# Compostable packaging is mandatory for three EU formats from 2028, but most national rules treat compostable plastic as plastic

> From 12 February 2028 the PPWR requires permeable tea and coffee bags, soft single-serve pods and sticky labels on fruit and vegetables to be compostable, and lets Member States add non-metal pods and lightweight carrier bags; outside those formats, England and New Zealand give compostable plastic no exemption from their bans, India grants a conditional one, and France restricts what a compostable pack may claim.

Publisher: Strategic Packaging Insights  
Published: 2026-10-30  
Last updated: 2026-10-30  
Page: https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/compostable-packaging-ppwr-national-rules/

**From 12 February 2028 the PPWR requires permeable tea and coffee bags, soft single-serve pods and sticky labels on fruit and vegetables to be compostable, and lets Member States add non-metal pods and lightweight carrier bags; outside those formats, England and New Zealand give compostable plastic no exemption from their bans, India grants a conditional one, and France restricts what a compostable pack may claim.**

Strategic Packaging Insights (SPI) read Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2025/40, the Commission's June 2026 guidance and the rules in five national rulebooks and three fee schemes. The result is a short list of formats where compostable is the legal answer, a longer list where it is a fee or claims problem, and a set of bans where it changes nothing.

## Executive summary

Compostable packaging is often sold as a regulatory safe harbour. The rules SPI read say otherwise. The EU's Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) makes compostability compulsory for only three formats: permeable tea, coffee and other beverage bags, soft single-serve units that are thrown away with the used product, and sticky labels on fruit and vegetables. The Commission's guidance, published in the Official Journal on 10 June 2026, says such packaging must be designed for composting by 12 February 2028 (Exhibit 2).

Beyond those three, the PPWR leaves room for national choice and then closes it. Member States may require compostability for non-metal capsules and pods and for very lightweight and lightweight plastic carrier bags, where bio-waste collection can take them. All other packaging, biodegradable plastics included, must be designed for material recycling from 12 February 2028 (Article 9(3), in the unofficial German text SPI read).

National rules outside the EU go further in both directions. England's single-use plastic bans, in force since 1 October 2023, catch compostable plastic in full. New Zealand's July 2023 bans do the same, with one carve-out: produce labels, which must themselves be home compostable, adhesive included, by 1 July 2028. India is the one rulebook that uses compostability as an exit, both from the 1 July 2022 item ban (list (b) only) and from the 120 micron carry bag floor, on conditions of standard, certificate and label.

Fees and claims add a second layer. In Belgium, Fost Plus charges compostable tea bags, pads and fruit labels EUR 687.9 per tonne from 12 August 2026, against EUR 4,419 for non-compostable ones, but charges compostable capsules the same EUR 4,419 as non-recyclable plastic. In Italy, CONAI charges certified compostable capsules a temporary EUR 45 per tonne. France bans the word "compostable" on plastic that composts only in industrial units.

For leaders, three moves matter: map every pod, tea bag and fruit label to its Article 9 group now, because the 2028 date is fixed; stop using compostability as a way round bans in England and New Zealand; and price the compostable choice scheme by scheme, because the fee signal points in opposite directions in Belgium and Italy.

## Key findings

1. The PPWR requires compostability for three formats only: permeable beverage bags, soft after-use single-serve units and sticky labels on fruit and vegetables, by 12 February 2028 (Commission Notice C/2026/3084, 10 June 2026).
2. Member States may add non-metal capsules and pods and very lightweight and lightweight plastic carrier bags, and the guidance says added formats may only be industrially compostable; formats already required nationally had to be decided by 12 August 2026.
3. England (since 1 October 2023) and New Zealand (since 1 July 2023) give compostable plastic no exemption from their single-use bans, except New Zealand's produce labels, which must be fully home compostable, adhesive included, by 1 July 2028 (SI 2023/982; [PR-NZ-001](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/new-zealand/pr-nz-001/)).
4. India exempts compostable list (b) items from its 1 July 2022 ban and compostable carry bags from the 120 micron floor, if they meet IS/ISO 17088:2021, hold a CPCB certificate and carry a label saying they compost only industrially (G.S.R. 201(E), 14 March 2024).
5. **SPI calculation:**  in Belgium the compostable tea bag, pad and label line (EUR 687.9 per tonne) is 15.6% of the non-compostable line, while a compostable capsule pays 15.0% more than a plastic capsule in 2026 and 87.9% more in 2027.
6. In Italy, CONAI's general compostable plastic line rose 89.2% to EUR 246 per tonne on 1 July 2026, while certified compostable capsules and pods pay a temporary EUR 45 from 12 August 2026, 37.5% of the EUR 120 aluminium capsule line (CONAI fee table; CONAI, 2 July 2026).
7. France has banned "biodégradable" claims since 1 May 2022 and bars the "compostable" mention on plastic whose compostability needs an industrial unit; all compostable plastic must say "ne pas jeter dans la nature" (ministry FAQ, 18 October 2023).

