# EPR fee schedule design: Oregon runs on a reserve return, B.C. and Colorado price cost and recyclability

> EPR fee schedule design differs sharply across the three North American programmes with published 2027 rates. Recycle BC prints one rate for each of 23 lines in Canadian cents per kilogram; Circular Action Alliance's Oregon schedule of 1 October 2026 subtracts two reserve drawdown columns from a base rate, taking steel containers from USD 0.09 to USD 0.04 a pound and aluminium containers to minus USD 0.09; and its Colorado schedule adds a malus and a bonus to base dues. For Oregon and Colorado rates line by line, see SPI's Ledger on the two schedules.

Publisher: Strategic Packaging Insights  
Published: 2026-11-03  
Last updated: 2026-11-03  
Page: https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/epr-fee-schedule-design-british-columbia-oregon-colorado/

**EPR fee schedule design differs sharply across the three North American programmes with published 2027 rates. Recycle BC prints one rate for each of 23 lines in Canadian cents per kilogram; Circular Action Alliance's Oregon schedule of 1 October 2026 subtracts two reserve drawdown columns from a base rate, taking steel containers from USD 0.09 to USD 0.04 a pound and aluminium containers to minus USD 0.09; and its Colorado schedule adds a malus and a bonus to base dues. For Oregon and Colorado rates line by line, see SPI's [Ledger on the two schedules](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/oregon-colorado-epr-fee-schedules-line-by-line/).**

Recycle BC's 2027 schedule of 21 October 2026 also publishes why each line moved, while CAA's US schedules print adjustment columns on every line; Recycle BC collects quarterly and CAA in two halves, in January and July 2027. This piece compares the three designs, in each schedule's own currency, and prices what a pack redesign is worth in each. The wider state picture is in SPI's [US state EPR overview](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/us-state-packaging-epr/).

## Executive summary

British Columbia, Oregon and Colorado are the three North American jurisdictions where packaging producers already pay published, line-by-line EPR fees for 2027. Recycle BC has run its program since 2014 under B.C. Reg. 449/2004. Circular Action Alliance (CAA) charges Oregon fees under the Recycling Modernization Act and Colorado dues under HB22-1355. All three schedules were out by 21 October 2026, so a producer selling in all three can now set its 2027 budget.

The schedules look alike, with a rate per unit of weight for each material, but they are built on three different designs (Exhibit 1). Recycle BC prints one rate per line and explains each change in a set of cause-of-change graphs. Oregon prints a base rate and then subtracts reserves: CAA says it is returning about USD 80 million of programme reserves and USD 3 million of system investment (SIM) fees through lower 2027 rates. Colorado prints base dues and then adds a 5% detriments malus and an off-list malus and subtracts a 5% high recycling rate bonus.

The design decides what a pack change is worth. By SPI's calculation, moving 10 tonnes of laminate pouches to mono-material PE film saves nothing in B.C., where both lines pay 174 cents per kg, USD 3,527.39 in Colorado and USD 9,700.33 in Oregon at 2027 final rates (Exhibits 7 and 8). Switching a coloured PET bottle to clear saves nothing in B.C., which has no colour split, but USD 5,291.09 to USD 7,495.71 per 10 tonnes in the two US states.

Oregon's 2027 numbers carry a warning. Its final rates rest on a one-year reserve return, and CAA's schedule does not say whether a drawdown of the same size will recur. The base column is the better guide to cost: steel containers at USD 0.09 a pound, not the USD 0.04 final rate.

For leaders, the practical steps are to budget each market in its own currency, read Oregon on its base column as well as its final column, put B.C. thermoform and kraft paper mapping right before the 31 May 2027 report, and aim redesign money at the states where the schedule pays for it. Each currency stays in its own table throughout; nothing here is converted, added or ranked across currencies.

