers, each with reported progress, status and company source. Free to filter and download as CSV.
- SPISPI Methodology: How SPI Sources, Checks, Labels and Corrects Packaging DataHow SPI sources 79 packaging rules, 179 brand targets and 216 fee rates, assigns statuses, re-checks sources weekly and corrects errors.