## What Article 9 actually requires

Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 sorts packaging into four groups (Exhibit 2). The Regulation has applied since 12 August 2026 ([PR-EU-001](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/european-union/pr-eu-001/)), but the compostability duty in Article 9(1) bites 18 months later, on 12 February 2028.

Group A is narrower than it looks. The guidance reads Article 9(1) as "a material-neutral provision": it covers permeable bags of any material, paper included (Commission Notice, p. 17). A paper tea bag is in scope; so is a soft pad of filter material. A hard capsule made for a machine is not in group A at all. It sits in group B, where the decision belongs to each Member State, and a metal capsule is outside even that option.

Group B is where coffee capsules and carrier bags sit. Recital 54 gives Member States flexibility to decide on compostable packaging for beverage single-serve units, and Article 9(2) ties any national requirement to the existence of bio-waste collection that can take the item. The guidance adds a limit: Member States may only decide that additional formats are industrially compostable (Commission Notice, section 8, p. 16). Home compostability may be mandated only for the limited group A items, under local conditions and supervision.

Group C protects existing national rules. Several EU states required compostable carrier bags or fruit bags before the PPWR, and the guidance asks Member States to publish explicit lists of such items and tell operators, the public and the Commission. SPI has not yet confirmed which Member States notified lists by the 12 August 2026 cut-off.

Group D is the default and the trap. A pack that is compostable but not in groups A to C must still be designed for material recycling from 12 February 2028. On the unofficial German text, the paragraph names biodegradable plastics expressly ("einschließlich Verpackungen aus biologisch abbaubaren Kunststoffen").

SPI analysis

For most packaging, the PPWR turns compostability from a design choice into a compliance risk. A compostable film tray, pouch or clamshell that cannot be recycled will fail the Article 9(3) test in 2028 unless a Member State listed it under group C. The [PPWR recyclability and format rules](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/ppwr-2030-format-restrictions/) then apply in full.

### The standard question

The Regulation asks for harmonised standards that do not yet exist in a form that gives a presumption of conformity. The Commission was to ask the European standardisation bodies for a new EU-wide home composting standard by 12 February 2026 under Article 9(6), and the guidance says presumption of conformity for compostable packaging will return only once a new decision lists the standards in the Official Journal (Commission Notice, p. 16).

Until then, EN 13432, the existing European standard for packaging recoverable through industrial composting, is the reference point the Commission names. SPI makes no assessment of any product against it. The guidance also says that existing national home composting standards and certification schemes do not create a presumption of conformity, so a pack labelled to a national home compost scheme gains no automatic EU status from it.

The labelling side, including Article 12's requirement that compostable packaging state whether it suits home composting and that it must not be discarded in nature, is covered in the [PPWR labelling piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/ppwr-labelling-harmonised-material-label-digital-marking/).

### What compostable status does not buy under the PPWR

Two exemptions travel with compostable plastic. SPI's tracker records that the EUR-Lex summary lists compostable plastics among the packaging exempt from the Article 7 recycled content targets, with pharmaceutical, medical device, infant food and dangerous goods packaging ([PR-EU-005](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/european-union/pr-eu-005/)). And the Article 9(1) formats are expected to go to bio-waste, not to recycling streams.

That is the full list SPI found. Compostable status does not exempt a pack from minimisation, substance limits or EPR fees, and it does not override a Member State's decision not to use the Article 9(2) option.

## The calendar: most of the national rules are already in force

The PPWR's 2028 date is the late arrival in a calendar that started in 2021 (Exhibit 3). Every non-EU rule in this piece is already live, and two EU fee schemes changed their compostable lines in the summer of 2026.