## Key findings

1. Oregon's 2027 schedule, originally published on 1 October 2026, sets steel containers at a USD 0.09 base and a USD 0.04 final rate per pound, and aluminium containers at a base of minus USD 0.03 and a final rate of minus USD 0.09, one of two negative final rates in the table (CAA).
2. Recycle BC's 2027 schedule raises 19 of 23 lines and cuts 4, from minus 27.1% for aluminium food and other containers to plus 10.3% for PET bottles, and prints plastic film and plastic laminates at the same 174 cents per kg (Recycle BC, 21 October 2026).
3. Colorado's 2027 dues add a 5% detriments malus and an off-list malus and subtract a 5% high recycling rate bonus, with Additional Material List lines set at least 20% above comparable Minimum Recyclable List lines (CAA).
4. **SPI analysis:**  inside each 2027 schedule, a laminate costs 1.00 times PE film in B.C., 1.26 times in Colorado and 4.67 times in Oregon at final rates, so the same redesign earns very different returns (Exhibit 5).
5. **SPI calculation:**  replacing 10 tonnes of foamed polystyrene with PET thermoforms is worth CAD 30,200 in B.C., USD 9,920.79 in Oregon at final rates and USD 41,887.78 in Colorado in 2027 (Exhibits 7 and 8).
6. Flat fees for small producers in 2027 run from USD 700 to USD 3,100 in Oregon and USD 900 to USD 4,100 in Colorado for supply up to 10 tons; Recycle BC's page still shows 2025 amounts, CAD 1,300 to CAD 11,800 for up to 15,000 kg.
7. Oregon's current CAA programme plan covers 2025 to 2027, so the 2028 schedule will be the first under whatever plan follows (CAA programme plan, amended 12 September 2025).

## EPR fee schedule design in Oregon: what the 2027 schedule prints

CAA's 2027 Oregon Fee Schedule, originally published on 1 October 2026, has seven columns: material class, reporting category, type, base fee rate, reserve drawdown for SIM only, reserve drawdown for other reserves, and final fee rate. All rates are in US dollars per pound. The type column carries each line's acceptance status: on the Uniform Statewide Collection List (USCL), on CAA's own acceptance list (PRO), or on neither (N/A).

The schedule states that its rates reflect producer-reported supply data, projected programme costs and regulatory requirements. It says that for 2027 CAA is returning about USD 80 million of programme reserves to producers through reduced fee rates, together with about USD 3 million of previously collected SIM fees, and that reserve balances are evaluated at the material-category level to decide whether funds stay in the programme or reduce future rates. That is why the drawdown differs by line rather than being one percentage.

Two features stand out. First, the base column already carries most of the recyclability signal. Clear PET bottles on the USCL have a base of USD 0.28 a pound, pigmented PET bottles on neither list USD 0.69, and steel aerosol containers, also N/A, USD 0.49 against USD 0.09 for steel containers on the USCL. Oregon has no separate malus column: status is priced into the base.

Second, commodity revenue can push a base rate below zero. Aluminium containers have a base of minus USD 0.03 a pound before any drawdown, and the drawdown takes them to minus USD 0.09. Clear or natural HDPE bottles have a positive base, USD 0.11, but a drawdown of USD 0.15 takes them to minus USD 0.04. These are the only two negative final rates in the 2027 table. SPI has not yet confirmed how CAA nets a negative line against a producer's positive lines, or whether a credit can exceed a producer's other charges.

The steel line is the clearest worked example of the design. A steel food can pays a USD 0.09 base, which is CAA's estimate of the line's own cost after its commodity revenue. The other drawdown column then returns USD 0.05 of reserves to that category, leaving USD 0.04, or USD 88.18 per tonne by SPI's conversion. In the 2026 schedule, the steel container line paid 10.0 cents a pound with a SIM portion of zero (CAA, 29 October 2025), so most of the 2027 fall comes from the reserve return, not from a lower base.

The highest-fee lines take the largest drawdowns in cents. Foamed polystyrene containers fall from a USD 1.13 base to USD 0.74 final, and plastic laminates from USD 0.97 to USD 0.56, while corrugated cardboard loses USD 0.05 and glass USD 0.04 in total. **SPI analysis:**  in percentage terms the cut is uneven too, from 35% on foam to 56% on steel and 100% on glass, which confirms that the drawdown follows each category's reserve balance rather than one rule.

Oregon's billing changes too. Both 2027 CAA schedules say producers receive two invoices for annual fees, 50% in January and 50% in July, each showing fees by material category. The SPI Ledger's [line-by-line read of the Oregon and Colorado schedules](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/oregon-colorado-epr-fee-schedules-line-by-line/) prices a fixed basket through both years; this piece looks instead at the design that produces those numbers.

## British Columbia: one rate per line, and the reasons published

Recycle BC posted its 2027 Fee Schedule on 21 October 2026. It is one page with 23 lines in six material groups, each 2027 rate printed beside its 2026 rate in Canadian cents per kilogram, with a variance column (Exhibit 2). SPI's [news report on the schedule](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/news/recycle-bc-2027-fee-schedule/) sets out every line; the point here is how the schedule is built.

Recycle BC sets each rate with what it calls its Four-Step Fee Methodology. Its cause-of-change glossary names the steps: gross cost (Step 1), commodity revenue (Step 2), program management (Step 3) and material market development (Step 4), the last described as investment needed to improve a material's recovery performance. Further factors then reallocate cost between lines: steward count, supplied tonnes, recovery rate, the material cost index, commodity revenue per tonne, a surplus drawdown or accumulation factor, and rounding to zero decimal places.

The plan approved by the B.C. ministry on 17 September 2025 sets the allocation rules behind that model. Every obligated material bears a share of cost even if it is not collected, commodity revenue is credited only to the materials that earn it, and extra cost is loaded onto uncollectable or underperforming categories to fund improvement (SPI fee-market file for British Columbia, from the plan). The plan treats the weight-based fee itself as the incentive to cut material, rather than adding bonus and malus columns.

That design shows in the 2027 numbers. There is no colour split: clear and coloured glass both pay 61 cents, and PET bottles are one line whatever their tint. Plastic film and plastic laminates pay the same 174 cents, as they did at 184 cents in 2026 and 146 cents in 2025 (Recycle BC 2026 schedule). The signal in B.C. comes from the category a pack falls in, not from its design within the category.

Reserves are handled inside the rate. The glossary defines the surplus drawdown or accumulation factor as a reduction in the fee rate when reserves finance part of the budget, or an increase when reserves are being built up. In the 2027 graphs that factor raised every line, by 0.17 cents per kg on aluminium containers to 2.74 cents on expanded polystyrene, as SPI's news report recorded. SPI has not yet confirmed whether that reflects a smaller drawdown than in 2026 or a rebuilding of reserves.

In practice: Recycle BC.

The cause-of-change file gives a graph for each of the 23 lines, from the 2026 rate through each factor to the 2027 rate. On plastic film, Step 4 investment cut 17.67 cents per kg, more than the 3.72 cents added by gross cost and the 1.34 cents added by program management, which is how film fell 10 cents while most lines rose. On aluminium containers, commodity revenue per tonne cut 11.80 cents and recovery rate 7.53 cents.

## Colorado: base dues with a malus and bonus stack

CAA's 2027 Colorado Dues Schedule, also originally published on 1 October 2026, prints eight columns: material class, reporting category, type, base dues, detriments malus, not on MRL malus, high recycling rates bonus and final dues, in US dollars per pound (Exhibit 4). The type column puts each line on the Minimum Recyclable List (MRL), the Additional Material List (AML) or not collected (N/C).

The statute sets the frame. Section 25-17-705(4)(i) of the Colorado Revised Statutes requires dues to vary by type of covered material and by whether it is readily recyclable, and to rest on the net cost of recycling services for each material (HB22-1355). The 2027 schedule turns that into two rules for the base: AML lines are set at least 20% above the average of comparable MRL lines, and N/C lines at least 10% above the average of comparable AML lines.

On top of the base sit the passive eco-modulation factors, which CAA applies automatically from supply data. A 5% detriments malus applies to materials that disrupt recycling: pigmented PET bottles go from a USD 0.40 base to USD 0.42, and plastic laminates from USD 0.74 to USD 0.78. A 5% high recycling rate bonus takes a cent off corrugated, steel containers, clear PET and both HDPE bottle lines. The not on MRL malus adds USD 0.04 to PP film and USD 0.11 to foamed polystyrene containers.

Colorado also plans active incentives. CDPHE says the Solid and Hazardous Waste Commission adopted producer eco-modulation amendments in November 2025, and the 2027 schedule says detailed CAA Colorado guidance with CDPHE bonus benchmarks was due by 1 October 2026. SPI has not yet confirmed the 2027 value of any active incentive.

There is no reserve column. Section 25-17-705(4) requires surpluses to go back into the programme or lower dues, and the organisation must hold a financial reserve, so a future drawdown is possible in law. SPI has seen no CAA statement planning one for Colorado. **SPI analysis:**  Colorado's 2027 schedule is the plainest of the three to read for cost, because what is printed in the base is what the programme expects to spend, and the stack moves a line by no more than USD 0.11 a pound in the rows shown.

In practice: CAA Colorado.

Dues have been payable since January 2026, the first dues year, and producers outside the programme have been barred from selling products in covered materials since 1 July 2025 (CDPHE). The 2027 schedule is therefore the first in which a producer can compare two public Colorado tables; SPI's [Ledger on the two states](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/oregon-colorado-epr-fee-schedules-line-by-line/) prices that change on a fixed basket.