## A framework: four treatments and a claims overlay

Across the rules in this piece, compostable packaging gets one of four legal treatments, with a fifth layer, claims, on top (Exhibit 4). SPI groups them by what the rule does to a compostable pack, not by what it says about plastic in general.

**Treatment 1, required.**  This is the smallest group. In the EU it is three formats from 2028. In New Zealand, produce labels must be home compostable, the one item the July 2023 bans let through in compostable form. In France, the ban on glued fruit labels that are not compostable has applied since 2022 ([PR-FR-002](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/france/pr-fr-002/)). SPI has not yet confirmed whether the French label rule requires home compostability against the Code text.

**Treatment 2, optional.**  Under the PPWR, capsules and carrier bags are a national choice. A coffee brand selling in all 27 Member States may face a compostable requirement in some, nothing in others, and the Article 9(3) recyclability test wherever no requirement applies.

**Treatment 3, conditional exception.**  India is the clearest case. Rule 4(3) of the Plastic Waste Management Rules exempts list (b) items made of compostable plastic, such as plates, cups and cutlery, from the 1 July 2022 ban, and G.S.R. 201(E) took compostable carry bags out of the thickness floor ([PR-IN-004](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/india/pr-in-004/)). The [India piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/india-single-use-plastic-ban-carry-bag-thickness/) sets out the list item by item.

**Treatment 4, no exemption.**  England and New Zealand define plastic by material, so a compostable fork is still a plastic fork. The same holds for India's list (a), which has no compostable exception ([PR-IN-004](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/india/pr-in-004/)).

**The claims overlay.**  France, India and the PPWR each control the words on a compostable pack, and they do not say the same thing (Exhibit 9).

SPI analysis

Treatments 1 and 4 can apply to the same company at once. A fresh produce supplier selling in New Zealand must use home compostable labels while its compostable plastic produce bags are banned outright. A specification that says "compostable" without naming the market and the item does not tell a converter what is allowed.

## Carrier bags: an EU option that meets older national rules

Carrier bags show how the optional and grandfathered groups work together. Under Article 9(2)(a), a Member State may require very lightweight and lightweight plastic carrier bags to be compostable where its bio-waste collection can take them (Commission Notice, p. 15). A state that already required compostable bags before 12 August 2026 can keep that rule under Article 9(2)(b), provided it publishes the list the guidance asks for.

France shows the link between bags and bio-waste collection. Its order of 15 March 2022 lists the waste that may be collected with sorted bio-waste, and the government told the Senate in November 2022 that the order admits compostable plastic packaging only in the form of fruit and vegetable bags that are compostable in home composting (Sénat, answer of 10 November 2022). In March 2023 the ecology ministry said the order already matched the ANSES findings because it limits compostable plastics to collection bags, and that no change was planned before the PPWR negotiations ended (Assemblée nationale, answer of 7 March 2023).

India treats bags through thickness, not composting. Since 14 March 2024, the thickness floor under rule 4(1)(c) does not apply to carry bags made of compostable or biodegradable plastic, and compostable carry bags must conform to IS/ISO 17088:2021 (G.S.R. 201(E), rule 4(1)(h)). The bag is allowed, but only with a standard, a certificate and a label.

SPI analysis

A retailer with one bag specification for the EU, France and India needs three answers. In an EU state that has not used the option, a compostable bag has no special status and must meet Article 9(3) from 2028. In France, the home compostable fruit and vegetable bag is the one compostable plastic format the bio-waste system accepts. In India, the compostable bag escapes the 120 micron floor only on conditions.

## Fees: the same compostable pack is cheap in one scheme and dear in the next

EPR fees put a price on each treatment, and the schemes SPI read do not agree (Exhibit 5). All rates are euro per tonne, excluding VAT, as published, and comparisons stay inside one scheme. The cross-scheme fee picture for conventional materials is in the [EPR fees per tonne piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/epr-fees-per-tonne-2026/).

Read Belgium first. Fost Plus has split the three PPWR Article 9(1) formats into their own lines, and in each the compostable version pays EUR 687.9 per tonne in 2026 and EUR 688.0 in 2027, against EUR 4,419 for the non-compostable version. Everything else compostable, from capsules to trays, is treated as obstructive. The 2026 rates document lists code 014-02, "Compostable and biodegradable plastic packaging", at EUR 4.4190 per kg, with a footnote that excludes only beverage bags, soft pads and sticky labels, and it names biodegradable and compostable plastic packaging among the obstructive items that need a detailed declaration (Fost Plus Green Dot rates 2026).