## The price signals inside each schedule

A fee per kilogram or per pound matters less to a design team than the gap between two lines it could choose between. Ratios inside one schedule are unitless, so they can be read side by side without converting any currency (Exhibit 5). Each ratio divides the dearer line by the cheaper one in the same schedule and year.

Three patterns follow. First, B.C. is flat on design within a material. A laminate and a mono film pay the same, and so do a clear and a coloured PET bottle, because the schedule has one line for each. B.C. sends its sharpest signals between categories: foam at 4.09 times PET bottles, and film at 2.76 times corrugated.

Second, Oregon's drawdown changes the signal. At base rates a laminate costs 3.34 times PE film; at final rates, after a USD 0.41 drawdown on laminates and USD 0.17 on film, it costs 4.67 times. The reserve return is set by category balances, not by design, so it widens some gaps and narrows others. PET thermoforms go the other way: 2.04 times PET bottles at base, 1.53 times at final, because the thermoform line takes a larger drawdown.

Third, Colorado puts its largest gap on foam. Foamed polystyrene containers pay 11.61 times clear PET bottles, against about four times in the other two schedules, because the not collected status adds both a higher base and a USD 0.11 malus. Colorado's laminate premium over PE film, by contrast, is the smallest of the three US readings at 1.26 times, because PE film is itself on the AML at USD 0.62.

SPI analysis

A pack strategy built for one schedule will not carry over. The same laminate redesign that is worthless on Recycle BC's table is the strongest single lever on Oregon's 2027 final rates, and the foam exit that matters most in Colorado is worth less, relative to the replacement, in Oregon.

## A framework: five design dials

Every fee schedule in this piece answers five questions, which SPI calls design dials (Exhibit 6). Reading a new schedule against them tells a producer where its bill comes from and which parts it can change. The dials apply equally to schedules SPI has covered elsewhere, such as Washington's 2027 early fees in the [Ledger on SB 5284](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/washington-packaging-epr-sb-5284-rcw-70a-208/) and Maine's planned low-volume tier in the [Ledger on Maine EPR](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/maine-epr-packaging-stewardship-program-municipal-reimbursement/).

**Dial 1, cost base.**  All three start from the cost of collecting and processing each material, net of what its bales sell for. Oregon's DEQ says the consequence plainly: rates follow reported supply, so they change every year. Recycle BC's plan adds a rule the US schedules do not state: uncollectable or underperforming lines carry extra cost to fund improvement, which is how B.C.'s Step 4 investment raised film by 26.0% for 2026 and then cut it by 17.67 cents for 2027.

**Dial 2, category grain.**  Recycle BC's 23 lines against roughly 60 in each CAA table is the largest structural difference. A finer grain lets a schedule price colour, format and acceptance status separately; a coarser one keeps reporting simpler. Recycle BC is still adjusting its grain: kraft paper and PET thermoforms were split out for 2026, and telephone books and steel paint cans were rolled into larger lines.

**Dial 3, eco-modulation.**  Oregon prices status inside the base and adds life cycle evaluation bonuses under OAR 340-090-0910(3); DEQ's approval of 12 September 2025 raised the Tier 2 and Tier 3 multipliers to 2.5 and 3.0 ([PR-US-002](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-002/)). Colorado prints its maluses and bonus and is adding active incentives. B.C. relies on the category rate alone.

**Dial 4, reserve cushion.**  This is the dial that moved Oregon's 2027 bill most, and it rewards no design choice. A producer pays less in 2027 because its category held reserves. In B.C. the same effect is folded into each rate and made visible only in the graphs; in Colorado it is not printed at all. Other Canadian programs show the same mechanism with different results: SPI's [report on Manitoba and Saskatchewan 2027 fees](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/news/canada-epr-fees-2027-manitoba-saskatchewan/) covers two schedules built on the same cause-of-change model, and the [Ledger on Canada province by province](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/canada-packaging-epr-by-province/) explains why fees outside B.C. sit on other bases.

**Dial 5, cadence and access.**  Recycle BC posts in the fourth quarter and collects quarterly; CAA posts on 1 October and invoices twice. Each programme also offers a flat fee to small producers, and the exemption lines differ: under CAD 1,000,000 of gross B.C. revenue or under one tonne in B.C., and under USD 5 million of gross revenue or under one ton in Oregon and Colorado, with Colorado's figure indexed each year ([PR-CA-004](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/canada/pr-ca-004/), [PR-US-002](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-002/), [PR-US-003](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-003/)).

## What a redesign is worth in each schedule

The ratios in Exhibit 5 become money once a producer puts tonnes on them. SPI priced three common changes on 10 tonnes of packaging in each schedule: a laminate pouch to a mono-material PE film, a pigmented PET bottle to a clear one, and a foamed polystyrene tray to a PET thermoform. Exhibit 7 holds B.C. in Canadian dollars and Exhibit 8 the two US states in US dollars.

The working is short. In B.C., expanded polystyrene pays 438 cents per kg and PET thermoforms 136, a gap of 302 cents, so 10,000 kg saves CAD 30,200. In Oregon at 2027 final rates, laminates pay USD 0.56 a pound and HDPE/LDPE film USD 0.12, a gap of USD 0.44, so 22,046.2 pounds save USD 9,700.33. In Colorado, laminates pay USD 0.78 and film USD 0.62, a gap of USD 0.16, worth USD 3,527.39. The 2026 Oregon and Colorado gaps use the 2026 schedules' cents per pound as printed: laminates 102.0 and film 43.0 cents in Oregon, 74.0 and 48.0 cents in Colorado.

The redesign value moves with the schedule. Oregon's laminate saving falls from USD 13,007.26 to USD 9,700.33 per 10 tonnes between 2026 and 2027 at final rates, but is higher than either at the 2027 base, USD 14,991.42. Colorado's falls from USD 5,732.01 to USD 3,527.39 because film rose faster than laminates. B.C.'s foam saving rises by CAD 2,900 because the foam line rose 31 cents and the thermoform line 2.

These figures hold weight constant, which real redesigns rarely do. A PET thermoform tray can weigh more than the foam tray it replaces, and a mono film may need more gauge than a laminate. **SPI analysis:**  the per-tonne gap is the right input for a design decision, but the business case needs the pack weights before and after, and the fee in each market where the pack is sold.

Foam has a regulatory side in two of the three markets. B.C.'s Single-Use and Plastic Waste Prevention Regulation, B.C. Reg. 254/2023, already bans foam food service ware, with foam trays for raw meat, poultry and fish exempt until 1 July 2030, and Oregon has banned foam food containers since 1 January 2025 under SB 543 ([PR-CA-005](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/canada/pr-ca-005/), [PR-US-013](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-013/)). SPI has not yet confirmed which foamed formats still report under Oregon's foam line.

## Small producers: three flat-fee doors

Each programme lets small producers pay a flat amount instead of reporting every material, and the doors are set differently (Exhibits 9 and 10). The useful number for a small producer is the implied rate: the flat fee divided by the tier's top tonnage, which shows the per-tonne level above which the flat fee is cheaper than per-material fees.

The implied rates tell a producer when to opt in. In Oregon in 2027, a mix whose per-material rate at final fees is above about USD 310 per ton at the top tier pays less on the flat fee; clear PET bottles at USD 418.88 per tonne and laminates at USD 1,234.59 are above it, corrugated at USD 44.09 is far below. In Colorado the line is about USD 410 per ton, against USD 220.46 for corrugated and USD 1,366.86 for PE film. In B.C., at the 2025 flat fee, it was about CAD 787 per tonne, against 2027 rates of CAD 630 for corrugated and CAD 1,740 for film.

Oregon's 2027 schedule adds that its tiers are also open to producers with more than USD 10 million of gross revenue, and states that the same tiers apply regardless of material. Colorado's 2027 tiers are optional for producers supplying 10 tons or less. Recycle BC's page describes the flat fee as a way to file a simplified report without detailed weighing, based on the packaging and paper supplied to B.C. residents.

SPI analysis

B.C.'s door is wider, running to 15,000 kg against 10 tons in the US states, but its published amounts are two years old. A small producer budgeting B.C. for 2027 should ask Recycle BC for the current flat fee before choosing between the routes.

## Industry reaction

> "In response to producer requests for details about annual changes to material fee rates, graphs have been developed to illustrate the factors driving changes from 2026 to 2027."

***Recycle BC** , producer responsibility organisation for British Columbia, [Cause of Change Graphs, 2027 Fee Rates](https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/21115210/2027CauseOfChange_FeeSchedule-RecycleBC.pdf), 21 October 2026*

The graphs are the feature neither CAA schedule has. CAA explains its 2027 Oregon rates in a short introduction and its reserve columns, but publishes no per-line breakdown of what moved each rate.