Italy reads the other way. CONAI raised its general compostable plastic line from EUR 130 to EUR 246 per tonne on 1 July 2026, which by SPI's calculation is an 89.2% increase, but that is still below every household plastic band from B1.1 (EUR 260 from 1 October 2026) upward (CONAI fee table). For certified compostable capsules and pods it set a temporary EUR 45 per tonne from 12 August 2026, citing the new European rules that bring such items, discarded with their coffee residue, into the definition of packaging (CONAI, 2 July 2026).

Austria sits between them. ARA's 2026 sheet prices household biodegradable materials at EUR 0.550 per kg, 52.9% of its EUR 1.040 household plastic line, and commercial biodegradable materials at EUR 0.100 per kg (ARA tariff rates 2026).

SPI analysis

The fee signal follows Article 9's grouping in Belgium and runs against it in Italy. Fost Plus rewards compostability only where the PPWR requires it, the group A formats, and charges every other compostable pack as if it were unrecyclable. CONAI rewards compostable capsules, a group B format that Italy may or may not require. A coffee brand that chose one capsule material for both markets would see opposite fee effects.

In practice: Fost Plus.

Fost Plus publishes its capsule, pad and label lines under a heading that says their rates take effect from 12 August 2026, the PPWR application date (Fost Plus rates page, consulted 30 October 2026). The same page states that the Green Dot logo may no longer be used on packaging from 12 February 2027. Its 2027 column cuts the plastic capsule line by 38.8% and the aluminium capsule line by 13.0%, by SPI's calculation, while the compostable capsule line stays at EUR 4,419. The [Benelux fees piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/benelux-packaging-fees-fost-plus-valorlux/) covers the rest of the table.

In practice: CONAI and Biorepack.

CONAI's board set the July 2026 increase after consulting Biorepack, the consortium for compostable bioplastic, noting that the contribution had been more than halved in the previous three years and that it aims to balance income and costs while keeping adequate reserves (CONAI, 30 October 2025). Italy recycled more than 44,000 tonnes of compostable bioplastic in 2025, reported alongside 1,161,000 tonnes of conventional plastic (CONAI, 16 July 2026). The [CONAI fee bands piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/italy-conai-fee-bands-explained/) explains the plastic bands.

In practice: ARA.

ARA keeps biodegradable materials as their own line in both its household and commercial tables for 2026, at EUR 0.550 and EUR 0.100 per kg, rather than folding them into plastic (ARA tariff rates 2026). SPI has not yet confirmed which composting or recycling route ARA uses for the tonnage declared on those lines.

## Capsules: the format where the rules diverge most

Capsules and pods show every layer at once: an optional PPWR format, two opposite fee signals and a scheme rate that is still moving (Exhibit 7).

**SPI calculation:**  in Belgium, 100 tonnes of compostable capsules cost 100,000 kg x EUR 4.4190 = EUR 441,900 in both years. In plastic they cost EUR 384,140 in 2026 and EUR 235,190 in 2027, so the compostable premium grows from EUR 57,760 to EUR 206,710. Against aluminium the premium grows from EUR 86,650 to EUR 132,800.

In Italy, the same 100 tonnes cost EUR 4,500 compostable, EUR 12,000 in aluminium and EUR 91,700 at Band B2.3. Italy's rates are a small fraction of Belgium's for every line, which reflects scheme design and cost recovery, not a comparison SPI draws between the two.

The PPWR overlay matters here. A non-metal capsule sits in group B: if Italy or Belgium required it to be compostable, the compostable version would be the only legal choice for that format in that market, whatever the fee. If neither does, the capsule falls under Article 9(3) and must be designed for recycling by February 2028. SPI has not yet confirmed whether Italy or Belgium has used the Article 9(2) option for capsules. An aluminium capsule is outside the option in every Member State.

## Scenario: what happens when CONAI's temporary rate ends

CONAI's EUR 45 line is explicitly temporary. CONAI says the value will be monitored for at least twelve months and then reviewed on the evidence collected (CONAI, 2 July 2026). Exhibit 8 runs a 100-tonne capsule volume through three outcomes.