> "Fee rates will change annually."

***Oregon Department of Environmental Quality** , state regulator, [Producers of Covered Products](https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Pages/Producers-of-Covered-Products.aspx), consulted 3 November 2026*

DEQ's page ties the rates to supply data. It also sets the date that feeds the next schedule.

> "Beginning with May 31, 2026, supply data for the prior year are due to CAA on or before May 31 of each year."

***Oregon Department of Environmental Quality** , state regulator, [Producers of Covered Products](https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Pages/Producers-of-Covered-Products.aspx), consulted 3 November 2026*

On that pattern, 2025 supply data filed by 31 May 2026 set the 2027 rates, and 2026 data due by 31 May 2027 will feed the 2028 schedule.

> "Additionally, it creates incentives for companies to design packaging that is more recyclable and reusable."

***Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment** , state regulator, [Producer Responsibility Program](https://cdphe.colorado.gov/hm/epr-program), consulted 3 November 2026*

CDPHE's description matches the malus and bonus columns in CAA's 2027 Colorado table. SPI has not yet confirmed any public statement on the 2027 rates in any of the three markets from trade associations or municipalities.

## Scenarios: what the laminate and foam decisions could be worth in 2028

No 2028 schedule exists in any of the three markets. SPI ran two decisions through stated assumptions, one currency at a time and using only published rates: moving 50 tonnes of laminate pouches to mono PE film in the US states (Exhibit 11), and moving 50 tonnes of foam trays to PET thermoforms in B.C. (Exhibit 12), where the laminate change is worth nothing on the schedule.

**SPI calculation:**  the Oregon range is the reserve question in another form. The 2027 drawdown takes USD 0.41 a pound off laminates and USD 0.17 off film, so the gap between them shrinks from USD 0.68 at base to USD 0.44 at final rates. If the drawdown ends and base rates hold, the switch is worth USD 26,455.44 more on 50 tonnes than at 2027 final rates.

Colorado's range is narrower because its stack is small. A return to the 2026 gap is the high case because, in 2026, laminates were 26 cents dearer than film; in 2027 film rose 14 cents and laminates 4 cents. B.C.'s range rests on the foam line's two-year path, up from 310 cents in 2025 to 438 cents in 2027.

SPI analysis

The decision with the widest range is the Oregon laminate switch, and its value depends mostly on a reserve policy the producer cannot influence. A brand should make that decision on the 2027 base column, and treat any 2028 drawdown as a bonus.

## What leaders should do now

1. **Finance leads, by 30 November 2026:**  load all three 2027 schedules into budgets, each in its own currency, and plan cash for quarterly Recycle BC payments from 31 January 2027 and for 50% CAA invoices in January and July 2027 in both US states.
2. **FP&A teams, at the 2028 budget round:**  carry Oregon at the 2027 base column alongside the final column, because CAA's current Oregon plan runs to 2027 and the reserve return is not stated to recur.
3. **Packaging development teams, before 2027 briefs freeze:**  aim laminate-to-mono and colour changes at Oregon and Colorado, where the schedule pays for them, and foam exits at Colorado and B.C.; do not count a B.C. saving on laminates or PET colour.
4. **Compliance and data teams, by 31 May 2027:**  map B.C. thermoforms and kraft paper to their own lines and check each US pack's USCL, PRO, MRL or AML status, since status moves the base rate in both states.
5. **Small producers, before the first 2027 payment:**  compare the flat fee with per-material fees at your own mix, using implied rates of about USD 310 per ton in Oregon and USD 410 in Colorado at the top tier, and ask Recycle BC for its current flat fee.
6. **Sustainability teams, by the next bonus windows:**  gather evidence for Oregon's life cycle bonuses and Colorado's active incentives, the only parts of either US schedule that reward documented improvement beyond pack status.
7. **Legal and compliance, now:**  confirm with counsel which entity is the producer in each market, given B.C.'s residence test and the US producer cascades; this article gives business planning, not legal advice.

## Questions for your board

- What will we pay in 2027 in B.C., Oregon and Colorado, each in its own currency, and how much of the Oregon figure comes from the one-year reserve return?
- Which of our pack changes are rewarded by the schedule in each market, and which are worth nothing there?
- Have we priced redesigns at real pack weights, not only per tonne?
- Are our B.C. thermoforms, kraft paper and US list statuses reported on the right lines?
- Which of our entities would pay less on a flat fee?
- Who owns the evidence for Oregon's and Colorado's active bonuses?