**SPI calculation:**  even the high case leaves a compostable capsule at 26.8% of the Band B2.3 rate (EUR 246 against EUR 917). The fee case for compostable capsules in Italy survives any of the three outcomes; what it does not survive is a pack that fails certification, since the EUR 45 line applies only to capsules and pods certified to EN 13432 (CONAI, 2 July 2026).

SPI analysis

For Belgium the fee lever runs the other way and is already published. A brand with 100 tonnes of compostable capsules in Belgium that moved them to plastic for 2027 would cut the fee by EUR 206,710, but would then need a recyclable plastic capsule by February 2028 under Article 9(3), unless Belgium uses the Article 9(2) option.

## Claims: what a compostable pack may say

A pack can be compliant in material and still fail on its words. Exhibit 9 sets the claims rules side by side.

France is the strictest. The ministry's FAQ on the decree under article 13 of the AGEC law says the ban on "biodégradable", "respectueux de l'environnement" and equivalent mentions has applied since 1 May 2022, and from 1 January 2023 for products made or imported before 30 April 2022. It reads article L. 541-9-1 of the Code de l'environnement as barring the "compostable" mention on plastic products and packaging whose compostability can only be obtained in an industrial unit, and as requiring all compostable plastic, home or industrial, to carry "ne pas jeter dans la nature" (ministry FAQ, version of 18 October 2023).

France's reasoning is set out in two government answers. In November 2022 the Secretary of State for ecology told the Senate that plastics meant for industrial composting offer no environmental benefit except in rare cases, and that the 15 March 2022 order admits only home compostable fruit and vegetable bags into bio-waste collection (Sénat, answer of 10 November 2022). In March 2023 the ecology ministry answered the Assemblée nationale that ANSES recommends not putting plastics in home composters (Assemblée nationale, answer of 7 March 2023).

The French rule may yet move. During the first reading of the bill adapting French law to EU law, a Senate amendment to keep the AGEC wording on "biodégradable" claims while transposing Directive (EU) 2024/825 was rejected at the sitting of 11 February 2026 (Sénat, amendment n° 117). SPI has not yet confirmed the final wording of article L. 541-9-1 after that bill.

India runs the opposite logic. Rule 11(3), as substituted by G.S.R. 201(E), requires compostable plastic packaging and articles to carry a label that they are compostable only under industrial composting, in conformity with IS/ISO 17088:2021, and rule 11(4) requires biodegradable items to state the days needed to degrade and the environment, in SPI's translation of the Hindi text. France forbids the claim an Indian label must make.

SPI analysis

A single global compostable claim is not possible for an industrially compostable plastic pack sold in both France and India. Artwork needs a market-specific panel, and the EU-wide Article 12 label will sit on top of the French rules once the labelling act applies.

## Bans: where compostable changes nothing

The no-exemption group is where compostable alternatives are most often misread. Exhibit 10 compares the four bans SPI holds.

England's regulation 2 defines plastic as a polymer material under the REACH definition, "with the exception of natural polymers that have not been chemically modified" (SI 2023/982, made 7 September 2023, in force 1 October 2023). Trading Standards guidance says the ban covers all types of single-use plastic, including biodegradable, compostable and recycled (Isle of Wight Council). The [England and Wales piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/england-wales-single-use-plastic-bans-packaging/) covers the items and the packaging test.

New Zealand's guidance says plastic includes bio-based or compostable plastics for the single-use criteria, and that tableware made wholly or mainly of any plastic, compostable included, is banned, while plastic-lined paper, bamboo or sugarcane pulp items are not (MfE, July 2023). The [New Zealand piece](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/insights/new-zealand-packaging-rules-product-stewardship/) covers the wider rulebook, including the cost of the label switch.

India's list (b) exception is the only route SPI found where a compostable plastic version of a banned item may be sold. G.S.R. 201(E) adds conditions: manufacturers of compostable or biodegradable items must obtain a CPCB certificate before marketing, report quantities placed on the market and pre-consumer waste to the CPCB, and register on the CPCB portal as EPR-obligated entities under Schedule II (G.S.R. 201(E), Hindi text, SPI translation).