## What to watch

- **31 Dec 2026:**  the 25 largest Oregon producers file their first life cycle impact evaluations ([PR-US-002](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-002/)).
- **Jan 2027:**  first CAA invoices for 2027, 50% of annual fees, in Oregon and Colorado.
- **31 Jan 2027:**  first quarterly Recycle BC payment date of 2027.
- **31 May 2027:**  Recycle BC producer reports due, and Oregon 2026 supply data due to CAA, which on DEQ's pattern feed 2028 rates.
- **Jul 2027:**  second CAA invoices for 2027 in both US states.
- **Oct 2027:**  CAA's 2028 Oregon and Colorado schedules would follow its 1 October pattern, and Recycle BC posts in the fourth quarter; SPI has not yet confirmed either date.
- **15 Apr 2028:**  next review of Recycle BC's stewardship plan under [PR-CA-004](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/canada/pr-ca-004/).

## Methodology

- **Data used:**  Recycle BC's 2027 Fee Schedule, Cause of Change Graphs and fee schedule page, and CAA's 2027 Oregon Fee Schedule and 2027 Colorado Dues Schedule, all consulted 3 November 2026; the DEQ and CDPHE programme pages, consulted 3 November 2026; Recycle BC's 2026 schedule and CAA's 2026 schedules as held in SPI's fee-market files for British Columbia, Oregon and Colorado (14 October 2026) and SPI's news report of 1 November 2026; SPI tracker records [PR-CA-004](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/canada/pr-ca-004/), [PR-US-002](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-002/) and [PR-US-003](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-states/pr-us-003/).
- **Counting rules:**  rates as published. Recycle BC cents per kg times ten give CAD per tonne. CAA US dollars per pound times 2,204.62 give USD per tonne, rounded to cents; 10 tonnes are 22,046.2 pounds. Redesign values hold pack weight constant.
- **Currencies:**  CAD and USD are kept in separate tables. Nothing is converted, added, averaged or ranked across currencies. Ratios in Exhibit 5 are taken inside one schedule and carry no currency.
- **Line counts:**  Recycle BC's 23 lines are as printed; Oregon's 60 categories are from CAA's 2025 to 2027 programme plan; Colorado's 61 rows are SPI's count of the 2027 table.
- **Scenarios:**  SPI assumptions applied to published rates, not forecasts by CAA or Recycle BC.
- **Cut-off:**  3 November 2026.
- **Limitations:**  SPI has not yet confirmed how CAA applies negative final rates on invoices, the 2027 value of active bonuses in either US state, Recycle BC's 2026 and 2027 flat fees, whether B.C.'s 2027 surplus factor reflects a smaller drawdown or reserve building, or the Colorado PET thermoform category used in Exhibit 8. This is not an invoice or a liability estimate; check obligations with each programme and with counsel.