SPI analysis

For food service and retail packaging, compostable plastic is a substitute in India and in the EU group A formats, and nowhere else in this set. In England and New Zealand the realistic routes out of a ban are unmodified natural materials, fibre without plastic content, or reuse.

## Industry reaction

> "Member States may only decide that such additional compostable packaging formats are industrially compostable."

***European Commission** , guidance on Regulation (EU) 2025/40, [Commission Notice C/2026/3084](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52026XC03084), OJ C, 10 June 2026*

The same guidance says the existing EN 13432 standard on industrial composting can serve as guidance until the new standard is adopted, that existing national home composting standards and certification schemes do not give a presumption of conformity, and that presumption returns only when a new decision lists harmonised standards in the Official Journal.

> "There are no exemptions to the ban on single-use plastic produce bags."

***Ministry for the Environment** , New Zealand, [Guidance on single-use plastic products banned or phased out from July 2023](https://environment.govt.nz/publications/plastic-products-banned-from-july-2023/), July 2023*

The Ministry says the produce bag ban covers bags made of recyclable, biodegradable, plant-based or compostable plastic.

> "Il valore del CAC introdotto avrà carattere temporaneo, con monitoraggio di almeno dodici mesi, al termine del quale sarà rivalutato sulla base delle evidenze raccolte."

***CONAI** , Italian national packaging consortium, [new contribution for compostable bioplastic capsules and pods](https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/conai-variazioni-del-contributo-ambientale-per-gli-imballaggi-in-legno-e-in-vetro-nuovo-contributo-per-capsule-e-cialde-in-bioplastica-compostabile/), 2 July 2026*

In English, CONAI says the new value is temporary, will be monitored for at least twelve months and will then be reassessed on the evidence collected. It links the new line to the European rules that bring capsules and pods discarded with their coffee residue inside the definition of packaging.

## What leaders should do now

1. **Packaging development leads, by 31 March 2027:**  map every tea bag, soft pod, capsule and fruit label against the four Article 9 groups in Exhibit 2, and schedule redesigns of group A items well ahead of 12 February 2028.
2. **Regulatory affairs teams, by 31 December 2026:**  collect each Member State's published Article 9(2) list and decision on capsules and carrier bags, and record where none has been published.
3. **Food service and retail buyers, now:**  remove compostable plastic from England and New Zealand ranges where it is used to escape a ban, and switch to unmodified natural materials, unlined fibre or reuse.
4. **Finance and procurement, before 2027 budgets close:**  price capsules and other compostable lines in each scheme's own table, using Fost Plus's 2027 column and an Italian sensitivity on the EUR 45 line (Exhibit 8).
5. **Marketing and artwork teams, by the next print run:**  build market-specific claims panels for France, India and New Zealand, and keep "biodégradable" off any pack sold in France.
6. **Suppliers to India, before the next CPCB reporting cycle:**  hold the IS/ISO 17088:2021 evidence and CPCB certificate for each compostable list (b) item and carry bag, and register on the CPCB portal where Schedule II applies. Check with counsel where it applies.
7. **Boards and investors, at the next portfolio review:**  ask for a list of products whose compliance depends on compostability, by market, and for the fee effect of the 2027 Belgian rates.

## Questions for your board

- Which of our products rely on a compostable claim or material to stay on sale, and in which markets?
- Are any of our compostable packs outside the PPWR Article 9(1) formats, and if so, are they recyclable by February 2028?
- What do our capsules cost in EPR fees in Belgium and Italy in 2027, in each scheme's own table?
- Do we sell compostable plastic items in England or New Zealand that their bans already cover?
- Is our French artwork free of "biodégradable" and of "compostable" on industrial-only plastic?
- Who tracks Member State decisions under Article 9(2), and when did we last update them?

## What to watch

- **31 Dec 2026:**  SPI expects more Member States to publish their Article 9(2) lists; the guidance asks for explicit published lists, and SPI has not yet confirmed how many exist ([PR-EU-001](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/european-union/pr-eu-001/)).
- **1 Jan 2027:**  Fost Plus 2027 rates apply: plastic capsules EUR 2,351.9 and aluminium capsules EUR 3,091.0 per tonne, compostable capsules unchanged at EUR 4,419.
- **12 Aug 2027:**  the earliest end of CONAI's twelve-month monitoring of the EUR 45 compostable capsule line, on SPI's reading of the 2 July 2026 release.
- **12 Feb 2028:**  PPWR Article 9(1) formats must be compostable, and other packaging, biodegradable plastics included, must be designed for recycling under Article 9(3).
- **1 Jul 2028:**  New Zealand produce labels and their adhesive must be certified home compostable ([PR-NZ-001](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/new-zealand/pr-nz-001/)).
- **Oct 2028:**  the latest date for the first five-yearly review of England's SI 2023/982 ([PR-GB-006](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-kingdom/pr-gb-006/)).

## Methodology

- **Data used:**  Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 as described and partly quoted in Commission Notice C/2026/3084 (sections 8 and 9), with the German text as reproduced by LX Gesetze, an unofficial reproduction, for Article 9(3) and the evidence duty; the Official Journal recitals; SPI tracker records [PR-EU-001](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/european-union/pr-eu-001/), [PR-EU-005](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/european-union/pr-eu-005/), [PR-FR-002](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/france/pr-fr-002/), [PR-NZ-001](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/new-zealand/pr-nz-001/), [PR-IN-004](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/india/pr-in-004/) and [PR-GB-006](https://www.strategicpackaginginsights.com/data/packaging-regulation-tracker/united-kingdom/pr-gb-006/) and SPI fee-market notes for Italy and Belgium; and each scheme's or government's own page, consulted 30 October 2026.
- **Counting rules:**  fees as published, excluding VAT, per kg x1,000; ratios and totals only inside one scheme; no currency conversion. The 100-tonne volumes are SPI assumptions.
- **Framework:**  the four treatments and claims overlay in Exhibit 4 are SPI's grouping of what each rule does to a compostable pack.
- **Scenarios:**  Exhibit 8's base and high cases are SPI assumptions, not CONAI proposals.
- **Cut-off:**  30 October 2026.
- **Limitations:**  points resting on the unofficial Article 9 text, the French label rule's home composting requirement, the French ban's treatment of compostable versions, Member State Article 9(2) decisions and the Italian band for plastic capsules (taken from SPI Ledger 18) are marked as not yet confirmed. Indian rule 11 and Schedule II wording is SPI's translation of the Hindi text. SPI does not test or certify packaging, and nothing here is an assessment of any product against EN 13432 or any other standard. This is not legal advice; check with counsel where it applies.