## Sources

1. Recycle BC: 2027 Fee Schedule (21 October 2026), [https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/21115215/Recycle-BC-2027-Fee-Schedule.pdf](https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/21115215/Recycle-BC-2027-Fee-Schedule.pdf), consulted 2026-11-03.
2. Recycle BC: Cause of Change Graphs, 2027 Fee Rates (21 October 2026), [https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/21115210/2027CauseOfChange_FeeSchedule-RecycleBC.pdf](https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/21115210/2027CauseOfChange_FeeSchedule-RecycleBC.pdf), consulted 2026-11-03.
3. Recycle BC: Fee Schedule page (updated 21 October 2026), [https://recyclebc.ca/producers/reporting-fees/fee-schedule/](https://recyclebc.ca/producers/reporting-fees/fee-schedule/), consulted 2026-11-03.
4. Recycle BC: 2026 Fee Schedule (2025 Report to Producers), [https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/11123858/Recycle-BC-2026-Fee-Schedule.pdf](https://bc-webmedia-assets-prod-shared-ca-central-1.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/11123858/Recycle-BC-2026-Fee-Schedule.pdf), consulted 2026-11-01.
5. Circular Action Alliance: 2027 Oregon Fee Schedule (originally published 1 October 2026), [https://circularactionalliance.org/s/OR-2027FeeSchedule_100126.pdf](https://circularactionalliance.org/s/OR-2027FeeSchedule_100126.pdf), consulted 2026-11-03.
6. Circular Action Alliance: 2026 Oregon Producer Fee Schedule (originally published 29 October 2025), [https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64260ed078c36925b1cf3385/t/693b2c9103be112d168e1b19/1765485713621/OR+2026+Fee+Schedule+Public.pdf](https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64260ed078c36925b1cf3385/t/693b2c9103be112d168e1b19/1765485713621/OR+2026+Fee+Schedule+Public.pdf), consulted 2026-10-14.
7. Circular Action Alliance: 2027 Colorado Dues Schedule (originally published 1 October 2026), [https://circularactionalliance.org/s/CO-2027DuesSchedule_100126.pdf](https://circularactionalliance.org/s/CO-2027DuesSchedule_100126.pdf), consulted 2026-11-03.
8. Circular Action Alliance: 2026 Colorado Producer Dues Schedule (13 October 2025), [https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64260ed078c36925b1cf3385/t/693b45923163e42ba98d634f/1765492118120/CO+2026+Dues+Schedule+Public.pdf](https://static1.squarespace.com/static/64260ed078c36925b1cf3385/t/693b45923163e42ba98d634f/1765492118120/CO+2026+Dues+Schedule+Public.pdf), consulted 2026-10-14.
9. Oregon DEQ: Producers of Covered Products, [https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Pages/Producers-of-Covered-Products.aspx](https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Pages/Producers-of-Covered-Products.aspx), consulted 2026-11-03.
10. Oregon DEQ: Producer Obligations Summary, Recycling Modernization Act, [https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Documents/RMAProducerObligationsSummary.pdf](https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Documents/RMAProducerObligationsSummary.pdf), consulted 2026-10-14.
11. Circular Action Alliance: Oregon Program Plan 2025 to 2027, amended version (12 September 2025), [https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Documents/CAAamendOPPa1.pdf](https://www.oregon.gov/deq/recycling/Documents/CAAamendOPPa1.pdf), consulted 2026-10-14.
12. CDPHE: Producer Responsibility Program, [https://cdphe.colorado.gov/hm/epr-program](https://cdphe.colorado.gov/hm/epr-program), consulted 2026-11-03.
13. Colorado General Assembly: HB22-1355, signed act (C.R.S. 25-17-701 to 25-17-716), [https://content.leg.colorado.gov/sites/default/files/2022a_1355_signed.pdf](https://content.leg.colorado.gov/sites/default/files/2022a_1355_signed.pdf), consulted 2026-10-14.
14. BC Laws: Recycling Regulation, B.C. Reg. 449/2004, including Schedule 5, [https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/449_2004](https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/449_2004), consulted 2026-10-14.
15. B.C. Government: Recycle BC packaging and paper products plan (19 August 2025) and approval (17 September 2025), [https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/waste-management/recycling/recycle/residential-packaging-and-paper-recyclebc/recyclebc_plan_and_approval_2025.pdf](https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/waste-management/recycling/recycle/residential-packaging-and-paper-recyclebc/recyclebc_plan_and_approval_2025.pdf), consulted 2026-10-14.
16. Recycle BC: Producer FAQs, [https://recyclebc.ca/producers/resources/producer-faqs/](https://recyclebc.ca/producers/resources/producer-faqs/), consulted 2026-10-14.
17. SPI Regulation Tracker: PR-CA-004, PR-US-002 and PR-US-003, /data/packaging-regulation-tracker/canada/pr-ca-004/, record data as of 14 October 2026.
18. SPI fee-market files for British Columbia, Oregon and Colorado, SPI EPR & Plastic Tax Calculator, /data/epr-plastic-tax-calculator/, data as of 14 October 2026.
19. SPI News: Recycle BC fees 2027 raise 19 of 23 lines (1 November 2026), /news/recycle-bc-2027-fee-schedule/, consulted 2026-11-03.
20. SPI News: Canada EPR fees 2027, Manitoba and Saskatchewan (2 November 2026), /news/canada-epr-fees-2027-manitoba-saskatchewan/, consulted 2026-11-03.
21. SPI Ledger: Oregon and Colorado EPR fee schedules for 2026 and 2027, line by line, /insights/oregon-colorado-epr-fee-schedules-line-by-line/, consulted 2026-11-03.
22. SPI Ledger: Canada's packaging EPR, province by province, /insights/canada-packaging-epr-by-province/, consulted 2026-11-03.
23. SPI Ledger: US packaging EPR, state by state, /insights/us-state-packaging-epr/, consulted 2026-11-03.