## Sources

1. EUR-Lex, Commission Notice C/2026/3084, Guidance document for Regulation (EU) 2025/40 on packaging and packaging waste, OJ C, 10.6.2026, [https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52026XC03084](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52026XC03084), consulted 2026-10-30.
2. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2025/40 on packaging and packaging waste, OJ L 22.1.2025, recitals, [https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202500040](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:L_202500040), consulted 2026-10-30.
3. LX Gesetze, Art. 9 PPWR, Kompostierbare Verpackungen, German text of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 as reproduced, [https://lxgesetze.de/ppwr/9](https://lxgesetze.de/ppwr/9), consulted 2026-10-30.
4. CONAI, EPR fee (Contributo Ambientale CONAI), value table 2026, [https://www.conai.org/en/companies/services-for-managing-consortium-obligations-and-business-opportunities/epr-fee/](https://www.conai.org/en/companies/services-for-managing-consortium-obligations-and-business-opportunities/epr-fee/), consulted 2026-10-30.
5. CONAI, variazioni del Contributo Ambientale per gli imballaggi in legno e in vetro; nuovo contributo per capsule e cialde in bioplastica compostabile, 2 July 2026, [https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/conai-variazioni-del-contributo-ambientale-per-gli-imballaggi-in-legno-e-in-vetro-nuovo-contributo-per-capsule-e-cialde-in-bioplastica-compostabile/](https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/conai-variazioni-del-contributo-ambientale-per-gli-imballaggi-in-legno-e-in-vetro-nuovo-contributo-per-capsule-e-cialde-in-bioplastica-compostabile/), consulted 2026-10-30.
6. CONAI, rimodulato il Contributo Ambientale CONAI per gli imballaggi in bioplastica compostabile, 30 October 2025, [https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/rimodulato-il-contributo-ambientale-conai-per-gli-imballaggi-in-bioplastica-compostabile-aggiornate-anche-le-liste-degli-imballaggi-in-plastica-nelle-fasce-contributive/](https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/rimodulato-il-contributo-ambientale-conai-per-gli-imballaggi-in-bioplastica-compostabile-aggiornate-anche-le-liste-degli-imballaggi-in-plastica-nelle-fasce-contributive/), consulted 2026-10-30.
7. CONAI, L'Italia supera il 77% di riciclo degli imballaggi, 16 July 2026, [https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/litalia-supera-il-77-di-riciclo-degli-imballaggi/](https://www.conai.org/news-e-press/litalia-supera-il-77-di-riciclo-degli-imballaggi/), consulted 2026-10-30.
8. Fost Plus, Packaging EPR rates (2026 and 2027), [https://www.fostplus.be/en/members/green-dot-rates](https://www.fostplus.be/en/members/green-dot-rates), consulted 2026-10-30.
9. Fost Plus, Green Dot rates 2026 per material, [https://www.fostplus.be/en/media/1930/download](https://www.fostplus.be/en/media/1930/download), consulted 2026-10-30.
10. ARA, tariff rates 2026, [https://ara.at/uploads/Dokumente/Tarifbl%C3%A4tter/ARA-tariff-rates-2026.pdf](https://ara.at/uploads/Dokumente/Tarifbl%C3%A4tter/ARA-tariff-rates-2026.pdf), consulted 2026-10-30.
11. French Ministry of Ecological Transition, FAQ on the decree on consumer information on the environmental qualities of waste-generating products (AGEC article 13), version of 18 October 2023, [https://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/sites/default/files/documents/FAQ-020123v2.pdf](https://www.ecologie.gouv.fr/sites/default/files/documents/FAQ-020123v2.pdf), consulted 2026-10-30.
12. Assemblée nationale, written question n° 5053 and answer of the ecology ministry, JO 7 March 2023, [https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/16/questions/QANR5L16QE5053.pdf](https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/16/questions/QANR5L16QE5053.pdf), consulted 2026-10-30.
13. Sénat, written question n° 01867 and answer, JO Sénat 10 November 2022, [https://www.senat.fr/questions/base/2022/qSEQ220701867.html](https://www.senat.fr/questions/base/2022/qSEQ220701867.html), consulted 2026-10-30.
14. Sénat, amendment n° 117 to the bill adapting French law to EU law, sitting of 11 February 2026, [https://www.senat.fr/enseance/2025-2026/348/Amdt_117.html](https://www.senat.fr/enseance/2025-2026/348/Amdt_117.html), consulted 2026-10-30.
15. Ministry for the Environment (New Zealand), Guidance on single-use plastic products banned or phased out from July 2023, [https://environment.govt.nz/publications/plastic-products-banned-from-july-2023/](https://environment.govt.nz/publications/plastic-products-banned-from-july-2023/), consulted 2026-10-30.
16. MoEFCC (India), G.S.R. 201(E), Plastic Waste Management (Amendment) Rules, 2024, 14 March 2024, [https://moef.gov.in/storage/tender/GSR201(E)-[14032024]-Plastic-Waste-Mangement-Rules-2024.pdf](https://moef.gov.in/storage/tender/GSR201(E)-[14032024]-Plastic-Waste-Mangement-Rules-2024.pdf), consulted 2026-10-30.
17. legislation.gov.uk, SI 2023/982, Environmental Protection (Plastic Plates etc. and Polystyrene Containers etc.) (England) Regulations 2023, as made, [https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2023/982/made](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2023/982/made), consulted 2026-10-30.
18. Isle of Wight Council Trading Standards, single-use plastics business advice, [https://www.iow.gov.uk/business-and-consumer/trading-standards-service/business-advice/single-use-plastics/](https://www.iow.gov.uk/business-and-consumer/trading-standards-service/business-advice/single-use-plastics/), consulted 2026-10-30.
19. SPI Packaging Regulation Tracker, PR-EU-001, PR-EU-005, PR-FR-002, PR-NZ-001, PR-IN-004 and PR-GB-006, and SPI fee-market notes for Italy and Belgium, /data/packaging-regulation-tracker/, consulted 2026-10-30.
20. SPI Ledger, Italy's CONAI fee bands explained, /insights/italy-conai-fee-bands-explained/, consulted 2026-10-30.

